3 ms·
> I think you are wrong, the geo-political tectonic plates has not only shifted but collided violently in Jan 2020. I don't think so. In 10 years, there will b
by baybal2 7y ago
> I think you are wrong, the geo-political tectonic plates has not only shifted but collided violently in Jan 2020.
I don't think so. In 10 years, there will be no Trump in the office, and I doubt than even US based companies are ready to stake so much money on US government money continuing to come in 10 years term.
> Taiwan needs Americas protection and no other country
Their biggest defence against China is their mutual economic annihilation, along with most of world's light industry.
Remember, it was USA who made them loose their UN seat, and sabotaged their nuclear weapons program to keep them dependent, and let China into the WTO. Since at least Jiang Jingguo, Taiwan has been rather ambivalent with USA, and are wary of being set up
Trump is not the first to raise the point on this exact matter, in fact that was going back and forth at least since Bush Jr as I know.
Lastly, the biggest, and most obvious argument about your sentiment is that if American political establishment (with Trump, or without him) were truly serious about committing to confrontation with China, they should've started with barring US companies making business with Chinese multinationals, or at least obvious state companies.
Without seeing that first, you can be assured that US will not run into collision with China, or the politically connected big money in US would be first to run.
- forgot_again 7y agoThe movement to bring supply chains back to the US, or at the very least out of China, is far bigger than Trump.
- fermienrico 7y agoNot just US, the entire world is waking up to CCP's iron grip. Europe, Korea, Japan, India and Australia are planning to recede from China's dependence on manufacturing. This is an amazing time to be alive, I encourage people to look into manufacturing disciplines. As Elon put it (agree or disagree with him, but he is right about this) - "Someone's gotta build stuff. If you're not doing it, someone else is." Physical things don't just pop out of thin air. Every single thing except your body and natural substances are manmade. Someone decided how its gonna be built and how it will come into existence.
- forgot_again 7y agoCompletely agree. I believe that we need to reframe the debate around manufacturing from one about jobs to one about national security. This mentally frees us to fully invest in manufacturing automation, which will neutralize any labor cost advantages China and other countries may have.
- yumraj 7y agoExcept that Elon is moving deeper and deeper into China...
- MangoCoffee 7y agofor the first time in a long time both party agree on this. i believed this is the U.S. failure for believing in China. U.S. bring China into WTO, open up trade and hollow out Midwest. what American get in return is Emperor Xi. CCP is not going to change and Xi already have more powers consolidated into him than any other previous CCP leader even Mao. American's dream for a open and democratic China is long dead.
- baybal2 7y ago> American's dream for a open and democratic China is long dead. There already is an open and democratic China across the Taiwan straight. And the USA has a looong history of rather ambivalent relationship with it, starting from the Chinese civil war (to the surprise of many, US has sided with Mao for quite a number of times) For long, US policy was to purposefully keep the Republic of China weak, vulnerable, and dependent. Were the US even 1% genuine in their commitment to seeing democratic China, they would not be consistently setting up Taiwan to be undermined politically.
- forgot_again 7y agoWe're discussing a recent change in tone, behavior and overall policy. What you're describing is the product of previous administrations working hard to get on (the People's Republic of) China's good side, cozying up to China and trying to integrate it into the Democratic community. This is now precisely what is changing.
- magicsmoke 7y agoBecause during the cold war Taiwan wasn't nearly big enough to counterbalance the USSR. the PRC was, and when the US got bloodied in Vietnam and needed to pull out they wanted to make sure the USSR couldn't step into the hole they left behind and start pushing across the rest of Southeast Asia. Cue the PRC. Right after the US left, the PRC had their own war with Vietnam because they thought Vietnam was working with the USSR to conquer the rest of Southeast Asia and surround them, and the PRC and the US ended up working to isolate Vietnam over its invasion of Cambodia and put pressure on the USSR. With China holding down the fort in East Asia, the US could pull back its military spending from 10% GDP to 5% GDP in the 70s while the USSR got bankrupted by a new military threat. Doesn't look like US politicians today are willing to throw Eastern Europe under the bus to flip Russia against the PRC like they threw Taiwan under the bus though.
- transpute 7y ago> barring US companies making business with Chinese multinationals, or at least obvious state companies. CFIUS actions have been reported in the tech news for the last 12 months, in multiple sectors.