7 ms·
The answer to this is to increase the housing supply. Housing costs increase when demand increases and supply doesn't. Increase supply at the same time and rent
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
The answer to this is to increase the housing supply. Housing costs increase when demand increases and supply doesn't. Increase supply at the same time and rents don't increase faster than inflation.
Buying property and renting it out is expected to yield returns. There's nothing wrong with that. It actually increases access to housing by allowing people who can't afford to buy property to still live somewhere in the meantime. The problem is when you're not just buying a $200,000 house whose value tracks inflation and renting it out, but buying a $200,000 house as the value quintuples and all of that money goes to the landlord while the tenant's rent quintuples as well.
- popotamonga 7y agoThere is only so much you can increase the supply without being hours away from the jobs. Plus the rich can just buy any new supply quickly and we are back to the same.
- jeffbee 7y agoHrmm. Speaking of my town, Berkeley, California, the housing supply has been almost static since 1950, the number of jobs in town is now double the number of employed people (prior to pandemic), and virtually all land is zoned for detached single-family dwellings. Increasing the supply in this town would be as easy as the stroke of a pen, and would bring people closer to, not further from their jobs.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> There is only so much you can increase the supply without being hours away from the jobs. Nonsense. We can build 100 story buildings but there is nowhere in the world you can find a hundred square miles covered in nothing but 100 story buildings. > Plus the rich can just buy any new supply quickly and we are back to the same. So the rich are going to buy the new supply and do what with it? If they rent it out, supply still goes up. They have to compete with each other for tenants. If they don't, wow -- huge profit opportunity building hundred story buildings and selling them to rich idiots who are willing to pay top dollar for something they get no returns from. Do that until they run out of money.
- fzeroracer 7y agoThe rich can buy out the new supply and either use it for things like AirBnB (which then just displaces people who need an actual place to stay) or they sit on the property and grow their investment over time because of how limited land is in metro areas. See: Warehousing [1]. Or they just keep those additional units in said building empty, because it would be more of a pain to convert them to residential units when mixed commercial earns easy revenue. The idea that the rich get no profit from sitting on buildings is wrong. [1] https://www.brickunderground.com/rent/why-landlords-leave-apartments-empty https://www.brickunderground.com/rent/why-landlords-leave-ap...
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> The rich can buy out the new supply and either use it for things like AirBnB (which then just displaces people who need an actual place to stay) This is fine, then you don't need as many hotels and can convert those those to permanent housing. It's not as if there is unlimited demand for short term rentals. > or they sit on the property and grow their investment over time because of how limited land is in metro areas. Which only works because construction is not actually happening, so sitting on the properties is profitable because the value appreciates over time. Build enough that values at least stop increasing and that stops being profitable. Notice also that your article is talking about a vacancy rate of 3.45%. If you increased the housing supply by 50%, do you really think they're going to buy all of it and let it sit vacant? And the best actual reason the article lists for why landlords do this is that their building is rent-controlled and they correspondingly want to convert it to condos and sell it, because that's more profitable, but first they need to get rid of the existing tenants, which implies not replacing them when they leave/die. So the reason the building is half empty for decades is the economic implications of rent control, not some plot by landlords to lose money.
- fzeroracer 7y agoThe crux of your argument seems to be that property grows in value because there's not enough housing, which seems like a reasonable assumption but is just that. Property grows in value because of its proximity to other things of value, not because of the amount of it on the market. If you were to expand the size of NYC to encompass the entirety of New York, housing inside of NYC is going to be vastly more valuable than housing located on the edges of the state. No amount of construction you do is going to devalue that property, and often you can't build upwards because of the rich property owners (see: NIMBY) choosing to use their financial leverage and property ownership to deny that.
- woah 7y agoYou can build multi-story buildings. If there are more apartments than renters then landlords will have to compete to offer lower rent.
- Joeboy 7y agoThe quintupling occurs largely because landlords are bidding against each other. Which doesn't increase the housing supply, just the rent.
- Brakenshire 7y agoIt’s because housing supply is limited and interest rates are low. People will bid against one another until the reach the limit of their ability to pay, and low interest rates mean the payments are low for large mortgages. To reduce prices you will either need to increase interest rates or increase the housing supply.
- cko 7y agoLandlords are bidding against each other because of limited supply. People with excess capital need it to go somewhere. Stocks, bonds, real estate. It's like complaining people who buy stocks are bidding up the prices. While true, there is no vitriol against stockholders vs real estate owners. One could even argue that buying real estate does more for the economy than buying stocks - you are liquidating a developer to build more properties, and banks to give loans. Buying stocks... I guess drives up the stock price, allowing the company to borrow more money?
- abeppu 7y agoThis is totally the problem. The desire of investors to treat real estate as a speculative opportunity has taken a front seat, and pushed out the fundamental reality that homes are for people to live in. You see less vitriol against shareholders bidding up stock prices b/c buying a fixed amount of stock isn't a necessity -- lots of people just don't do it. But everyone needs housing. To make a different comparison, in the 2007 food crisis, when poor harvests combined with sudden enthusiasm for making ethanol from corn helped drive up food prices around the world, there was some quite legitimate vitriol. You might think the high prices help produce more grain next year (analogous to your developers). I don't think that's actually true, I'm not sure -- but even if it were, it did little to help people during the crisis.
- 7y ago
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThe answer to this is to increase the housing supply. People have been saying that for decades but we seem unable to achieve it. Meanwhile the proportion of people in rented accommodation has been increasing and the proportion of home owners has been falling. Perviously landlords in the UK were getting a tax advantage that home owners didn't have access to. This seems to be slowly shifting. Buying property and renting it out is expected to yield returns. There's nothing wrong with that. Actually I think there is something wrong with that. Personally I won't use my easy access to capital to deny the younger generation the ability to buy a house in the way I was able to.
- sokoloff 7y agoLots and lots of people are better off renting than buying and those people need to have a supply of housing. If no one can make money renting properties, where will this supply of rental properties come from?
- fennecfoxen 7y agoNYCHA, of course. (This is a joke. Unfortunately, the joke is on NYCHA residents, and on those priced out of apartments.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jeffbee 7y agohttps://thetyee.ca/Solutions/2018/06/06/Vienna-Housing-Affordability-Case-Cracked/ https://thetyee.ca/Solutions/2018/06/06/Vienna-Housing-Affor...
- truckerbill 7y agoCo-operatives should be more of a thing for starters.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoSome people are better off renting but right now we have a lot of people in middle age with families who are stuck with insecure housing. It's bad enough now but it's going to become a nightmare when they get to retirement age. The UK had a pretty good housing situation that was developed after the end of the second world war. It was disassembled by Thatcher.
- jesusthatsgreat 7y agoHow do you increase supply in densely populated cities with extremely strict planning laws & regulations? The solution is to ban short term leasing in cities, increase taxes on sales of property within a certain timeframe and increase taxes on owners who have a property with nobody registered to live in it. Basically you don't want people buying property to flip it quickly, to hoard it or to have a holiday home. You only want buyers who'll live in the property and/or rent it long term.
- jeffbee 7y agoThis is the utilization theory of dwellings, which I think is bunk. Actual utilization is over 90% in California cities, so fiddling with vacant and underused properties can only make a small difference while being rather difficult to achieve. 10% vacancy is actually desirable because it makes the marketplace work. Land, on the other hand, is severely underused. Zoning changes could easily triple the housing supply in American cities. That's a lot better than 5-10%.
- fennecfoxen 7y agoI am routinely amazed by the the hoops people are willing jump through to avoid the simple answer of "building more apartments." High end estimates of AirBnB apartments are about 4% of units in the most popular neighborhoods -- Times Square, the East Village, Williamsburg. Drift out to Park Slope and you can see 2%, maybe. House hoarding? Very few people pay a mortgage for empty space when they can get a tenant to pay the mortgage instead. The real house hoarding is the high end luxury market with $20 million penthouses, where renters were never in the picture. We don't need to free up 4-5% more units in the most popular neighborhoods. It'll help a little, yes? It's just that it's such pathetically small thinking. Why don't we have a plan to build 50% more units citywide, and make housing actually affordable? Hell, it's New York. Build us 100% more apartments. Put real price reductions on the table. Do what it takes to chop rental prices in half.
- MrPatan 7y agoOr you could change those extemely strict planning laws and regulations.
- 7y ago
- gadders 7y agoOr you could reduce housing demand by putting limits on immigration.
- lucideer 7y ago> The answer to this is to increase the housing supply I'm not sure what you mean by "increase housing supply": there are many ways to do this, some simple, some complex and challenging. If you simply mean "build more houses" (this is the most common answer I see), that comes from an oversimplified view of the the market. Too much for a HN comment but some variables to consider: - financialisation of residential property affects vacancy rates (and by extension market supply). When selling and renting aren't the only two options for extracting value from residential property, the equation becomes a lot more complex. - tourism is another obvious one: while tourism is economically nice, it's not a stable source (see current crisis) and overtourism negatively impacts many aspects of society, housing supply being just one of them. Building more housing without accompanying measures means slightly more AirBnB, further overtourism and accompanying negatives. - urban planning. A lot of supply problems are regional, and caaused largely by poorly planned distribution of services, and places of work. Building more in one area will lead to an oversupply in another area where infrastructural change could simply relocate demand.
- fennecfoxen 7y agoYes, it means "build more houses". Cutting tourism and changing financing won't chop NYC rents in half. Expanding supply to meet the demand will. (Even if you cut them in half, it'd still be expensive.) Yes, this means more infrastructure. Unfortunately, this does mean actually spending money on that infrastructure, instead of spending it on incompetence and/or corruption, and I fully admit this may be impossible. ($4.5 billion for three new stops on Second Avenue? That's 9x the cost of the Golden Gate Bridge. Yes, adjusted for inflation.)
- lucideer 7y agoI've re-read your comment a few times now and I've failed to find any justification for your position. I get that you believe building more houses will solve the issue, but I can't see where you've said why you think that or why I'm wrong here. No, it won't solve it because it's a simplistic one-dimensional answer to a complex multifaceted economic problem. I've listed some of these complexities. Would building housing be a component of some successful solution: highly likely. But it wouldn't even make up the majority of such a solution.
- ethbro 7y agoIncrease the housing supply in certain ways. One of the things that drives me nuts about my town is (1) 90% of new, non-SFH development is rental, (2) new, non-SFH development is only in the upper price ranges, & (3) renovations are actively converting low range SFH stock into higher priced stock. I understand this is good for the city (tax revenue+, especially via SFH up-valuing, given that school demand will be unchanged), but it paints a pretty grim "in 10 years" picture. As a landlord myself (hobbyist), it's 100% unfair that someone is paying me wages they earn, because they don't have other good options. People should, at minimum, be able to realistically earn equity in their own homes. Full stop. Looking holistically at the entire chain: ownable, dense, affordable housing needs to be created. To do so, cities should use their leverage to reprioritize builders' incentives: decrease the permitting (and anything else) burden for such stock, and mandate ratios of own:rent and affordable:unaffordable for projects (it'd be fine to create and trade credits!).
- hirundo 7y ago> As a landlord myself (hobbyist) You're a private landlord, but not for the money? I don't think I've heard of that before. What do you get out of it instead? You actually enjoy the process? I haven't been a landlord, but I worked for one doing the things he would have had to do if he couldn't afford to pay me to do it. Repair, maintenance, sales, evictions. I can't imagine doing that stuff for pleasure, but it takes all kinds.
- ethbro 7y agoLet's say the amount of money I make from landlording isn't material income, partly by ethical choice. It's a hobby that interests me to learn about, but not one I'd say I currently enjoy, past the learning. I strictly rent to <= 2 degrees of separation from friends / family, which helps with evictions. And am currently renting to a newly married couple in their 20s, as it makes me happy to rent more stable housing than they could otherwise afford.
- epistasis 7y agoWhat you describe seems like the result of only allowing a tiny amount of new housing. If housing is highly restricted, then only the most wealthy will get served by new housing. The problem isn't the builders, it's the citizens of the city/town that are trying to keep people out, and limit supply. I'm that environment, the only builders that can exist at all are the ones trying to extract maximum dollars, and those who try to experiment with more affordable building types are locked out of the process. The process is selecting for exactly what you claim to not want.
- gav 7y agoThe other part is that as the value of your properties increase, you can leverage this to buy more properties, capturing even more wealth. My old landlord was a civil engineer who went into business buying multi-family homes in Los Angeles with his brother-in-law maybe 30 years ago. They now own close to 30 buildings, maybe around 120 units total. I'm not unhappy that he's been successful. What's annoying is that this success is not replicatable by other generations. There's no way two people who make less than $100,000 are going to buy a single multi-million dollar residence, let along leverage that process 20 times over.