3 ms·
>That said, I'll reiterate that keeping people from dying due to "economic devastation" is very much within our present capabilities and doesn't depend on globa
by s1artibartfast 7y ago
>That said, I'll reiterate that keeping people from dying due to "economic devastation" is very much within our present capabilities and doesn't depend on global economic recovery.
Very true, but the most likely outcome is that people will not exercise their power to reduce the hardship in the third world. Most people of means did not bother to end starvation in the 3rd world before this, why would they be more likely when they are in worse economic position. How much have you personally donated to end starvation before this? If you haven't, what made you make the choice not to?
- clawedjird 7y agoI agree, unfortunately.
- pasabagi 7y agoCharity is more of a symptom of than a cure of poverty. Nations that kept the 'charity is a big part of welfare' model typically have high levels of poverty, even if they're wealthy. The US is the standout example of this. Nations that treat it as a basic function of government, and a right of the governed, to be able to eat and receive medicine, don't usually have a problem with that kind of poverty. I think it's about how people think of their rights. If somebody has a right to something, they can't receive it as a gift. It is theirs, no matter who holds it. If it isn't a right, then it can always be legally withheld. Charity celebrates the gift-giving side of the equation, but it conceals the darker side: that charity doesn't make sense if it isn't backed up by people taking property rights more seriously than basic needs. If basic needs are protected by law, it's not a charitable donation, it's a tax.