5 ms·
Contracts incorporate all relevant contract law in the jurisdiction, though, since you can't enter a contract contrary to a jurisdiction's law. Say you sign an
by _delirium 16y ago
Contracts incorporate all relevant contract law in the jurisdiction, though, since you can't enter a contract contrary to a jurisdiction's law.
Say you sign an employment agreement in California that purports to include a "non-employment" condition, which CA doesn't permit. I suppose you could say that it was "agreed to but not enforceable", but it makes more sense imo to say that non-compete agreements simply aren't possible in California (because an unenforceable contract is not a contract in any meaningful sense).
Or, if you deal with mortgages in a state whose mortgage law says that all mortgages can be exited with no further legal obligation by returning the property to the lender, then all mortgages in that jurisdiction have such a termination clause written into them, whether the contract purports to include it or not. For clarity, it probably should be restated in the document as well, but even if the document omits it, it's legally there.
The phrase "nothing wrong with" did have moral content. The morally required activity when dealing with contracts is exactly equivalent to the legally required activity. That's the whole point of contracts, to impose legal obligations on the parties. I could see an argument if someone was misled, and didn't realize what legal obligations were being imposed. But I don't think that was the case here; lenders in no-recourse states presumably were aware that they were agreeing to a mortgage where the borrower had that option.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe activity legally required by a mortgage is to pay the debt. The existence of a penalty doesn't change this - it simply makes the calculation of whether or not it is profitable to violate the agreement a lot simpler. By your logic it is morally right to deliberately violate the terms of any contract as long as you accept whatever penalties the courts dish out. Instrumentally speaking, all contracts have an embedded option to break them and accept the legal judgement against you. Personally I don't buy into this moral schema. But that's just a question of values, I suppose.