2 ms·
I think we don't disagree that soft anonymity is an important social concept. We disagree that radio broadcast fits the soft-anonymity space. It never has in t
by shadowgovt 7y ago
I think we don't disagree that soft anonymity is an important social concept.
We disagree that radio broadcast fits the soft-anonymity space. It never has in the past and we probably do more harm than good adding it (for starters, we kill the hobby radio industry. We give massive power to the largest owners of radios---broadcast conglomerates---that could start claiming their broadcasts were intended for only their audience and hit people with a cudgel for tuning in. And there's a lot of ugly corner cases where the radio specturm is shared; if my neighbor's broken wifi is stomping all over my signal quality and I record packets to prove it, should I be held liable that I grabbed that data when their radio activity was harming my ability to use my radios?).
We'd be better served by teaching people "What you broadcast with a radio is broadcast. Make decisions about what you broadcast accordingly."
> google exploited and is clearly on the wrong side of morality regarding storing also the unencrypted payloads
It doesn't sound like Google intended to do that, but I think the fact they didn't highlights why it's important people understand the need to not broadcast that which you don't want public; accidental data collection is too easy.
If I flip my router into debug mode because it stops talking to my laptop, I'm going to see the packets of my neighbors. I don't want to see them, and if they don't want me to either, they really ought to stop sending them unencrypted like that.