3 ms·
Just as their opponents use their own confirmation bias to "prove" them wrong. Politics in the UK and US and is clearly far more polarised and far more extremi
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
Just as their opponents use their own confirmation bias to "prove" them wrong.
Politics in the UK and US and is clearly far more polarised and far more extremist in tone - especially on the right - than was the case ten years ago.
The Brexit nationalist nonsense in the UK was almost unthinkable in 2010. It was literally considered fringe lunacy. A senior politician on the right literally called the people in favour of it "swivel-eyed loons."
Now it's mainstream policy, with huge popular support - balanced against a slightly larger segment of the population who still consider it self-harming folly.
That's your instability right there. You can Google any number of people on both sides saying that they cannot remember a time when the country was this polarised, and an utter absence of anyone saying the opposite.
This is not normal. If you want to claim it is, prove it.
- JackFr 7y agoIn the U.K. I’d point to the General Strike of 1926 as a time when people were more polarized and I might add substantially prone to more political violence. Yes, it was nearly a century ago, but we’re often subject to recent bias wheN we think the current time is special. In the U.S. when someone points out that we've never been more polarized, it’s always easy to point out that a couple million men took up arms against each other during the civil war. But more recently between 1965 and 1968 there were riots in a dozen U.S. cities including N.Y., Chicago, L.A., Detroit, Newark , Baltimore and Washington which required use of the National Guard or army to restore order. We see nothing like that today.
- mistermann 7y agoAnd for good reason: https://www.historyplace.com/unitedstates/vietnam/index-1965.html https://www.historyplace.com/unitedstates/vietnam/index-1965... https://learninglab.si.edu/collections/martin-luther-king-jr-the-later-years-1965-1968/uyGek3MpmmPtXC6J https://learninglab.si.edu/collections/martin-luther-king-jr... > We see nothing like that today. True, but knowing why that is the case is hard to do. Are modern day Americans more supportive of military adventures in far away lands that kill thousands of innocent people, or is it that we hardly see anything about it on the news, especially images of dead bodies? Similarly, are Americans now satisfied with the level of equality and justice currently enjoyed by the African American community, or are they occupied by other distractions? Riots in the streets seem to have been largely replaced by arguments in internet forums, particularly Reddit, where you will find not only large amounts of "unrest", but also a significant amount of mental illness - people who have completely lost touch with reality.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- friendlybus 7y agoIt's frustating bringing a new idea to the Brits and have it be claimed that nothing new in the world truly exists, it has always been done before in one form or the other. The brits invented it first anyway. And then encounter your line of thinking where an event less damaging than the battle of the somme, or the great fire of 1666 is somehow exempt from the normality of history. I dont think HN is the appropriate place to discuss polticial demands on what is 'normal'.