3 ms·
Your post is quite good at explaining half of the problem. But you're ignoring the other half and, despite some excellent snark in the first paragraph, the oth
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Your post is quite good at explaining half of the problem. But you're ignoring the other half and, despite some excellent snark in the first paragraph, the other half of the problem is also real.
The money will be used to buy food - if there is any. The food can be eaten - if there is any.
We need the people who are close to the edge to not fall off because they miss some work. We really do. But we also need the economy to continue to function to produce things like food. That's ars's point and, despite your snark, it is also a valid one.
- fragmede 7y agoThank you for deciphering ars' point for me, I'd missed it; too busy snarking :) Ars makes the leap that giving everyone money means they won't produce anything, and uses that to prove that giving bulk money won't work. Competent managers realize that money only goes so far, and there are things other than money that employees (also) value. Yes we need the economy, but does the economy disappear if the poorest aren't having their bootstraps constantly cut off?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThe economy can disappear if too much of it is closed for too long. (My dad tells about being unable to buy thread in the Great Depression, not because he didn't have enough money to buy it, but because all the thread factories had closed, and so there was no thread being made.) We need a course 1) that doesn't trample on those who are poor, laid off, and still have to eat and pay rent, but 2) that leaves as few of them laid off for as short a time as possible. What course will do that? That's above my pay grade. I just can see two problems that we must, somehow, avoid both.