5 ms·
An evergreen headline... In the 90s I remember hearing this too. Use the high salary and property value increases to build a nestegg, but keep an eye out for o
by epistasis 7y ago
An evergreen headline...
In the 90s I remember hearing this too. Use the high salary and property value increases to build a nestegg, but keep an eye out for other geographic opportunities because the locals are determined to keep you out, as a class, even if they are friendly one to one.
These days, the property value scam has been going so long that new high wage workers are often locked out for many years, to the benefit of all prior arrivals. But same story otherwise.
- malandrew 7y agoWell to some degree it actually happened. All the activity in the first dot com book was in the Valley. Afterwards a lot of it migrated up to San Francisco. Now that both places are saturated. It's starting to happen in the East Bay. After San Francisco and the East Bay have started saturating, other places were put on the map like Seattle, NYC, Austin and Pittsburgh.
- lanewinfield 7y agoOne minor difference in the story: a global pandemic
- arbuge 7y agoHow do you think that will change things this time around exactly?
- rsanek 7y agoI think it's already forced many employers that perviously weren't as remote-friendly to move more aggressively towards it. Already we've seen that in a big way at Twitter (see post from 2 days ago, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23155647 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23155647)
- lanewinfield 7y agoIt's simple. There needed to be an outside force to push large scale testing of remote to convince people to try it. That's the pandemic. It wasn't going to happen on large scale without it. Now that it's been proven in many fields to be viable, it's got a much higher likelihood of sticking than before.
- mikestew 7y agoIn the 90s I remember hearing this too. What, that due to the fact that we're all working from home because of a global pandemic, and my employer says I can WFH long-term, I'm thinking about moving out of SV? You must run with a different crowd than I do, because I don't recall a single person saying that in the 90s.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- epistasis 7y agoThe headline is the evergreen part; certainly the specifics are different now then they were back then! Edit: also, check out Raldi's link to a 1993 post for complaints about housing costs and more: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23181981 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23181981 (That said, the housing costs are far worse now then in 1993 on a wage to land price basis, I hear!)
- ghaff 7y agoI didn't pursue a few job options during the 90s in the Bay Area in part because of housing costs and companies that weren't offering enough to cover the difference. As you say, relative prices are much worse now. But Bay Area prices were high even then.
- dh5 7y agoNot sure what the scam is. Sounds like normal supply and demand.
- fossuser 7y agoForcing artificially low housing supply via legislation.
- shuckles 7y agoThe land values are legit. That they cannot be amortized across many occupants is not.
- epistasis 7y agoI get where you are coming from, but my intuition is that we have actually created a massive bubble in land prices by restricting use so much. Land would get a hell of a lot cheaper if we massively decreased demand by letting people live in ways that use less land.
- Ericson2314 7y agoWell there are countervailing trends here: on one hand, land being extra scarce because it is used inefficiently, and on the other, land being extra valuable because it is used efficiently. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox is probably the answer: Non-idiotic land use would make the cost of floor area decrease, but the cost of land increase.
- shuckles 7y agoLand values in urban areas always increase in response to upzoning and loosening of development restrictions.
- epistasis 7y agoThat's because we have restricted land use so much that any upzoning is in response to intense pressure, which focuses massive amounts of capital that was waiting on the sidelines to compete for the new opportunity. If, instead, we hadn't massively down zoned everything in the 20th century, an upzoning wouldn't be "giving away" lots of value, because there would be an abundance of locations that could be used. This is why small focused upzonings like those that happen in NYC and SF are so disastrous and destroy neighborhoods. Instead of gradual city-wise change like what happens in more affordable places like Tokyo, SF and NYC are super expensive because they set zoning so almost everything is "built out." Any area that is "built out" has reached complete failure in city planning, in my opinion. Which is pretty much all of the Bay Area.
- BurningFrog 7y agoA lot of people have moved out.
- jseliger 7y agoIt's also possible that a thing won't work until it does. Electric cars had that quality and don't anymore, like many other practices and technologies.