8 ms·
Privately run and privately funded schools seem to do the job, but only for people who can afford them. Perhaps the solution is not to abolish public schooling
by swombat 18y ago
Privately run and privately funded schools seem to do the job, but only for people who can afford them.
Perhaps the solution is not to abolish public schooling altogether, but to work on actually improving it. Perhaps improving the quality of teachers would do the job better.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoIt's not obvious to me that improving teacher quality is possible. Is there really a large enough pool of people out there who would be good teachers, but choose not to teach? I know it's a popular talking point by teachers unions angling for more money, but I don't think it's really a solution. Improving the process also matters, and we even know how to do it (Direct Instruction). It is effective even when used by low quality teachers. Unfortunately, it's also dead in the water since teachers unions don't like it. http://www.projectpro.com/ICR/Research/DI/Summary.htm http://www.projectpro.com/ICR/Research/DI/Summary.htm http://www.mathematicallycorrect.com/honestft.htm http://www.mathematicallycorrect.com/honestft.htm
- swombat 18y agoWell, as an example of how you might go about doing that, I remember reading an article about a study that found that bad teachers don't get better with time, but they tend to cling on anyway because they get significantly more money each year. One of the suggestions from that article was that to improve teaching quality, it might be worth offering a flat (higher than the current 1st-year and lower than the current 10th-year) salary to encourage people to try teaching for a couple of years after uni (since the salary would then be decent right away). This would also discourage people from clinging on to the job unless they really like it. This is certainly not a solution that teachers' unions would advocate, but I suspect it could produce some positive effects, assuming the study I mentioned was correct, and assuming part of the problem is indeed the fact that many people who could be great teachers don't bother because they pay is very bad at the beginning and they can go and be bankers instead. Of course I'm not an expert on this, so my theories may be wide off the mark, but I don't accept the idea that the pool of existing teachers can't be improved. I suspect that one of the reasons why private schools are indeed better than public schools is precisely that they can afford better teachers. As for teachers' unions... I have little respect for a professional organisation that works against its own professional aim. I'm sure they can be taken care of in some way or another.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoI'm not sure that altering salaries alone will do much of anything. Now there is an incentive for young people to teach, and it might save money, but there is no incentive for good teachers to teach. My main objection to the idea of "hire better teachers" is that I don't think the people who would "go and be bankers" would necessarily be good teachers. It's a completely different skill set. I'm a good programmer and researcher, but I'm an adequate teacher at best. There isn't much benefit in attracting me to teaching. Also, teacher pay is actually quite good when include benefits, tenure, multiply by (12 months per year/9 months of work) and add in the value of 3 months vacation.
- wallflower 18y agoIn the words of a dot-com-bubble-bursting-era letter from a teacher in response to a dot-commer saying he'd just get a job teaching (as a fall-back): "Good luck!". Teaching is hard and it's keeping qualified teachers teaching that is a problem. I remember reading an article in Time magazine "Why Teachers Hate Parents" (2005). I was fairly shocked back then to read why teachers hate their job: Parents. The article was helpfully blog-copied; it is a good read, even though it probably uses more extreme examples of "helicopter parents" "Ask teachers about the best part of their job, and most will say how much they love working with kids. Ask them about the most demanding part, and they will say dealing with parents. In fact, a new study finds that of all the challenges they face, new teachers rank handling parents at the top. According to preliminary results from the MetLife Survey of the American Teacher, made available exclusively to TIME, parent management was a bigger struggle than finding enough funding or maintaining discipline or enduring the toils of testing. It's one reason, say the Consortium for Policy Research in Education and the Center for the Study of Teaching and Policy, that 40% to 50% of new teachers leave the profession within five years. Even master teachers who love their work, says Harvard education professor Sara Lawrence-Lightfoot, call this "the most treacherous part of their jobs." "At the most disturbing extreme are the parents who like to talk about values but routinely undermine them. "You get savvier children who know how to get out of things," says a second-grade teacher in Murfreesboro, Tenn. "Their parents actually teach them to lie to dodge their responsibilities." Didn't get your homework done? That's O.K. Mom will take the fall. Late for class? Blame it on Dad." http://forums.atozteacherstuff.com/showthread.php?t=8834&page=2 http://forums.atozteacherstuff.com/showthread.php?t=8834&...
- mynameishere 18y agoIs there really a large enough pool of people out there who would be good teachers Keep in mind that the labor pool is controlled by a cartel. Remove the certificate (and other) requirements and you have a very large pool. Allow people with specialties to teach part time, and you could get some very good people.