4 ms·
> When our actions can harm others, the government absolutely has the right—and the obligation—to step in. No. When our actions have harmed others, then the go
by pdonis 7y ago
> When our actions can harm others, the government absolutely has the right—and the obligation—to step in.
No. When our actions have harmed others, then the government has the right to step in--because we delegated that power to them.
But the government does not have the right to step in just because some government official things our actions "can" harm others. That's not their call to make. We are adult human beings and don't need keepers or nannies. We make our own choices, and if those choices do harm others, we take the consequences. But if they don't, the government needs to leave us alone.
- ajmurmann 7y ago> We make our own choices, and if those choices do harm others, we take the consequences I am all for this! How can we make this happen? Maybe we put tracing in place and if you left your house for no essential reason and without a mask and infect someone else you get shared with manslaughter? Let's do it!
- pdonis 7y ago> Maybe we put tracing in place and if you left your house for no essential reason and without a mask and infect someone else you get shared with manslaughter? Who says what counts as "no essential reason"? How do you know whether I infected anyone else? Not everyone without a mask is an asymptomatic COVID-19 carrier. If you're basically arguing that the government needs to have invasive surveillance and micromanagement powers to ensure that every possible way someone might harm someone else is captured, then no, I don't agree.
- ajmurmann 7y agoSo how does your "if those choices do harm others, we take the consequences" get enforced in practice and doesn't turn into a situation where a few people who don't take care to not infect others will kill millions?
- pdonis 7y ago> how does your "if those choices do harm others, we take the consequences" get enforced in practice and doesn't turn into a situation where a few people who don't take care to not infect others will kill millions? By looking at everyone's choices, not just the one person you want to pick on. Suppose Person A is an asymptomatic COVID-19 carrier and doesn't know it. They go to the grocery store without a mask. Person B also goes to the grocery store without a mask, and gets infected by Person A. You could say Person A is responsible because they should have worn a mask. But you could also say Person B is responsible because they should have worn a mask. Yes, if you know there are a lot of asymptomatic carriers, you should take into account the possibility that you might be one. But you should also take into account the possibility that someone else might be one. So the appropriate rule in this case is that anyone who doesn't wear a mask in a public place where they can't social distance takes the consequences if they get sick. Someone who gets infected because they didn't wear a mask can't pawn off the responsibility on the person who infected them that also wasn't wearing a mask. In other words, your scenario where "a few people who don't take care not to infect others can kill millions* simply cannot happen unless those millions of other people also don't take care not to get infected. So putting all the responsibility on the person who unknowingly infected someone else, instead of sharing it equally among all the people who didn't take common sense precautions, is wrong. Justifying invasive surveillance and tracking of everyone on those grounds is basically saying you want the government to make sure you don't have to take any prudent precautions or exercise any common sense at all in your daily life in order to avoid having anything bad happen to you. That's not reasonable.
- achenatx 7y agoexactly this. Somehow a large proportion of people only want to focus on a hypothetical infectious person going out and infecting high risk people. But if the high risk people are not out they cannot get infected. In fact, everyone who is out has agreed to the shared risk. I plan to continue to minimize my outings, but Im fine if everyone who is out shares the risk of getting infected. I do think that people who are at risk should be able to get unemployment so that they are not forced to work.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kenjackson 7y agoWait. I can drive drunk now? Those checkpoints are actually illegal? All those people in jail for DUIs shouldn’t be there? Has anyone taken these laws to the Supreme Court?
- WillPostForFood 7y agoWait, you can ban drinking because it could lead to drunk driving now? Because that's a closer analogy.
- kenjackson 7y agoThat’s a further analogy. That’s more like banning breathing.
- pdonis 7y ago> Has anyone taken these laws to the Supreme Court? No, but that's because we live in a legal regime where the government assumes the power to punish people with jail time even when no actual harm is caused, based on a government official's judgment of "possible harm". But the fact that we live in such a regime does not make it right. In a sane legal regime, what would happen if you were driving drunk, but had not caused any actual harm, and a cop saw you and stopped you, would be: cop determines that you are drunk (breathalyzer, let's say); cop makes sure your car is safely parked off the road, locks it, and takes the key; cop says "sir, I really think you should let me drive you home, since you're too drunk to drive safely; you can get a family member or friend to bring you back to get your car tomorrow when you're sober". Then, either the cop drives you home and gives your car keys to whoever is there; or, if you resist, the cop puts you in the back of his car and drives you to the police station instead, and calls a family member or friend to come take you home, and gives your car keys to them. In other words, the cop has a perfect right, when he sees you're obviously impaired, to stop you from driving. Indeed, anyone would; if you were at a friend's house and you were clearly too drunk to drive home, the friend would have a perfect right to hide your car keys and either drive you home himself, or have you crash in his spare bedroom or on the couch. But the government does not have the right to throw you in jail if all you did was drive drunk, and caused no actual harm. It only has the right to punish you if you caused actual harm.