4 ms·
The answer to this is to increase the housing supply. People have been saying that for decades but we seem unable to achieve it. Meanwhile the proportion of pe
by tonyedgecombe 7y ago
The answer to this is to increase the housing supply.
People have been saying that for decades but we seem unable to achieve it. Meanwhile the proportion of people in rented accommodation has been increasing and the proportion of home owners has been falling.
Perviously landlords in the UK were getting a tax advantage that home owners didn't have access to. This seems to be slowly shifting.
Buying property and renting it out is expected to yield returns. There's nothing wrong with that.
Actually I think there is something wrong with that. Personally I won't use my easy access to capital to deny the younger generation the ability to buy a house in the way I was able to.
- sokoloff 7y agoLots and lots of people are better off renting than buying and those people need to have a supply of housing. If no one can make money renting properties, where will this supply of rental properties come from?
- fennecfoxen 7y agoNYCHA, of course. (This is a joke. Unfortunately, the joke is on NYCHA residents, and on those priced out of apartments.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jeffbee 7y agohttps://thetyee.ca/Solutions/2018/06/06/Vienna-Housing-Affordability-Case-Cracked/ https://thetyee.ca/Solutions/2018/06/06/Vienna-Housing-Affor...
- truckerbill 7y agoCo-operatives should be more of a thing for starters.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoSome people are better off renting but right now we have a lot of people in middle age with families who are stuck with insecure housing. It's bad enough now but it's going to become a nightmare when they get to retirement age. The UK had a pretty good housing situation that was developed after the end of the second world war. It was disassembled by Thatcher.
- djmobley 7y agoThe primary constraint on housing supply in most developed economies is planning restrictions, and those could be lifted with the stroke of a pen. Allow densification, abolish green belts, reduce the friction and cost of obtaining planning permission, etc. The solution is simple, but it’s not politically viable when a majority of the population have a vested interest in property prices remaining high.
- entropicdrifter 7y agoIt's not a majority of the population, it's a majority of the wealthy that have the vested interest. It just so happens that in the UK and US (among others), the wealthy get significantly more sway than anyone else.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoWell no, there is actually a specific problem causing this -- most of these rules are at the local level and the people who get a vote in the local assembly are... local residents. Who are predominantly local homeowners. The home ownership rate in the US is ~65%. Since they already own a home, they want the price to go up rather than down, so they vote for that, and they still outnumber the tenants. Meanwhile the prospective new homeowners don't get a vote in the local elections because they don't live there yet. In theory this shouldn't happen in local areas where the tenants outnumber the homeowners, but then some jackass invented rent control for those areas, thereby giving the existing tenants an interest in maintaining the status quo and once again screwing over new tenants and prospective homeowners.
- jgwil2 7y agoWhy would living in a rent-controlled dwelling incentivize a tenant to constrain supply? If a new building goes up next door to me it's not going to make my rent go up.
- bhupy 7y agoRent-control doesn't incentivize a tenant to constrain supply. Tenants are incentivized to vote for rent control (for obvious reasons), and rent control has the unintended consequence of restricting supply — on average developers construct less housing in markets with rent controls than those without, relative to the demand. https://www.nber.org/papers/w24181 https://www.nber.org/papers/w24181
- lotsofpulp 7y ago> People have been saying that for decades but we seem unable to achieve it. That’s because for decades, we’ve also been destroying low volatility, decent paying jobs via outsourcing and automation and concentrating high paying secure employment into fewer regions.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoBut big property companies still have that tax advantage
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> People have been saying that for decades but we seem unable to achieve it. The people who have been saying that for decades have been right. The problem isn't that it doesn't work, it's that we haven't done it. > Meanwhile the proportion of people in rented accommodation has been increasing and the proportion of home owners has been falling. Not meanwhile, because of. Demand has been growing faster than supply for decades. > Actually I think there is something wrong with that. Personally I won't use my easy access to capital to deny the younger generation the ability to buy a house in the way I was able to. But that's not what's doing that. The only way you could get someone to rent who otherwise would have been able to buy is by offering them a better deal. You can't just outbid them because without supply constraints, higher prices would result in more construction, and then that person would have a new house built instead of having to outbid you on the existing stock. Meanwhile there are are still people who need somewhere to live and can't afford a down payment yet.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoBut there are supply constraints, there is a finite amount of land to build on as well as a planning system and a cabal of builders banking land. Meanwhile there are are still people who need somewhere to live and can't afford a down payment yet. Nobody said there isn't, there will always be people for whom renting makes sense. But right now there are a lot of people where they would much rather buy the property they are in than rent it.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> there is a finite amount of land to build on This isn't the problem until the zoning prohibits tall buildings. > as well as a planning system and a cabal of builders banking land. The planning system is the problem. Reforming it is the solution. > But right now there are a lot of people where they would much rather buy the property they are in than rent it. So what's stopping them? High prices as a result of supply constraints, right?
- bhupy 7y ago> But there are supply constraints, there is a finite amount of land to build on as well as a planning system and a cabal of builders banking land. While you're right that there is a finite amount of land, we haven't even come close to reaching the practical limit of how much housing we can construct on that land: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/laissez-faire-in-tokyo.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/la...