3 ms·
I think we are on the same page here in many way. But the only reason that those higher end homes are still viable to build is because there aren't enough of t
by epistasis 7y ago
I think we are on the same page here in many way. But the only reason that those higher end homes are still viable to build is because there aren't enough of them. Just as there aren't enough of the affordable homes.
I'd be wary of lionizing home ownership as capitalism done right, as it has led to many of California's problems. For example, rental versus condos is a weird issue here. Million-dollar home owners here deride owned-condos, at half the cost of their detached homes, as "luxury condos" only for the super wealthy as they try to block them. They see themselves as working class, but because of the incredible appreciation of property values, and their regulatory capture which has prevented building any more housing, they have become the capitalists just like the multifamily rental building owners. (And in fact many are owners of both, because buying real estate in the 60s-70s in California has been the easiest form of capitalistic gains that I know of... protected tax status, regulatory driven shortages, etc...)
We place all sorts of restrictions on new housing, but I think we should transfer all of those to existing housing as well. If somebody is against luxury condos in their neighborhood, then all remodels should have to go through just as rigorous a process. Perhaps income caps on those purchasing existing property, just as are demanded in newly built property. Otherwise, by restricting just new property in this way, we are systematically locking our younger people and immigrants from the system that provided so much wealth to the Boomers.
- ethbro 7y agoGood points. I'm curious if there's anywhere world-wide that's tried land swaps on a large scale. Maybe Japan? In the sense of "I give you my house + lot (and my neighbors do), you give me back X units in the more dense development you replace them with." I read on an article here that China does something similar, but that was more geared around transit right of ways and farmland, vs increasing density in low density urban areas. As you pointed out, California seems like it needs a carrot and a stick. A carrot, to financially incentivize existing homeowners to be part of the solution. And a stick, to discourage the worst tendencies of sit-on-it-forever.