3 ms·
> Furthermore, for his model to be in any way validated by such an outcome, it would have to happen for the reasons he proposed, and not, say, as a consequence
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> Furthermore, for his model to be in any way validated by such an outcome, it would have to happen for the reasons he proposed, and not, say, as a consequence of Covid-19, which he did not predict.
I mostly agree with you, but I don't agree with this point.
It's perfectly coherent to take the view "by [2020], society will be stretched to the point that [whatever comes up] will trigger [whatever]". There is a very wide range of possible responses to any event. A minor stressor can cause a breakdown in bad times when it would barely even have been noticed in good times. The same omen will usually signify good things in good times and bad things in bad times. As such, if you're predicting "bad times will result in typical stresses leading [pretextually?] to atypical breakdowns", which stresses happen to do so is kind of beside the point.
If e.g. people somewhere are almost ready for a revolution, and some charismatic guy comes along who thinks we need electrum-based money, and he leads a revolution with electrum-based money as a major part of his policy platform... we don't necessarily want to say that electrum was a key issue at the time. The revolution was determined by many things, but not that one. Electrum was mostly chosen arbitrarily by a guy who happened to be good at revolting, at a time when revolting was fruitful.
- mannykannot 7y agoThat's a fair point, though then we might wonder if it would have happened on Turchin's schedule in response to a more normal trigger. Regardless of what happens this year, it takes more than one successful prediction to support a theory of predictable cycles.