3 ms·
that's s pretty bleak outlook. some people have the integrity to not cheat on tests because it is simply wrong. to claim that everyone has an incentive to cheat
by em-bee 7y ago
that's s pretty bleak outlook. some people have the integrity to not cheat on tests because it is simply wrong. to claim that everyone has an incentive to cheat is a very low opinion of humanity. trust noone. they are all out to get you.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- em-bee 7y ago(responding to a deleted comment, since it explains a downvote, which i appreciate, and therefore like to take the opportunity to clarify) > to claim that everyone has an incentive to cheat is a very low opinion of humanity. trust noone. they are all out to get you. I don't believe "everyone has an incentive" was ever stated, but regardless of that, if we could trust everyone with everything laws wouldn't need to exist. maybe this is a language issue. i understand 'there is an incentive' as something that is there generally motivating, as if it asks for that to happen. like advertising is an incentive to buy, and a stop sign is an incentive to stop or a green light is an incentive to go. but just like an open door may be an incentive to enter someones home, it is not an incentive to steal, and therefore i reject the idea that the existence of a test is an incentive to cheat. but to me "There is an incentive to cheat any time there is a test, where capabilities are measured that are not routinely used." says exactly that. most laws are created as a reaction to missbehavior. it's not about needing to trust everyone, but designing the system so that everyone can learn and assess their learning without needing to fear that failing that assessment will leave a permanent record. this is the problem with graded tests. they don't so much help me assess what i know and need to catch up on, but they grade how well i keep up with the classes progress. there is no way to catch up and have that test redone, showing that i have learned the material, even if i did. a top grade does not indicate that i learned everything, but also that i learned it at the pace the teacher wanted it. if i fail the first test, i have lost any chance to make a top grade for the rest of the year, even if i catch up and maybe surpass others.
- curryst 7y agoThat assumes that everyone believes cheating is "simply wrong". Who is harmed by cheating? Unless you manage to cheat so well you blow the curve, you're not impacting anyone elses grades. And of course everyone has an incentive to cheat. Higher grades and lower time investment are the incentive. Those are basically universally appealing to college students. Having an incentive doesn't mean everyone is going to take the opportunity, as some feel it is wrong and others feel the risk doesn't justify the reward.
- em-bee 7y agosorry, i am not buying it. it is neither that everyone believes cheating is wrong, nor that everyone has an incentive to cheat. in my university there were no grades. only pass or fail. anyone who was not at risk of failing had no incentive to cheat whatsoever.
- unishark 7y agoThe word cheating pretty much means unethical practices by definition of the category. So obviously the people who make the rules consider it wrong. And someone needs to make a common set of rules for grades to mean anything. The student handbook is basically a contract which sets out the ethical system you agree to abide by. As for victims, ultimately you would probably defraud future employers presumably, by taking their money under false pretenses, and damage the school's reputation. Perhaps also kill people when the plane you designed crashes or something.
- mac01021 7y agoWho is harmed by cheating? Whoever is making decisions based on the outcome of the test. A school or professor risks it's reputation by graduating incompetent students. An employer who hires based on a false GPA risks wasting its money and time.