4 ms·
Not really, no. The human perception of colour is fundamentally three-dimensional. In order to describe a perceived colour, no matter the system you choose, you
by sudosysgen 7y ago
Not really, no. The human perception of colour is fundamentally three-dimensional. In order to describe a perceived colour, no matter the system you choose, you need three dimensions. For example, you could use frequency and amplitude of a light wave, but that would only be sufficient for pure tones, leading to the need of a third dimension - saturation - for "impurity".
Or you could use a B-L B-R pair for tone and a third component for Luma - three-dimensional.
Or you can give the amplitude of Red, Green and Blue; three dimensions.
You could add a fourth dimension, RGB+Luma, but the fourth dimension is useless in describing a given perceived colour, as the activation of the intensity receptor is a function of the activation of the three colour receptors, it is only there for high-gain situations.
Sound is not one-dimensional, as simply considering the pressure of a point is insufficient as a description of sound perception of humans. Indeed, we perceive variations in pressure, not pressure itself (consider the balancing of the pressure of the inner ear). In order to understand sound, you fundamentally need two dimensions, either pressure and time, or frequency and amplitude. This is only for an instantaneous perception of sound, in order to record "a sound", you need three dimensions. Although you could indeed plot a time-series of pressures, this does not describe what actually is happening - for a time-series of pressures to be interpreted as a recorded sound you necessarily need a sample rate, otherwise the physical interpretations are infinite. This is why a spectrogram is three-dimensional - frequency, amplitude, and time. Hence, the sounds we operate on and process are three-dimensional, as any representation of a sound is tridimensional, either a time series of pressure, time and sample rate, or a continuous spectrum of time, frequency and amplitude.
- fsh 7y agoThis is not how any of this works. Sound simply is a variation of pressure over time, hence a one-dimensional signal (in classical physics, time is not considered a dimension). Sampling is simply a way of approximating this continuous signal on a digital computer. A music instrument doesn't have a sample rate and neither have your ears.
- sudosysgen 7y agoYour ears do have a sample rate. They are bandwidth limited, which is the same thing as having a sample rate. While in classical physics, time is not considered a dimension, if you what you want to do is encode a signal, or construct a mathematical model, time is very much a dimension.
- fsh 7y agoSorry, but this is completely wrong. Analog systems, such as human ears, can be band-limited but do not have a sample rate. In fact, any digital recording system requires analog lowpass-filtering to avoid aliasing. Otherwise, the original (analog) signal cannot be accurately reproduced from the samples. Of course you are free to use a different definition of "dimension" than the rest of the world. But this won't help making discussions any easier.
- sudosysgen 7y agoA digital signal with a sample rate of 1000hz is an exact representation of an analog signal with a bandwidth of 500hz. The low-pass filter is just part of how you would build a DAC. If you want to use the physics definition of dimensions in a discussion about colourspaces that has nothing to do with physics jargon, that's ok. If you want to represent amplitude over time, you need two dimensions. There is no graphical representation of sound that can be done in less than two dimensions for this reason. If you want to graphically represent the human perception of sound, you need three dimensions, that correspond to frequency, amplitude and time.