12 ms·
In the past, I have always looked at Demos from Games and thought this is very good and getting close to movie quality. But that "close to" remained "close to"
by ksec 7y ago
In the past, I have always looked at Demos from Games and thought this is very good and getting close to movie quality. But that "close to" remained "close to" for quite some time. Even though It is improving every year but you can still tell it is gaming graphics. Even if some of the shots are not real time and pre rendered, they are still gaming like.
That Unreal 5 Demo was the first time ever I thought this is Hollywood Movie quality GFX ..... ( Apart from the Character ). IT IS STUNNING! And this is done Real time on PS5!
Edit: I am sorry for the tone and block capitals.... I am seriously geeking out.
- guilamu 7y agoWell, I may be wrong, but I was under the impression that the Unreal Engine will also work on the next XBOX (and any PC) and that the PS5 was less powerfull than the next XBOX.
- ksec 7y agoYes, it isn't specific to PS5. I was only mentioning PS5 because it is not the most powerful machine of all and we are already capable of that.
- skohan 7y agoIt remains to be seen how the PS5 and the new XBox compare in terms of performance. The specs of the new XBox are slightly higher on paper, but the PS5 is doing some really interesting things in terms of optimization. Basically the XBox is going for high constant clock speeds, and the PS5 is shifting priority between the CPU and GPU components of the SOC so each gets boosted performance when it's most relevant. Both consoles are doing very interesting things with asset streaming and decompression of assets directly from the SSD to video memory which are going to open up new opportunities not only in visual quality, but in terms of how flexibly game worlds can be designed. Probably we will have to wait and see how all of this plays out in terms of real-world performance.
- rowanG077 7y agoHighly dangerous of the PS people to build non-deterministic performance into their console. Developers who try to push every ounce of power out of it will hate it. edit: Maybe deterministic isn't the correct word. What I mean is that you can design a physics system that you can ensure runs on the PS5 CPU. But then the graphics boys make an upgrade and suddenly some power is diverted to the graphics and the physics system is no longer working correctly. This is still deterministic. But a nightmare to work with when optimizing for hard-real time requirements. The only way this can be done sanely is if the developers can fix this power budget and thus restore "determinism".
- didibus 7y agoIt sounded like they managed to make it deterministic by keeping the power draw always the same and fixing the cooling solution to handle max load. So developer can expect it to perform identical to whatever balance they've set between CPU/GPU. That's my understanding at least.
- rowanG077 7y agoIf the developer can control the balance then it's fine. If this balance cannot be controlled by the developers then it's a nightmare. It's not clear to me this is developer controlled.
- iMark 7y agoMark Cerny's tech talk emphasised that performance is determistic: 'So how does boost work in this case? Put simply, the PlayStation 5 is given a set power budget tied to the thermal limits of the cooling assembly. "It's a completely different paradigm," says Cerny. "Rather than running at constant frequency and letting the power vary based on the workload, we run at essentially constant power and let the frequency vary based on the workload."' https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-2020-playstation-5-specs-and-tech-that-deliver-sonys-next-gen-vision https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-2020-plays...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ingenieros 7y ago"As for Microsoft’s Xbox Series X, Sweeney isn’t saying the new Xbox won’t be able to achieve something similar; both are using custom SSDs that promise blazing speeds. But he says Epic’s strong relationship with Sony means the company is working more closely with the PlayStation creator than it does with Microsoft on this specific area."
- rasz 7y agoThat just means they got paid to say it.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoI think with every engine- or console generation people will go "this is photorealistic!", but in practice / real games it doesn't look / feel that way, or (maybe more likely) you get used to it until you run into the next best thing. That said, The Mandalorian has used the Unreal engine to render real-time backgrounds for scenes, so it's good enough for that at least. And in films they don't need to do real-time, they can take their time to render a scene.
- jfoster 7y agoIn this demo I thought it "didn't feel that way" more due to the camera positioning and character than anything else, though. The environment seemed quite indistinguishable from pre-rendered CGI.
- skohan 7y agoA highly scripted tech demo is also not such an accurate representation of what real-world results are going to look like. Yes they can render it in-engine, but they can use bespoke character animations which don't have any blending artifacts, and they can put the camera on a rail and tune the assets and particle effects until they are certain every single frame can be rendered in under 16ms. They can hide billboards and other rendering tricks and be certain the camera is never going to hit them at an angle which gives them away. Real-world game play scenarios are much more unpredictable, and the results are likely to fall well shy of this mark.
- MrScruff 7y agoIt definitely wasn't indistinguishable from pre-rendered CGI, there are a lot of shadow artifacts for one thing. It looks great but we get this ever few years from the real time people - they're amazing at picking off the low hanging fruit of offline rendering and finding a quality compromised solution that can work in realtime, but they're chasing a moving target.
- ubercow13 7y agoIt's definitely impressive but kind of obviously not pre-rendered still. There is quite some aliasing in smaller details of the more complex objects and the edges of shadows aren't soft. The water effects looked quite bad still.
- swalsh 7y agoUnreal is now starting to be used in place of green screens in some movies. (there's a lot more that goes into it, but essentially it seems like unreal is one of the core software pieces) Here is an example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hjb-AqMD-a4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hjb-AqMD-a4
- jotm 7y agoAmazing, the future of this tech is just exciting
- centimeter 7y agoThe Mandalorian filmed a lot of scenes with UE4 doing real-time rendering onto large LED screens like in that demo. Looked pretty good! Probably more fun and easier for the actors too.
- miohtama 7y agoHere is how the production looked https://youtu.be/gUnxzVOs3rk https://youtu.be/gUnxzVOs3rk
- diimdeep 7y agoIncredible. Replace green screen with real time rendered scene. Truman Show IRL.
- ngold 7y agoWe are getting closer to wallpaper and screen meaning the same thing.
- m3at 7y agoIf you're interested, this was a good article going into details of what's happening behind the scene for the real time rendering: https://ascmag.com/articles/the-mandalorian https://ascmag.com/articles/the-mandalorian
- 7y ago
- nabla9 7y agoTriangles that are just one pixel in the screen, dynamic lightning and overall rendering this close to photorealism, it's the all the other aspects of the games that limit the experience. Physics engine, character movement, etc. could still be improved.
- majora2007 7y agoDid you watch the video? Because they also have improved the audio system, chaos engine and animations drastically.
- nabla9 7y agoYes, and you can clearly see that they have not reached at the same level of realism as the rendering.
- globular-toast 7y agoThe quality of the graphics make the lack of realism in the animations more jarring for me. When the character touches a surface it just doesn't look in the slightest. It's quite frustrating actually. My brain seems ready to see realistic contact but instead sees a body moving around unnaturally near a surface that its supposed to be in contact with.
- driverdan 7y agoKeep in mind it's contending with YouTube compression too. A lot of the artifacts you see around the character and other moving objects are likely compression artifacts.
- Shivetya 7y agothe water effects just after the four minute mark looked odd. while the fixed assets like the statues and such later on looked great. however I kept going back to the water and questioning some of the lighting effects too. don't get me wrong, the fixed assets look amazing and I look forward to seeing more done with this system
- explorigin 7y agoWater, dust, cloth and hair physics are all still in the uncanny valley...not to take away from the tremendous progress with triangles and lighting!
- bt1a 7y agoI thought the scarf movement looked great.
- explorigin 7y agoNot to me. It was too stiff which caused it to move in some unnatural ways.
- robotdongs 7y agoIt didn’t seem to reflect well the way cloth moves when sliding across another piece of cloth. When she was climbing, I’d expect the scarf to sort of wrinkle/bunch up, then fall to her side, not just cleanly slide off. However I could see them adjusting the physics for the demo to ensure the cloth actually fell by her side so we could see it swaying as she climbed.
- SahAssar 7y agoReally? To me it felt like it was in the uncanny valley for cloth. When climbing it seemed to cling to at certain distance from the body at all times, like it had a certain range it could swing to/from the body but could not exceed.
- 7y ago
- jfoster 7y agoIt's strange that the character wasn't more photorealistic in this demo. If you Google Image search you can find more photorealistic characters from previous versions of the Unreal Engine. I wonder if there might be some trade-off being made between photorealistic character and lifelike character movement.
- skohan 7y agoI suspect it's a way to avoid the uncanny valley, and serves to highlight the photo realistic quality of the environments even more.
- onli 7y agoI assumed the same. If you also make the character more realistic you run into the risk of making the demo eve more unbelievable. Now there are some hints that underline their claim that it runs on a PS5, like some videogame like animation transitions, character movements and the character model itself.
- extesy 7y agoIt was done on purpose, similar to how Pixar movies have obviously cartoony and unrealistic characters in an otherwise photo-realistic environment.
- uryga 7y agothe problem isn't that her design is a bit stylized; it's that her face looks kind of... not-face-like in closeups. (missing some shininess & subsurface scattering imo). it's different from e.g. Moana, where skin is kind of marzipan-y, but still recognizably skin-like
- pythonaut_16 7y agoThis is the best way to do graphics IMO. Instead of pushing the tech to its limits and landing in the uncanny valley, it's better to back off a bit from the limits of the tech and perfectly execute a more stylized result.
- simias 7y agoAt the risk of sounding a bit negative I personally find that graphics have plateaued since about the PS3. Sure, there are more polys, sure, there are higher res textures, sure, there are more complex and dynamic lights. But you don't really have the kind of gap we used to have between, say, the PS1 and PS2 for instance. Diminishing returns and all that. The problem is that, in my experience, this eye candy only matters for about 10 minutes when you get into a game, then you stop really paying attention to how it looks and you focus on the gameplay and story etc... Meanwhile all the dynamic stuff is still fairly primitive IMO. At around 4 minute in the video they briefly mention the water effects. They don't really spend a lot of time on them and for a good reason, they don't look particularly good. When I was a kid in the 90s I definitely expected future games to look a lot better, but I also expect gameplay and world interaction to progress massively. Fully interactive environments you can interact with like in the real world. You could destroy everything, dig holes, build things, have advanced physics, great AI for NPCs etc... It saddens me that the AAA video game industry is almost entirely focused on eye candy first and foremost. That being said I concede that I'm clearly in the minority, after all the Uncharted games are generally considered to be good games when I find them incredibly boring. I hope that now that we can reach near-photorealism in games they'll have to come up with something new to keep pushing the envelope.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoYour only commentary here is that it doesn't live up to your expectations. You wanted more. And then you wonder why AAA studios focus on graphics? > That being said I concede that I'm clearly in the minority You definitely aren't in the minority. r/gaming is full of people racing to be most unimpressed by a good looking game. All the HN comments pointing out flaws with "don't get me wrong, it looks decent!" could be predicted the second I read the submission title.
- skohan 7y agoMaybe it's just because I am old enough to remember playing Super Mario on a CRT, but that attitude sometimes astounds me. Like I have read many assessments that the latest Doom game's incredible framerates are nothing to be impressed by, because the game is "visually underwhelming". I think a lot of people don't understand how difficult real-time computer graphics are to implement, and I have difficulty viewing the world through their eyes.
- sevencolors 7y agoMaybe i just don't play many games where a camera tracks a single player like the demo. But the camera tracking felt jerky. Is that normal?
- barbecue_sauce 7y agoDepends on the game, and camera logic is usually up to developers rather than the game engine so sensitivity can be fairly flexible.
- elihu 7y agoI think it's the global illumination that really makes the difference. You can't get to realism just by drawing more polygons, but if light acts in believable ways (especially when the scene changes or lights move around) it really starts to look like real life.
- eslaught 7y agoThe graphics are better, but camera and animations are a dead giveaway. It was fine when the camera was relatively static and far away, but shots with more movement became really noticeable. (Watch carefully, you can see the character's hand go through the rock in some places, or not make full contact in others. Once you notice it's hard to un-see.) I'm sure this is all fixable, but some part of me wonders how much larger game budgets will have to become (or correspondingly, how much less content will be offered) in order to achieve the new standard in production qualities.
- grogenaut 7y ago- no shadows on the scarabs - obvious SSAO when hand touched the rock wall - odd reflections on the bird sculptures - down-resing of textures and motion blur when she flew - obvious uncanny valley face (pancake makeup, no subsurface scattering) on face closeup - dust sprite clouds were some of the things I noticed on my first watch but it was still quite pretty. like what I'd expect uncharted 5 on the pc to look like
- uryga 7y agoalso, the spinning shiny smoke in the portal looked like it's just a bunch of flat rotating textures
- grogenaut 7y agoaah, yeah but it was damned gorgeous :) it was on many different planes
- robocat 7y ago> motion blur when she flew I think that was intended and programmed into the clip on purpose - not a side-effect of a poor engine.
- grogenaut 7y agoSure but it was still "engine motion blur" not real motion blur. Just like SSAO is fake shadows and noticeable.
- tanilama 7y agothe character is still quite unconvincing