3 ms·
> "and compare it's impact with other energies" This is where your argument falls apart. What other energy sources are there? Let's see... burning fossil fuel
by potatolicious 16y ago
> "and compare it's impact with other energies"
This is where your argument falls apart. What other energy sources are there?
Let's see... burning fossil fuels is not only environmentally unsustainable but also, as part of its regular operation, releases more radioactive material into the atmosphere than nuclear power plants.
Solar? Workable on small scale, physically impossible to provide the majority of humanity's energy needs. Same goes for tidal, wind, and hydro.
Geothermal? Ditto - only possible in very selective environments, zero chance of being able to provide significant power generation outside of very limited circumstances.
There simply isn't a better technology out there right now. Until fusion comes along, nuclear is the best we've got. Nobody here is claiming it isn't without its risks, but it sure beats the pants off of what we're doing right now.
Even if we completely ignore the environmental angle, the social angle, and the economic angle, and consider these choices purely on how much radiation exposure they will subject people to, nuclear still wins. That's how far apart these options are. You are choosing between an extremely low chance of being exposed to a potentially damaging dose of radiation... or a guarantee of breathing down radiogenic material for your entire lifetime.
Anti-nuclear paranoia has been one of the most insidious and evil things to infect our collective consciousness in the past decades. It has enforced a continued and growing reliance on depleting fossil fuels, which has not only damaged the environment via greenhouse gas emissions, but pumped gigatons of radioactive material into the atmosphere to be inhaled by everyone. It has caused wars and famine and anti-science paranoia (did you know that the MRI was first called the NMRI? Guess why they had to rename it?).
- maigret 16y agoRenewable energies are almost making the same output as nuclear power, so this should be possible to get off nuclear without flooding the world under CO2 https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Nuclear_power https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Nuclear_power You may also look at that http://energypriorities.com/entries/2010/12/renewables_nuclear_share.php http://energypriorities.com/entries/2010/12/renewables_nucle...
- Dn_Ab 16y agoFirst, I am not against nuclear and hope the fallout from this incident isn't used as fuel for damaging propaganda. But this >Solar? Workable on small scale, physically impossible to provide the majority of humanity's energy needs. is wrong. Efficient use of all sustainable earth's solar input is a hard engineering problem (how best to stick satellites in space and then efficiently radiate back to base stations) but not impossible and would compete with anything Fusion (yes fusion) could produce. The world's current usage is estimated at 1.6 x 10^13/yr watts while 5.2 x 10^16 watts (30% of the sun's constant input to us) is completely reflected and never used by Earth. And the end game in some far flung future would be solar taken straight from the sun. The Kardashev scale is a probably not useful but nonetheless interesting take on this.