3 ms·
A note on Deno and the safety of its V8 bindings: > All of the V8 source code is distributed in the crate itself. Finally rusty_v8 attempts to be a safe interf
by rvz 7y ago
A note on Deno and the safety of its V8 bindings:
> All of the V8 source code is distributed in the crate itself. Finally rusty_v8 attempts to be a safe interface. It's not yet 100% safe, but we're getting close. Being able to interact with a VM as complex as V8 in a safe way is quite amazing and has allowed us to discover many difficult bugs in Deno itself.
We'll also have to wait on who will be the first to have a production ready Javascript Engine written in Rust that could replace V8, if you're talking about safety.
Even with the "safe" bindings, you will still get the same C and C++ vulnerabilities found in V8 that will also be present in Deno.
- ahupp 7y agoFor this sort of problem Rust's safety guarantees don't buy you all that much. If you're generating machine code and implementing a GC that's not the sort of thing that Rust's typesystem can prove correct. That said, a rust JS runtime would be amazing just because it's easier to integrate into rust projects.
- klodolph 7y agoWell, sure, but a big chunk of the bugs in JRE were in the library, not the code generation or GC.
- ahupp 7y agoSpeaking of: Neon, a system for writing Node libraries in Rust is pretty cool: https://neon-bindings.com/ https://neon-bindings.com/
- jchw 7y agoNot sure exactly how much it buys you but I suspect there’s still room for research especially since Mozilla themselves has interest in a Rust JS JIT. I am curious to see if HolyJIT goes anywhere and what kinds of safety improvements it could potentially offer.
- afiori 7y agoDeno plans to not expose V8 internals, unlike node. I do not know where the V8 vulnerabilities came from, but it should decrease the attack surface.