6 ms·
It seems to me one attack vector that they aren't accounting for is the person who maliciously uploads a fake positive diagnosis, causing unnecessary panic and
by jedberg 7y ago
It seems to me one attack vector that they aren't accounting for is the person who maliciously uploads a fake positive diagnosis, causing unnecessary panic and possibly wasteful extra testing.
I guess it's possible to mitigate this attack through controls in the app that reports, but that doesn't stop a rogue developer using a test app, unless even they are prevented from accessing the APIs without approval.
- selectodude 7y agoYou need a code to mark yourself as infected.
- jedberg 7y agoBut where do the codes come from? How does a legit user get a code?
- gravypod 7y agoFrom what I've read online it seems like hospitals and healthcare organizations will have the ability to generate codes. After a doctor thinks you could possibly be infected they will provide you with a code.
- guiambros 7y agoFrom Wired[1]: "In another series of screenshots, the companies show how the apps will likely work when a user is diagnosed as Covid-19 positive. As Apple and Google had suggested earlier, they'll require users to enter a unique code provided by health care providers or a Covid-19 testing lab before allowing them to declare themselves as infected, since otherwise trolls or mistaken self-diagnoses could flood the system with false positives." [1] https://www.wired.com/story/apple-google-covid-19-contact-tracing-interface/ https://www.wired.com/story/apple-google-covid-19-contact-tr...
- jedberg 7y agoThanks. So it sounds like they at least took it into consideration.
- jmull 7y agoOn the iOS side you have to apply to Apple for the entitlement to use the API. > This entitlement is limited to government health organizations or developers who have been endorsed and approved by a government health organization. Please make sure to read the Exposure Notification documentation before submitting your information. And there’s a form where you provide the relevant information. Presumably there is some mechanism to validate this. I don’t know about the Google side.
- jedberg 7y agoI'm not super familiar with iOS app development. Do you need to get entitlement just to test the API? Or only to publish an app using that API? Because if you can test with any API you want, what stops you from making an app in your dev environment and triggering the API?
- asiachick 7y agoSo it sounds like Apple (and Google) just made it very clear to every government where to ask to spy and by enabling the spying there's no more denying "we can't do that" since they clearly are doing it. I can't imagine say, China, not demanding to be able to use this API for whatever purposes they want and if Apple/Google says no they'll just say "fine, get out of China". I also can't imagine the US government and/or state and local police won't also come knocking eventually. Of course we should do what's right for the COVID issue but I think the is clearly a foot in the door moment.
- jmull 7y ago
- m3kw9 7y agoThat is why this protocol is only allowed to be used by local official governments where they would have access to test data, each person need add an id to declare themselves pos and is matched against the Covid test db
- jedberg 7y agoI think people are missing my point. Sure you can't publish an app that does this, but unless I'm mistaken, you can access any API you want in your own dev setup, or on a jailbroken phone. What stops a malicious actor for triggering the API in a dev or jailbroken environment?
- z3rgl1ng 7y agoThe API doesn’t trigger an alert; the application consuming it does.
- varenc 7y ago> What stops a malicious actor for triggering the API in a dev or jailbroken environment? Server side authentication stops this. Sure a jailbroken device can call whatever local APIs they want, but to have a non-local effect you have to update some centralized server where the list of infected keys/users is stored for downloading by other devices. Given that, it's straightforward for the server to require some admin-level credential specific to their service. The source of truth for covid-19 positive devices/keys is still centralized and gatekept by each state/national agency's contract tracing service. (But identity/location info isn't centralized)
- rubatuga 7y agoLiterally a password page, that the hospital logs into before uploading the infected IDs. Or public key encryption. I think you should read the white paper.
- godelski 7y agoI think that still leaves the question of how you enforce that.
- PeterStuer 7y agoWhy fake? Just roam with your phone through as many busy locations as you can. Better yet (but statistically entirely optional) , get within (boosted) BTLE range of known positives (offers available, lowest prices in your region, guaranteed two weeks of work or money back! 100% safe!) first (Ten tips on shutting down your competition without lifting a finger!)
- dbbk 7y agoThe NHS model accounted for these attack vectors by saying that on the server-side they would do some risk modelling to try and identify bad actors and stop those reports from being sent out to 'exposed' users. Specifically, they used an example of someone sitting outside a hospital all day.
- PeterStuer 7y agoI think it is naive to assume they can 'catch' these cases. BTLE radio ranging, which can be manipulated by numerous factors outside the phone, and actual infection risks can easily be decoupled (and correlation is even strenuous at best). So just acting as one of the 20% of people that are completely callous and oblivious to the consequences of their actions, just wearing proper PPE, would be sufficient cover. Besides, the public is led to believe that no location identification (direct or derived) is possible, so on the basis of that 'sitting outside the hospital all day' should not be identifiable, right? As for taking out a directed 'hit', that will certainly not show.