Sounds like you're properly applying priors! There's an interesting chapter in Jaynes' Probability Theory: the Logic of Science where he talks about how much e

Sounds like you're properly applying priors! There's an interesting chapter in Jaynes' Probability Theory: the Logic of Science where he talks about how much evidence it would take to convince him that ESP is real. At the time that book was written, there were experiments supporting it that failed to replicate. Basically you're totally allowed to read a scientific study, say "okay, that's an interesting result", and then still not believe the conclusion if you have enough reason to doubt the premise a-priori.