4 ms·
100% of Hacker News is moderated by the same people HN is open about it. That's the difference.
by onion2k 7y ago
100% of Hacker News is moderated by the same people
HN is open about it. That's the difference.
- nexuist 7y agoI mean, so is Reddit. Subreddit moderators are public information. All the original image did was take this data and aggregate it onto one chart. HN doesn't say "100% of posts are moderated by the same people" anywhere on the site in the same way that Reddit doesn't say "our top 100 are mostly moderated by 5 people."
- fzeroracer 7y agoOpen to some extent, yes. On others, not so much. There's been much discussion on HN with how it handles users from shadowbans, hidden rate limits, story weighting and so forth. I don't personally have a problem with those concepts at all, but it does seem weird to me that people here blast Reddit for doing the same things that HN does. There's been instances here of mods editing titles in order to appeal to the trolls (in hopes of removing flame wars, but an appeal nonetheless) for example. Now there's a full different discussion with how HN and Reddit use these tools to try and curate quality however.
- appleflaxen 7y agoisn't reddit open about it? mod names are published on every sub.
- onion2k 7y agoThe owners of the subreddits in question go out of their way to hide the fact that they own so many.