4 ms·
It's unfortunate, but not surprising that the headline is 'meltdown a possibility,' ignoring things like: > "What we have seen is only the slight indication
by pyre 16y ago
It's unfortunate, but not surprising that the headline is 'meltdown a
possibility,' ignoring things like:
> "What we have seen is only the slight indication from a monitoring post of
> cesium and iodine," he said.
> "We have some confidence, to some extent, to make the situation to be
> stable status," he said. "We actually have very good confidence that we
> will resolve this."
- scott_s 16y agoPeople who may be held responsible for Very Bad Things tend to downplay the probability that the bad thing will occur and express confidence that they have it under control. That an official admits a meltdown is possible is the most noteworthy thing. When I run what he said through my public-official-Bayesian-filter, what comes out is "There is a non-trivial chance a meltdown will occur."
- foobarbazban 16y agoThis particular official (or his office, honestly) doesn't have much to gain from downplaying the possibility of a meltdown. He is part of the regulatory agency, not the plant management. They are already going to have to revamp all of their regulations with regard to coolant water pumps (whoever screwed up there, be it someone writing regulations or an inspector, is already in trouble).
- Klinky 16y agoYour second paragraph contradicts itself.
- earl 16y agoThis particular official (or his office, honestly) doesn't have much to gain from downplaying the possibility of a meltdown This is the same Japan, you'll remember, that actually doctored video footage to downplay a previous accident at a nuclear reactor -- see Monju[1] -- with the direct involvement of the government. Or when they had to take the extraordinary step of forcing the shutdown of 17 reactors because a major (the major?) utility falsified safety records [2]. A cursory googling of japan nuclear safety would have immediately informed you that officials often downplay and conceal information. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monju_Nuclear_Power_Plant http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monju_Nuclear_Power_Plant [2] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/3548192.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/3548192.stm
- Someone 16y agoI think the only fact in that article is "we saw radiation levels of X but we do not know what caused them". The rest could be interpretation. The press will want to hear more than that 'we do not know', so it presses on, and asks, "do you have a meltdown?", A good PR Guy would probably say 'we do not want to speculate at this time', and nothing else, but holding that line is hard. It is way too easy to (especially for an engineer) to follow that by 'it very, very probably is 100% safe, but of course, since we do not _know_, it could be a meltdown'. Guess what part of such a statement would make the news? So, to draw any conclusions from this, I would want to know who were present at that phone call, and what exactly was said.
- codex 16y agoI believe a meltdown, if contained, may not necessarily release radiation into the environment. That would qualify as "stable status" in my book.