3 ms·
“From Google” “From a random employee of Google” Everything about this is solution is laughable, by the way...appsheet and google sheets application made by s
by dangus 7y ago
“From Google”
“From a random employee of Google”
Everything about this is solution is laughable, by the way...appsheet and google sheets application made by some random dude is not a private solution. We have no way to verify anything. Google Sheets itself may be secure but it’s the human element that’s not secure: someone else owns access to this google sheet. It’s a huge, huge privacy concern. Why is all this information being collected!?
And it’s not even legit enough to have a static website. Apparently I have to read about it in a google sheet or on Facebook. Please.
- northwestcoder 7y agoHi, During this peer review we went with sheets as a convenience. If we were to continue, we would move to an open source db (e.g. mysql or similar) in a cloud instance, secured via ssl as well as ip firewall. Thanks for the feedback.
- northwestcoder 7y agoI'm not sure what you meant by static or legit. You can learn all about these various technology choices at appsheet.com - we want hacker news feedback just like this, btw. Thanks again.
- dangus 7y agoRight it’s secure in terms of the way Google and Appsheet handle data, but we are just handing over all our data to you? What organization is responsible for handling this data? Where is the privacy policy and terms of use? What stops you from just grabbing all the contact info you got in your google sheet and running with it? In terms of the static site, what I mean is that you built all this out but couldn’t be bothered to put the information onto the actual public web. A shared google doc or a Facebook post is not really a public website. The fact that the 30 minutes wasn’t spent to make a website just sets off all kinds of red flags to me.
- northwestcoder 7y ago"we are just handing over all our data to you?" that is in fact the requirement as outlined by the State of Washington Governor's office (Jay Inslee), document here:https://www.governor.wa.gov/sites/default/files/COVID19Phase2PersonalServicesGuidance.pdf https://www.governor.wa.gov/sites/default/files/COVID19Phase... - we made no assumptions about "what org is responsible for handling this data" and instead designed a "data roach motel". It does remain to be seen who would access the data in the event that the state of washington needed to "contact a bunch of restaurant patrons informing them of exposure". This app does not attempt to solve for that, in fact. "but couldn’t be bothered to put the information onto the actual public web" - that's a fair comment. We are approaching this in stages. I also have a bunch of restaurant contacts as well as technology contacts, and wanted a kind of "soft release". And if we had gone ahead and created a "proper website" we would get dinged for having gone too far too quickly, before a proper peer review. This approach seems like a good compromise in terms of sharing info but not being "too proper, too soon". Again, I do appreciate this feedback. Keep it coming.
- pstuart 7y agoI submitted the document in question for my friend. I purposely put Google in the title because it's going to be a sponsored Google effort (as I understand it), and it will get more eyeballs on it for feedback. I also warned him ahead of time to expect less than polite responses and have been validated right out of the gate.
- dangus 7y agoYeah, there is no way this is a sponsored Google effort. Google would never put something like this out in public. My guess is that if Google finds out about this you’re gonna get shutdown, or maybe even fired (if the claim of being a google employee is actually legitimate). And google wouldn’t be using sheets and Appsheet, they’d be using their own contract tracing API. You put Google in the title to get hits. I don’t think google is at all involved with this.
- pstuart 7y ago> You put Google in the title to get hits. Not hits. Eyeballs for review. This project attempts to address a critical need in very short time, and constructive feedback might help it succeed.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- northwestcoder 7y agoI am part of a product team at Google called AppSheet. AppSheet.com was a Google acquisition in Jan 2020. I received approval to post this via social media and then I did so. You may be correct that this project and idea never sees the light of "production" day. We didn't and don't need the hits. We were trying to solve a particularly tricky problem. Thanks again for the feedback.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't be a jerk on HN, even if you do have legitimate concerns. Your comments in this thread broke the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and particularly the Show HN guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html