3 ms·
Condo fees go to a small body controlled by people who pay the tax. Property taxes go to a very much larger body which includes all sorts of people who, for wh
by sandworm101 7y ago
Condo fees go to a small body controlled by people who pay the tax. Property taxes go to a very much larger body which includes all sorts of people who, for whatever reason, don't necessarily pay the tax directly.
That inclusivity on the basis of legal status, citizenship rather than asset ownership/wealth, is the difference between civil government and a private club requiring buy-in. The requirement to own property in order to participate in government was abandoned long ago, with good cause. That system was horrible.
- cl42 7y agoI just want to say that this is extremely eloquent and well-written. I aspire to write like this. I also agree with you.
- wutbrodo 7y agoThank you for the thoughtful answer! I'm not sure I understand. I have a friend renting a condo from its owners, which I gather isn't an unheard-of occurrence. Given that she's not paying the "property taxes" (HOA fees) and not a member of the direct democracy "government" (the HOA), is she any different from someone living in this development who rents from an owner?
- gtfoutttt 7y agoThey pay the HOA, it's just built into their rent. Most property owners and landlords don't tend to overlook stuff like that.
- wutbrodo 7y agoYes, I know. That's the case for my friend, and I don't think anyone would suggest that her situation is horribly undemocratic. The parent comment's claim, as I understood it, is that this is horribly undemocratic because my renter friend is not directly a member of and represented by the HOA, as those rights are proxied through her landlord. My point is that I don't see how that differs from this proposed development: either you own, and are represented by the HOA-equivalent, or you rent, and are in the same position as any renter of a condo.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pseudalopex 7y agoIt sounds like they would suggest your friend's situation is horribly undemocratic.
- wutbrodo 7y agoSure, but that brings me back to my original question: people's reaction to "Google wants to charge property taxes" has been nowhere near their reaction to "condominiums exist". I'm hoping to get an answer to my question that isn't simply "people are stupid and react based on buzzwords instead of a basic understanding of what they're talking about".