4 ms·
> It's not a target because it is a library catalog. Oh! That's actually a great little encapsulation of the larger problem here. Before COVID hit, I was a vo
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
> It's not a target because it is a library catalog.
Oh! That's actually a great little encapsulation of the larger problem here.
Before COVID hit, I was a volunteer teacher at a Girls Who Code class at a library. Most of the library's computers were running Windows 7, which of course lost security updates in January.
One of the other volunteers remarked: "Someone needs to update those to Windows 10."
I answered: "Someone should update them, yes. But no one is going to."
I don't even know if those old laptops could run Windows 10. Should the library really spend money on replacing all of them? As opposed to buying books, or teaching more students?
---
There was an article on Hacker News some time back about how the NYC subway system runs OS/2. A lot commenters said this is a huge security risk—sure, it's ostensibly not connected to the internet, but who really knows?
But, what should be done about it? It doesn't make sense to switch out the architecture of a city's subway system every 30 years—I'm not convinced it makes sense even every 50 or 100 years. How do you set up a system like that?
- Silhouette 7y agoWe have some machines that still run Windows 7 at the office, while we don't use Windows 10 for anything beyond isolated testing environments. This is a result of assessing the risks of using Windows 10 as being greater overall than the risks of using Windows 7 in the relevant cases, despite the state of official support and lack of any further security patches. And that in turn is in no small part because Windows 10 has a track record of breaking things that would be important to our business operations. Newer is not always better, and being more secure in some respects is not always being more useful overall.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoFor your office specifically, have you looked into Windows 10 LTSC? That's my solution when I need to run Windows at home.
- Silhouette 7y agoYes, we did. The higher editions of Windows 10 do seem to be qualitatively different products that don't have the technical deal-breakers we are concerned about. Unfortunately, as far as we could tell, there was no (legal, properly supported) way to get hold of any of them for small businesses like ours through simple one-off purchases of permanent licences.
- EvanAnderson 7y agoI have a lot I experience navigating Microsoft's licensing for small businesses. I have a Customer who needed Windows 10 LTSC for some PCs running expensive laboratory instruments as a recent example of needing to do just what you're looking for. You can acquire a permanent license for Windows 10 LTSC through Microsoft's Open Business licensing program. There is a minimum initial purchase quantity of 5 SKUs, but any competent reseller will just pad your order with the lowest-price-in-the-catalog SKU to get you up to that minimum. The Open License Agreement itself expires in two years, meaning that you're subject to the minimum 5 SKU purchase to start a new one at the end of 2 years. During the term of the Agreement you can purchase licenses piecemeal. Regardless of the Agreement's term the software you license thru the program is perpetually licensed. This won't make it any cheaper, though. Windows 10 LTSC is ridiculously expensive, to me, for what it is. Licenses acquired through this program are transferable to new hardware, at least. That's why I used it a lot over the years. Buying Office and transferring it to a new PC once in the useful life ended up being a cost savings over buying OEM Office with the original and replacement PCs.
- at_a_remove 7y agoThis is very helpful. I've bought a couple of LTSBs (now LTSC) over the years through oddball means, I strongly favor it, but it seems like Microsoft doesn't want me to be able to buy the licenses. Finding less shady-seeming resellers has not been something I've been able to manage. I agree, they're costly.
- Silhouette 7y agoThank you for sharing those insights. The idea that you have to go through a dealer, join some overcomplicated volume licensing programme, possibly buy extra stuff, and probably pay a premium for the privilege just to get a legitimate copy of LTSC to use doesn't sit well with us. If Microsoft offered LTSC as a one-time, off-the-shelf purchase with no strings attached, I expect we'd buy several copies immediately. It seems to be the only version of Windows 10 we might actually want, other than for having the same as our customers/clients for testing purposes. But as a small business, we have limited time and resources, and we have remarkably little interest in playing big business games.