4 ms·
This seems like such a weird law. Cool for supply chain transparency and all but it feels super political to target delivery apps when literally everyone does c
by Spivak 7y ago
This seems like such a weird law. Cool for supply chain transparency and all but it feels super political to target delivery apps when literally everyone does commissions for sales.
Customers should also be confused that…
* Paying $1.99 for an app doesn’t mean the developer receives $1.99.
* Buying a product on Amazon when your browser has a referral cookie means the full cost doesn’t go to the seller.
* Buying a pack of Oreos at Walmart doesn’t mean that Nabisco gets $3.
* Paying $17 to see a movie doesn’t mean the theater gets all of it.
* Buying a game on Steam…
* Buying a flight on a Travelocity…
* Getting a hotel through hotels.com
* Renting an AirBnB…
Like this list could almost literally go on forever.
- malandrew 7y agoI would go even further and suggest that a lot of the high standard of living we enjoyed post WWII can be attributed to all these inefficiencies of cost information. Due to the lack of transparency, pretty much every profession and industry was able to pad enough margin into their business that they could make a decent living. The acceleration of information diffusion means that no one's margin is safe anymore and why we have Bezos' favorite aphorism "Your margin is my opportunity". Historically, margin was not the opportunity except maybe between grocery stores or gas stations (businesses where discovery of two or more providers of the same good/service was trivial and all where easily accessible to the customer). Historically, simply providing the customer with the product or service they need was the opportunity. It was only when discovery became easy (first the yellow pages, later the internet) and competition ceased being local (first franchises, later the internet) that margins eroded across the board.
- maxerickson 7y agoYour argument is that higher prices for goods increase standard of living? Isn't the standard argument based on increased productivity?
- malandrew 7y agoMy argument is that less price transparency (due to less competition and diffusion of information about prices) produced less aggressive competition based on margins. You only needed to provide a good or service people wanted and charge them a price they were willing to pay. There was far less need to worry about competing on price.
- JAlexoid 7y agoI loved when there was no competition for stuff in my town of 100k people.... LOL! (I suspect that you aren't actually against competition. But all competition is based on price, ultimately.)
- malandrew 7y agoThere's no value judgment in my statement. I'm for competition, but I'm just pointing out that it's easier to everyone to embed a margin they can live on when there is less competition.
- malandrew 7y agoOn a related note, I would love for all businesses to periodically send customers an email or other notification showing them how much of the money they spent went to taxes on a monthly basis and yearly basis. People would give a lot more thought to taxes if they added up all the different ways the government nickels and dimes them.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoPeople can already see the governments tax receipts and expenditures on the government websites. People don’t want to relax by auditing taxes.
- dannyw 7y agoWe're talking about knowing how much a middleman is charging here. To use your example, when I rent an airbnb, yes I absolutely want to know how much Airbnb is pocketing. Airbnb happily discloses this as an itemised "Service Fee", and they charge hosts a fair 3% fee to cover payments processing. When I hire a cleaner on Thumbtack, I absolutely want to know how much the cleaner is paid. I want to make sure everyone is earning a liveable wage. And when I order something through a delivery app, I absolutely want to know how much the restaurant is paid.
- zaroth 7y agoI think you are vehemently agreeing with OP? Food delivery is being singled out here because of pure politics. Your AirBnb example by the way is a perfect example. The 3% service fee is the amount charged to the host by AirBnb. They also have a separate charge which they bill to the renter; > Guest service fee: This fee is typically under 14.2% of the booking subtotal (the nightly rate plus cleaning fee and additional guest fee, if applicable, but excluding Airbnb fees and taxes). I’m counting a total of at least 5 different line items for taxes and fees. Not all of which will be broken out on the renter’s invoice. Like when renting a car at the airport, eventually you stop paying attention and just look at the total. You’re only amazed after taking a second look that taxes, fees, concession recovery, environmental etc. fees make up more than half the cost.
- petre 7y agoIn my country we often get breakfast included for the same price as the room if we cut out the middleman (booking.com, airbnb).
- JAlexoid 7y agoFun fact, I prepaid my trip to Croatia and lost all of my money... because I paid directly to the person. 800Eur down the drain. Can you guess if I'm giving a fuck if the middlemen take 90% of your income?
- 7y ago