4 ms·
Thanks for taking the time to flesh that out! I was guessing something like that might be it in a neighbor post, so automatic web CAs at this point are essentia
by xoa 6y ago
Thanks for taking the time to flesh that out! I was guessing something like that might be it in a neighbor post, so automatic web CAs at this point are essentially a bit of a hack/workaround on a common inability of clients to securely verify DNS itself? And from reading it looks like there are plenty of ways to do that (from DNSSEC to DoT/DoH or even for low sophistication attacks simply hard coding a DNS server rather then depending on DHCP, though some of these themselves create other headaches), but those ways are far from universal and in some cases could have conflicts with other network middlemen?
It definitely makes sense, and I completely understand how this sort of workaround can be necessary to get stuff done. But it's also too bad and I hope there can be a push towards securing DNS sooner rather then later, as it really should be the minimal source of trust in most cases. Having DNS be reliable for that with widespread support would open up a ton of additional new possibilities too, and not just for public websites.