4 ms·
> Adding a monetary reward for comments and posts really skews the incentives of the community members who choose to participate People like to complain about
by dehrmann 7y ago
> Adding a monetary reward for comments and posts really skews the incentives of the community members who choose to participate
People like to complain about FOX New's conservative bias (and to a lesser extent MSNBC's liberal bias), but they miss the fact that their real bias is towards viewership, and they've become news entertainment products, not sources of journalism.
- michaelbuckbee 7y agoThat's an interesting way to describe it - that's really how I consider YouTube as well. The wacky conspiracy videos all do really well because they're interesting (in a what the hell is going on with this guy kind of way if nothing else) and entertaining while reality has a style more like CSPAN.
- three_seagrass 7y agoThe conspiratorial and alt-political videos are an extension of reality TV online. Unfortunately if you expose yourself to too much of them you end up co-opting some of their views. NYT did a really good job covering this recently with their podcast Rabbit Hole: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/22/podcasts/rabbit-hole-prologue.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/22/podcasts/rabbit-hole-prol...
- goostavos 7y ago"co-opting some of their views" for sure happened to me. I don't think it's bad thing, though. I'm curiously drawn towards anyone whom has people shouting "don't give them a platform!" or has suggestions that their ideas are so powerful that they may somehow corrupt minds weaker than, presumably, their own superior ones. So I semi-regularly listen to these "alt" people. Alex Jones, McInnes, molyneux, and so on. The co-opting was largely realizing that in-between some of the crazy (there's a fair amount to filter out in Jones' case), there are these kernels of truth, often backed by government documents or reports. The co-opting ideas, I guess, was a general realization that the common narrative doesn't necessarily reflect the entire reality. Even things which are presented as cut and dry, are often a frustrating messy grey once you dig into them. It's also given me a general skepticism of commonly held opinions about people in general. These "literal cult leader", "literal nazis", etc... have turned out to be less monsters and more humans with nuanced opinions which don't necessarily translate to 5min clips.
- michaelbuckbee 7y agoI've always felt that the framing of "don't give them a platform" is off as it's more like "don't make me support and amplify these things I really disagree with". Different communities are good for different things and there is such a thing as community standards. It doesn't have to get to the Alex Jones political level either, just think like how weird it is when people hit on each other on Nextdoor [1] or if some guy was trying to sell his lawnmower on Grindr/Tinder. 1 - https://twitter.com/bestofnextdoor/status/1002656581341700097?lang=en https://twitter.com/bestofnextdoor/status/100265658134170009...
- three_seagrass 7y agoI think you really need to listen to the NYT podcast. Your comment eerily similar to the experience of one of the people they follow who was deep in the rabbit hole.
- goostavos 7y agoThat's largely the point I'm making ^_^ but I'm just trying to clarify that it's not necessarily some scary negative thing, or that I've been warped or something. I think of listening to them largely in the spirit of Lincoln's “I don't like that man. I must get to know him better.” There's an entire machine telling me to hate these people, write them off, or that they're overall "bad." So I listened to a bunch of their content to see what it was about. That's kinda it, really. I haven't turned into some conspiratorial nut job or joined some cult (I don't think!). I listened to a couple of podcasts to try to form my own opinions. The output of the exercise was that I don't think these people are evil demons. I think they're largely just... people. Complex, right sometimes, wrong sometimes, and fun to hate on by the general media.
- eutropia 7y agoThere are reasonable people who also can give you the "general realization that the common narrative doesn't necessarily reflect the entire reality", I would point to Noam Chomsky as a source of that very same wisdom but without the mania or toxicity.
- 7y ago
- jliptzin 7y agoIf you know how to think critically, look for and evaluate source material, account for author bias, etc, you should not be co-opting any nonsense views just by sheer amount of exposure. Think about nuclear engineers; dealing with radioactive material is not dangerous if you know what you're doing.
- 101404 7y agoI may live in a completely different world here, but I've never seen a single conspiracy video on YouTube. All I see when I open YouTube is videos about science, tech, diy projects, etc. What am I doing wrong?
- wholinator2 7y agoYou simply haven't viewed any conspiracy videos. My YouTube was very clean forever as well but a few days ago I saw a bright light in the sky (far brighter than any reasonable star or satellite I'd seen) and I googled around to see if there was anything about it online. Watched a YouTube video of a bright light in the sky with no explanation provided. Next day I watched a suggested Joe Rogan video taking about UFOs. Now a good third of my suggestions are UFO conspiracies. It's been getting better as I avoid them but YouTube was very quick to suggest multitudes of conspiracy because of a single Google search, and I had no history of interests like that. So it's possible to have a reasonable and logical YouTube. However, even a single video can trigger YouTube's algorithm to attempt to pull you in.
- jasonv 7y agoI pay for Youtube Premium, but I find it curious (and objectionable) that their "View in Incognito" function (in Youtube) will not reflect Premium-ness. They show ads. They still know who you are -- because it's just an option to leave Incognito mode to get back to Premium/not-incognito mode.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoFwiw you can always reset dynamic recommendations with the "Clear History" button in the History tab. Nice to do this every once in a while anyways, just to find another pocket of Youtube that interests you.
- Benjammer 7y agoYellow journalism has been around forever
- guerrilla 7y agoSociety has a short memory it seems.
- Benjammer 7y ago"That's an interesting way to describe it" This sibling comment response is literally giving me chills. Is this like a bot or something or someone who literally thinks the idea of sensationalist journalism is like a "huh that's interesting, never thought of that" kind of thing? I am pretty sure sensationalist journalism predates real journalism... Why would a feudal lord want his subjects to really know what was going on in the world?
- eli 7y agoThey should instead produce content that people don’t want to watch?
- xevrem 7y agonews 'ideally' has nothing to do with 'want' it is about the latest new information. It is not supposed to be entertaining, it is supposed to transfer information. Again, those are ideals, and reality of human behavior rarely meets them.
- eli 7y agoSo do you force people to watch it? Nothing is being transferred if nobody watches.
- derefr 7y agoIdeally, they would produce content that people would, after watching, be happiest that they did watch (or most regret if they instead hadn't watched.) This is my big complaint about Hollywood, too: if they charged people after the movie, instead of before; and 100% of the base price went to the theatre itself, while people could "leave a tip" for the filmmakers; then "box office" would actually correlate to the quality of the movie itself, rather than to the amount of effort put into the marketing campaign.
- gpm 7y agoI bet your scheme would get a lot more movies encouraging giving money to artists, tipping large sums of money, and targeted at rich people who have the money to give large tips.
- derefr 7y ago> a lot more movies encouraging giving money to artists Doesn't sound like a bad thing, IMHO. > tipping large sums of money This would kind of suck, given the stupidity of current North American tipping norms. But I'm not sure whether they could actually manage to communicate "the existing tipping system should be venerated" during an experience that directly involves exposure to/use of a different tipping paradigm. It'd be like watching a movie about monarchy, as the result of the audience holding a democratic vote on what movie to watch. To be clear, it's a "different tipping paradigm" because of these properties: • tipping would be entirely optional, in a selfish-pragmatist sense: there's no way in which a lack of tipping would get you blackballed from the theatre or even given a bad look, because the tips don't go to the theatre or its employees; • you'd be tipping a collective of unseen workers far away who produced the experience a while ago, rather than tipping an individual close-by who did the work just now; • there would be no possibility for tipping to get you individually a better quality of service, because your tip would be anonymized through the hub-and-spoke (studio-theatre-audience) delivery model. The studio would just see a pile of tip money, at best traced back to particular theatres. Really, it's more equivalent to how film-festivals ask for donations; but they'd be asking for donations on behalf of the movie maker, rather than for themselves. > targeted at rich people who have the money to give large tips This is true, but 1. I'm not sure it's worse than whatever kind of targeting we have right now given the system's current inventives (which would be... cinematic populism?); and 2. this would put film in line with most of the arts, which generally run off of commissions/patronage. Society doesn't generally outright reject the output of those fields of endeavor, despite their being mostly tuned to the tastes of their (rich) clients/patrons. (Society does feel more "detached" from such works, though; there's a lot of "I don't get it" in art galleries, mainly because many works were created to be understood mostly by the patron and the social-milieu of people they showed it to, rather than by any passerby.)
- ouid 7y agoI think this is a rather naive view of Fox News. There's a lot of money to be made in propaganda as well.
- busterarm 7y agoCNN is really going after awards choosing luminaries such as Greta Thunberg for their COVID-19 Town Hall this evening.
- dehrmann 7y agoSomething bugged me about her during her 2019 UN climate action summit speech: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TMrtLsQbaok https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TMrtLsQbaok She delvers a "how dare you..." line at the beginning that gets a good round of applause. Then she continues with her speech. Maybe I'm armchair QB-ing it, but she should have called out the audience for clapping. They're clapping for what she's saying, but as world leaders, it's their failure she's pointing out.
- searchableguy 7y agoI mean it wasn't in the script so why would she?
- free_rms 7y agoAnd it's not even ideological bias, it's more like the tribes from Survivor. Joe Biden is more conservative than Donald Trump in a lot of ways, as far as ideology and policy go. But MSNBC viewers love him and hate Trump, Fox News the opposite. They're not fair weather fans, they're committed to their teams.