4 ms·
> Bumps on people's heads have nothing to do with violence. This is a non sequitur. I submit to you it's exactly as irrelevant as skin color. I submit to you i
by shadowgovt 7y ago
> Bumps on people's heads have nothing to do with violence. This is a non sequitur.
I submit to you it's exactly as irrelevant as skin color. I submit to you if you take the population that you have described, change only the category from "African American" to another category and nothing else, and kept the same population of people with no other parameters changed, you would not see a change in the violence rate.
Believing that measurable correlation implies causation is one of the major failings that I see often encouraged in the computer science space. It underpins some of the greatest failings of machine learning.
You made claims about population and then claims about interventions that suggest that the population membership is causal. What if the causal issue is poverty? Poverty in the United States is so deeply correlated with being a member of a racial category that it is extremely hard to disambiguate effects that show up in race from effects that show up in income and asset levels. This is what I mean when I say lies, damn lies, and statistics.
Because if the cause is poverty and not "African American culture," then violence interventions for African Americans are like "get your energy level up" interventions for people who are starving. You'll waste good money treating the wrong problem. You'll also miss people that also have the same problem but don't get any intervention because they don't fit the poorly-defined template.
- TA0x0 7y ago>I submit to you it's exactly as irrelevant as skin color. It quite possibly is. No one mentioned anything about skin color except you. >I submit to you if you take the population that you have described, change only the category from "African American" to another category and nothing else, and kept the same population of people with no other parameters changed, you would not see a change in the violence rate. This is a non sequitur tautological fallacy. Of course if you kept the population the same nothing would change. This is a poor attempt at strawmaning that still makes no sense. >Believing that measurable correlation implies causation is one of the major failings that I see often encouraged in the computer science space. There is no correlation here, it's an indisputable fact. Your major failing is your inability to understand these basic concepts, including correlation/causation because it's not even being used here. >You made claims about population and then claims about interventions that suggest that the population membership is causal. It's not a claim, it's a fact. Regardless of the suggestion of causality, YOU ASKED: Give an example theory, I did. Give an example policy, I did. Now you're moving the goalposts on "suggestions of population membership" which is immaterial to the points I made and proved above. >What if the causal issue is poverty? It could be, but it's totally immaterial to the facts I stated above. Again, it is a FACT that African Americans commit more crimes than Asian Americans. You can draw theories and propose policy from these basic FACTS, but the facts are not open to interpretation, which is what I claimed and proved above. >Poverty in the United States is so deeply correlated with being a member of a racial category that it is extremely hard to disambiguate effects that show up in race from effects that show up in income and asset levels. This is what I mean when I say lies, damn lies, and statistics. Immaterial to the discussion at hand, and may not even be correct, not that it matters. >Because if the cause is poverty and not "African American culture," then violence interventions for African Americans are like "get your energy level up" interventions for people who are starving. Makes no sense, and is immaterial to the discussion about the facts. They are the official ethnic group that is the most violent; if we are to target a specific group for ethnic-centric anti-violence training, the that is the best policy to go with from the basic hard facts laid above. QED. >You'll waste good money treating the wrong problem. You'll also miss people that also have the same problem but don't get any intervention because they don't fit the poorly-defined template. Except by definition it is treating the correct problem, and targeting the correct group. It's not poorly defined, it's fact based.
- shadowgovt 7y agoThe reasoning presented in this thread is pretty representative of the thought processes Damore laid out in his memo. Which is pretty indicative of why he was fired.
- TA0x0 7y ago>The reasoning presented in this thread is pretty representative of the thought processes Damore laid out in his memo. Logical, rational, built from facts. The thought process used by a Harvard grad, MIT research scientist. >Which is pretty indicative of why he was fired. "They hated him because he told the truth."
- shadowgovt 7y ago"Told the truth." LOL. Yep, the kind of truth that got him fired with cause so hard the NLRB wouldn't go to bat for him. Apparently, being a Harvard grad, MIT research scientist doesn't guarantee an understanding of how not to get fired. Oh well. Google can always replace him with another Harvard grad, MIT research scientist with a better ability to play well with others. That's the perk of being Google; you don't have to tolerate the semi-productive smart kid who alienates his co-workers with "facts" he thinks he understands but doesn't. :-p
- Gibbon1 7y agoThat's been my general thought. Legally a company can fire you for any reason except the ones they aren't allowed too. Trying to undermine a companies diversity policies on a company owned channel when said company already has public problem with diversity, good way to get 86'd.
- TA0x0 7y ago>"Told the truth." LOL. Yep, the kind of truth that got him fired with cause so hard the NLRB wouldn't go to bat for him. Correct, inconvenient truths. The NLRB actually agreed they were immutable facts, but stating them caused disruption; they were just making sure Google didn't break the law in firing him. Thanks for proving my point HAHAHAHAHA!!! >Apparently, being a Harvard grad, MIT research scientist doesn't guarantee an understanding of how not to get fired. Oh he understood, it's just higher order thinkers don't care about employment as much as being factual and correct. With his credentials he can always get another job. "It is the responsibility of intellectuals to speak the truth and expose lies." -Noam Chomsky >Google can always replace him with another Harvard grad, MIT research scientist with a better ability to play well with others. Another grad that's more willing to toe the line, and not speak their mind. A win for the corporatists, loss for the truth of course. >That's the perk of being Google; you don't have to tolerate the semi-productive smart kid who alienates his co-workers with "facts" he thinks he understands but doesn't They don't have to tolerate the exceptionally intelligent people who aren't afraid to speak the truth; they're willing to let go of those who speak the facts. Not like you'd understand these concepts anyway, higher order thinkers don't need to toe the line to make a living :D