5 ms·
> In this view, a building with a thermostat would seem to be conscious to some degree. I don't think this is as overly broad or bad of a definition as you pre
by colordrops 7y ago
> In this view, a building with a thermostat would seem to be conscious to some degree.
I don't think this is as overly broad or bad of a definition as you presume. I recall sitting at a laundromat one day, in a somewhat sleepy state daydreaming, with the rhythm of the washing machine in front of me playing through my mind. My subconscious told me that the machine was conscious. I dug deeper into that intuition, and realized I was seeing a bit of the inner workings of the mind of the engineer that designed the algorithm. Not a perfect example, as I didn't know if the alg was closed-loop, but in any case, it made me realize that our minds are just large bodies of these algorithms working together. We have some additional oracles, random data generators, and probabilistic mechanisms thrown in as tools, but consciousness really is mechanistic and pluralistic.
To recreate it requires not only the qualitative aspects of a being that can think, but also sufficient (read: vast) quantity of systems to get to a useful general purpose thinking machine. There is no "soul" or special sauce or singular definition of consciousness. It's an illusion.
- mewpmewp2 7y agoI personally don't understand how a logically and rationally thinking person could get to a conclusion anything other than that we are a combination of algorithms. So essentially we can in theory be simulated and there is nothing special about us. In this case the machine simulating us would be as conscious as ourselves. It seems any other conclusion is just fooling oneself.
- goatlover 7y agoReplace algorithms with math and you'll see that you're making a rather strong metaphysical claim that is essentially Platonism.
- mannykannot 7y agoOne reaction to that statement might be "so be it." I did not, however, come here to defend the idea that consciousness is an algorithm. Personally, I consider it rather more plausible that a computer plus a random number generator might achieve consciousness through simulating the sorts of physical processes that occur in a brain, and if it is a 'true' random number generator, rather than a deterministic PRNG, then we are no longer talking about math, at least in the sense that you use to conclude Platonism. One might respond by saying that if the universe is deterministic, then there is no such thing as a 'true' random number generator, as distinct from a PRNG. My understanding of the philosophical implications of QM, and its competing interpretations, is insufficient for me to be sure whether the universe as we experience it is deterministic, but regardless of whether it is or is not, I suspect that the true hard problem of consciousness is 'why do we (feel that we) have free will?'
- goatlover 7y ago> I suspect that the true hard problem of consciousness is 'why do we (feel that we) have free will?' Free will and consciousness are separate issues. You can potentially have one and not the other. What's important for free will is whether choice is free and what that freedom amounts to. What's important to consciousness is subjectivity. You can feel pain while not having a choice about feeling that pain, say if you were restrained and unable to do anything about it, just to give an example. And potentially, a robot could be free to make choices while not feeling anything.
- mannykannot 7y agoI doubt that 'will', as it is commonly conceived, has any meaning, or at least a very different one, for a non-conscious agent. It's similar to the way i think IIS is clouding rather than clarifying the issue. For related reasons, I feel that compatibilist positions on the issue are largely avoiding it. As for subjectivity, I had more to say about it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23162714 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23162714 Regardless of whether I am right or wrong on this, I think my other points in this post (platonism, etc.) are independent of it.
- mewpmewp2 7y agoI don't think there can be or is a reason to believe there exists a 'true' random number generator. What's the reason to believe such a thing exists? If something seems random to us likelier explanation is because we couldn't observe it from close enough so we do not know the exact algorithm/causes behind that event or occurrence. To me it seems like even if there's a random number generator there's no reason to believe such a thing exists. Simpler explanation is that there's some logic involved which we just can't observe (yet). Same thing as we can't prove that a man in the cloud does not exist, but there's no good reason to believe that one exists - except for people's ego of course.
- umvi 7y agoWe are obviously more than just "algorithms". Algorithms don't have free will. Unless you are also arguing there is no such thing as free will and that the world is just playing out in a predetermined physics reaction? Yet even that doesn't 100% jive with physics because quantum mechanics are not deterministic.
- Rury 7y ago> Yet even that doesn't 100% jive with physics because quantum mechanics are not deterministic QM is a branch of physics, with some theories having multiple interpretations, some being deterministic and some non-deterministic. By this I mean, quite literally there exists deterministic and non-deterministic models of the same phenomenon, which both work in accurately describing said phenomenon. As so, it hasn't been proven whether QM is deterministic or non-deterministic. Regardless, in cases where it skews non-deterministic - how can we be certain that the exhibited randomness isn't just simply because we aren't accounting for all conditions there is to know about the phenomenon (hidden variables)? Before shooting that down, Bell even admitted his own theorem does not rule out determinism - as determinism which evades it - he calls "superdeterminism".
- mellosouls 7y agoWhile I wouldn't claim a special case for us over machines as a foundation for consciousness, plenty of logical and rational people consider a reduction of cognition ("AGI") to algorithms to be a naive but understandable approach in early decades. There has been zero success with it in creating a sentient being in all that time, so who's fooling themselves? And that's just cognition; not consciousness which is a different matter, and still not even understood on a philosophical level, let alone scientific - physics, computing or other. You should consider the possibility this is a gap in your understanding, rather than a privileged access to rational and intelligent thought over others.
- WJW 7y agoI don't think it's bad to describe a building with a thermostat as a (very) little bit conscious. It would be interesting to formulate a spectrum of consciousness. Something like: Level 0: Inanimate objects like rocks. They move when moved by something else but not on their own. Level 1: Objects like mechanical locks that move iff interacted with but do make some sort of "choice". (ie opening or not opening depending on the key used in the case of the lock) Level 2: Systems that interact with their environments but in very mechanical ways, like mosses, trees and thermostats. It is essentially predictable how the system will behave when disturbed in certain ways, ie it does not learn or only in a predictable way (like trees growing around obstacles). Level 3: Systems that can actively learn about their environment and use the knowledge to get what they want. Most animals would be here. Level 4: Systems complex enough to form a "theory of mind" about other beings. Most social animals would be here. Level 5: Self-aware systems, which can form a theory of mind about themselves. Complex planning lives here. There might be levels higher than self-awareness, but I can't think of any examples (obviously, since humans are as far as we know the most intelligent beings on Earth). Some attributes a hypothetical "level 6" system might have: - Perfect insight in their own motivations. Humans clearly lack this but it does not seem impossible. - Better ways to communicate qualia. The colour purple or the taste of strawberries is difficult to explain for humans, but once again it does not seem like it would be impossible. - Ability to "really" multitask. Once again something that is not theoretically impossible but very difficult for humans to do.
- mellosouls 7y agoThis (from the top Level 5 down) is one of the arguments proposed by the thermostats-are-conscious people, an argument that often leads to panexperientialism and related theories. Most famously espoused by Chalmers in his classic division of philosophy of mind into hard (consciousness) and "easy" (cognition, etc) problems. http://www.eoht.info/page/panexperientialism http://www.eoht.info/page/panexperientialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_problem_of_consciousness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_problem_of_consciousness
- mapcars 7y ago>Level 0: Inanimate objects like rocks. They move when moved by something else but not on their own. If you want to explore it deeper - take a leaf. It is like a rock not moved by itself. But wind can pick it up and move it. Now the question is - does the leaf happen in a way that it can be moved by the wind by accident or there is some "intelligence" behind it? See that moving leaf is exactly like any moving object is not moved purely by itself - when you move it happens together with other forces like gravity and friction (rubbing? not sure how it's in English) and so on. So maybe rock is the same in this way just it requires more (or better say different) energy to move as you require different energy to move compared to a leaf. If you look this way everything is conscious and works together, there is no single, separate entity anywhere in the Universe. And all things somehow working together on billions visible and invisible levels can be called consciousness.