4 ms·
If all the people holding bitcoins become multi-millionaires in real terms over 20 years I'm sure they'll manage to cope with the philosophical loss somehow. T
by roenxi 7y ago
If all the people holding bitcoins become multi-millionaires in real terms over 20 years I'm sure they'll manage to cope with the philosophical loss somehow.
There is still plenty of evidence that bitcoin is a bad long term investment; but if it turns out to be a once-in-a-generation style success then it seems to be on the right path. The idea of it being digital gold isn't as far fetched as it was in 2016.
- Melting_Harps 7y ago>If all the people holding bitcoins become multi-millionaires in real terms over 20 years I'm sure they'll manage to cope with the philosophical loss somehow. Given when you entered, some did. Many spent it trying to build what we have today. The former may have given into your reasoning, the latter however did very little to change their behaviour and only their attention-seeking acts changed: look at Amir for example. > There is still plenty of evidence that bitcoin is a bad long term investment... Based on what, 2017's absurdly inflated ATH and the ICO scams that made no sense to anyone who actually understood this tech and instead cashed out only to buy back in? Yeah, perhaps to those not capable of seeing any of that it might be a bad position... > The idea of it being digital gold isn't as far fetched as it was in 2016. Gold is a relic and an arbitrary thing that has no significance when Money is not only fiat but digital, and can now be programmed to be be defacto finite. I was a PM guy before I got into BTC, and I can tell you right now had I the good sense to trust my gut to trade my metal for BTC back then I'd be in a much loftier position in Life, and yet... no regrets as it taught me many valuable lessons and have me greater insight into Life than people 2-3 times my age. Specifically, that arguments about 'intrinsic worth' be it by Austrian economists (or there opponents) are really just rehashed fallacies and ideas only relevant to the clergy of Salamanca (who the Austrian's stole their ideas from) and their concepts of 16th Century thinking and Market dynamics. The 21st Century requires far more nuanced thinking, tools and I just hope we have Fiat to carry us until we become multi-planetary. Modern Capitalism, which is to say State-corporate controlled, is doing away with many myths, and revealing some basic truths; not least of which that Money has and will always be an abstraction. It's just so damn scary when you understand the implications of that statement and all that it entails when trust is lost in such a system.
- roenxi 7y ago> Gold is a relic and an arbitrary thing that has no significance when Money is not only fiat but digital, and can now be programmed to be be defacto finite. I feel compelled to point out gold has been outperforming Bitcoin for 2 years now and has been a performant investment to buy in to at basically any point in the last 15 years except 2012.
- Melting_Harps 7y ago> I feel compelled to point out gold has been outperforming Bitcoin for 2 years now and has been a performant investment to buy in to at basically any point in the last 15 years except 2012. It what sense, because it's spot price remains at $1200, if you're talking about day-day roi then that's cherry picking at its finest as very few people who actually hold physical trade it. The paper markets are, much like anything Wallstreet, a machination so far detached from the real thing its hardly relevant. But, sure, lets assume the paper market has outperformed Bitcoin; lets see your numbers to validate that?
- roenxi 7y agoThe spot price hasn't been anywhere near $1,200 for more than a year. 15 years ago the spot price was around $400. Gold went from ~$400 in 2005 to ~1,300 in 2019. That is about 3x. S&P 500 went from ~1,100 in '05 to ~3,000 in 2019. Also about 3x. Gold is doing fine. And turned out to be a much better bet than stocks after including 2020 :D. And if you want to put a bitcoin price chart side by side a gold price chart over the last 2 years it sorta speaks for itself. Gold went up. Bitcoin went all over the shop, averaging flat. If you want to call 2 years cherry picking be my guest, but it hasn't been a performer recently. It isn't a point of contention that Bitcoin is up infinitely from 2005.
- gamblor956 7y agoLike other metals gold has intrinsic value and can be used in actual, physical things beyond just being shiny or representing an arbitrary unit of exchange. For example, gold is non-corrosive and a good conductor.
- koalala 7y agoCould you give an example of some of that evidence? As a contrarian, I'm interested in anything that goes against the narrative.
- roenxi 7y agoTake the Madoff scam that fell apart back in '08. Everyone believed they were making money from 1999 up until it turned out in 08 they had none. And that was in an environment that was considered well regulated. Financial scams and collapses frequently go 3-5 years looking like a gravy train of wealth creation. And those are actual scams with people lying. Let alone a new phenomenon like Bitcoin where there is a plausibility to the whole thing. That is enough evidence that Bitcoin might just be a fad. In terms of Bitcoin's actual fundamentals if you want an argument to mull over: 1) There is a slight incentive against new buyers to entering the market - they are pretending that someone who bought Bitcoin for $500 did useful work which is trivially not true. The more the Bitcoin price rises the more true that is. 2) The brand name "Bitcoin" is meaningless long term - look at how the meaning of words shift when it is convenient. Traders don't care about dictionary definitions. At some point mining ceases and people don't trade enough to sustain the mining network. At that point, the miners all switch to some new ByteCoin. With a powerful hashing network providing a cheap alternative crypto and with incentives against new entrants into the market people stop accepting Bitcoin. The value collapses. The basic argument is there is no technical difference between Bitcoin and any other crypto. At some point, the miners stop making money and leave; then Bitcoin gets outcompeted. The value retained by crypto tends towards the marginal cost to create new crypto which is 0. This stands in contrast to the argument that the only cryptocurrency that matters is Bitcoin - which I don't think holds true long term. I can see why sellers of Bitcoin would believe that but I don't see why the buyers will cooperate. Cryptocurrencies are completely fungible from a buyer perspective - they can't actually distinguish between them unless the words matter. Or one has a massive hashing network behind it. Compare to gold - doesn't matter what word is used; gold is still gold. I can go to almost any major civilisation, not speak a word, but wave some gold around and they will recognise it. Words don't matter. Hope that ramble is of interest.