8 ms·
I think this is a false rumour. The digital office of Taiwanese president is vehemently against letting fab tech out of the island. The woman running it is supe
by baybal2 7y ago
I think this is a false rumour. The digital office of Taiwanese president is vehemently against letting fab tech out of the island. The woman running it is super sharp, can tell from knowing people who worked under her personally.
It is one of their biggest insurance against mainland aggression. Any conflict with Taiwan is suicidal for the mainland economically. Plus, add the fact that 3/4 of China's own light industry is within 1000km radius of Taiwan.
TSMC has already bough land and started construction for its 5nm fab, and laid first stone for 3nm fabs in Taiwan.
Stopping 3nm fab construction now is completely out of the question unless they are ready to throw out few billion dollars cash out of the window, at the time when they took biggest debt obligations in their history.
Only 2nm node is left on the roadmap, but there are big, big doubts of it materialising any time soon. We are talking about at least 8-10 years.
With all my knowledge of the industry, such deliberations never result in decisions like "Hey, lets set aside 20-30 billion USD to lay still for 10 years, and hope for everything happen according to plan."
Semiconductor fab companies are extremely, extremely risk averse, and snap judgements are completely uncharacteristic of the industry.
They don't do anything without having top tier economists, and finance people have a go at the task for years on end. Financial planning of fab construction takes years.
What is much more likely is them taking over a smaller fab in US, or building a limited scale project to make specialty chips for rad-hard, or US military hardware companies on US soil. This is what I myself been hearing for much longer than Trump been in office.
- solidasparagus 7y agoThe article says it would be a 5nm fab and the core reason behind it would be to sell to America which is getting more and more worried about dependence on Asian supply chains. As a US government backed initiative, it seems likely that the US would help financially in some way.
- baybal2 7y ago5nm fab will require an investment of $15B+. Moreover, having it in the middle of nowhere in Arizona, without a semiconductor supply chain there will also add massive cost of building a support cluster by themselves. Intel itself has to haul all consumables for their US fabs in Arizona from Asia. So, add few more billions for the uncertainty on the supply chain side. Plus, having a 2-3 year project deadline looks to me as feasible, but still very tight. TSMC's 5nm fab in Taiwan has effectively took 4 years given that they still in the final stages of setting up its internals. In US, they will have to do all of that without the massive support of Taiwanese industry, and no local expertise. Also, by completing a 5nm project 3-4 years from now, who they will be selling the capacity to, when biggest cash cows will move to 3nm, and there will be nobody to take their place for existing 5nm capacity? The cost of tapeout on 14nm is already so extreme that leaves only around 30 companies globally in the game, it will be much worse for 5nm. Now, the biggest showstopper — TSMC is a public company with a lot of pension fund, and sovereign fund type investors. How they are going to make them swallow that? Them saying that out of the blue will be a bombshell. Lastly, Taiwanese government has long subjected its semiconductor industry to zealous supervision, and policy guidance. Such move will have to pass by the regulators, which Taiwan has many. So, without US government putting at least $20B cash, and big guarantees on the table, the project seems to be in the same gimmick rank as Foxconn's Wisconsin plant. Commercially, it makes not much sense to me unless something really surreal is happening on the political, or financial side of the matter.
- Cyph0n 7y agoWell, having a fab in the middle of nowhere alleviates concerns related to vibration, noise, and water supply, no?
- dralley 7y agoAnd pollution. Semiconductor manufacturing is dirty, dirty business.
- kube-system 7y agoNot sure about having plenty of water in Arizona, but they've got plenty of silicon. :)
- lawrenceyan 7y agoIntel has the majority of its fabs in Arizona. What are you talking about?
- dralley 7y agoIntel has 4 fabs in Arizona, and one in New Mexico =. They have more fabs in Oregon (6) but it's not like TSMC will be building from scratch out in Arizona. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_manufacturing_sites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_manufacturing_si...
- coredog64 7y agoMicrochip has fabs in AZ. Before LSI sold off their Oregon plant, ONN’s most advanced fab was in Phoenix. NXP has Freescale’s old fabs as well. I think generally speaking, AZ is well represented in terms of fab expertise.
- solidasparagus 7y agoWe'll have to wait to see what happens, but $20B cash is absolutely nothing to the US government if we are talking about securing vital supply chains. And US-Chinese relations aren't going so hot so it feels like ripple effects on the chip industry are inevitable.
- sremani 7y agoI think you are wrong, the geo-political tectonic plates has not only shifted but collided violently in Jan 2020. US is brining supply-chain by hook or crook. Taiwan needs Americas protection and no other country can be its security guarantor not even Japan. So US has leverage. I would be surprised if TSMC does not open multiple facilities in US.
- AaronFriel 7y agoIf TSMC brings state of the art fabrication to the US, doesn't that mean they're subject to seizure by the Defense Production Act we've all learned so much about, TSMC's corporate fate becomes subject to CFIUS approval, and because of that, Taiwan loses a significant amount of political leverage to protect itself?
- fermienrico 7y agoLOL, that's literally the case with any foreign investment in physical assets. Tesla factory in Shanghai - if there is a war, all bets are off. CCP will raid the factory within the next 20 mins and employ military rule in the factory in about an hour's notice. Physical assets are in some ways the ultimate thing to own. Even services that run on data centers which are physical things. Semiconductors are physical objects that your Dropbox runs on.
- kick 7y agoWhich is exactly why this rumor makes no sense.
- fermienrico 7y agoThis rumor makes perfect sense. Taiwan is looking at US to shield it from Chinese influence. Moving manufacturing to US and building on top of strong American-Taiwanese collaboration (which already exists) only makes sense. The US has strong laws for IP protection, has proper constitutional values and doesn't steal technologies on a whim without due process. Taiwan has benefited greatly from the US and the US has benefited greatly from Taiwan. I just wish American president was someone like the Taiwanese president. She is a strong, powerful and smart lady.
- gtm1260 7y agoSo what happens when we get to 2nm? Do we just stop getting faster computers?
- ghaff 7y agoCMOS process scaling is already on its last legs. There are various options: more efficient code (ROFL), stacking of various sorts, new material/techs, co-processing (GPU, FPGA, quantum for certain classes of problems), etc. But there's certainly a school of thought that CMOS process scaling was the big engine of tech over the past few decades and there may be nothing that comes close to replacing it to anything like the same degree.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoWe could see a 4x boost in computer speed by scrapping all scripting languages and electron. Also the future seems to be more cores. A 64 core laptop may not be too far away.
- SemiTom 7y agoThere are challenges but work is on the way, transitioning to gate-all around FETS (GAA Fets) https://semiengineering.com/making-chips-at-3nm-and-beyond/ https://semiengineering.com/making-chips-at-3nm-and-beyond/
- camillomiller 7y agoYou might have missed the part about the stranglehold that the U.S. administration is exerting on Taiwan, and especially TSMC, by kicking around the idea of banning U.S. companies to selling components to a supplier of Huawei. It is an insane measure that the hawks have been thinking about for a while now. A good summary of what's going on: https://asia.nikkei.com/Opinion/Taiwan-s-semiconductor-industry-is-stuck-between-Trump-and-Huawei https://asia.nikkei.com/Opinion/Taiwan-s-semiconductor-indus...
- MangoCoffee 7y ago>Taiwanese president is vehemently against letting fab tech out of the island she is pan-green. CCP does not like pan-green anything at all. they especially doesn't like her and favor the pan-blue candidate during the president race. CCP even went as far as bribing Taiwanese in China to go back and vote for pan-blue candidate. this story just break recently. Taiwan needs U.S. security guarantees. she will let TSMC out of island if it mean it doesn't piss off Uncle Sam and US have been applying a lot of pressures on TSMC for making chip for China.
- davidf18 7y ago"TSMC has already bough land and started construction for its 5nm fab" The A14 CPU processors based on the 5nm process on the next iPhone, the 12, with phones shipping in Sept are already in production, or will be in the next month or two.
- redis_mlc 7y agoI'd have to agree. The US is more "business-friendly" than Europe, but nothing compared to China or Taiwan for people with the right connections. Occasionally you'll see unscripted interviews between a US reporter and a visiting Chinese business leader. The US reporter always asks if the visitor will be opening a local factory (because the US is so awesome!), and the visitor starts looking around wildly and demurs, since they're just here to park money.