3 ms·
What's biologically different about submariners? Mostly male, I guess, but anything else?
by whatshisface 7y ago
What's biologically different about submariners? Mostly male, I guess, but anything else?
- dmoy 7y agoPhysically more fit, pass certain psych screenings, etc. It's not exactly a good random sampling, they filter candidates very aggressively.
- learc83 7y agoIt's not a good random sample, but they were exposed to C02 levels 10x higher than what you'd be exposed to even in a poorly ventilated conference room.
- tfehring 7y agoPossibly "tolerance" to high levels of CO2, and/or a baseline level of cognitive performance that's already impacted by chronic exposure to high levels of CO2?
- learc83 7y agoStudies that raised the alarm on C02 levels showed a severe impact on cognitive function at 1,500ppm. Submariners routinely live and work in levels at 5,000ppm. >baseline level of cognitive performance that's already impacted by chronic exposure to high levels of CO2 If that explanation is true submariners would barley be capable of operating their boats. >Possibly "tolerance" to high levels of CO2, And if that explanation is true new submariners would be barely functional. The most likely explanation is that the study that showed severe impairment at relatively low levels is wrong.
- maxbond 7y ago> Submariners routinely live and work in levels at 5,000ppm. People are telling you that this study may not be reflective of the general population, and you are only demonstrating their point. It seems like you are really invested in a particular outcome for this research. Maybe you should take a step back and try to let go of your biases. Dying on the hill of one particular study is the definition of cherrypicking.
- marchenko 7y agoI think the poster has a good point. It's not just the one submariner study he's referencing that's relevant, it's the decades of experience navies of various nations have operating submarine fleets - the armed forces are not shy about collecting physiological data in the service of operational readiness. If the headline article is correct, we should be very concerned that a significant fraction of the world's nuclear weapons are immediately operated by officers experiencing extraordinary CO2 exposure. Every submariner is green at some point (and there are female submariners as well) - how is acclimation handled?
- maxbond 7y agoI agree it's worth investigating. I just found it peculiar how unreceptive they were to the suggestion that the population was unrepresentative, yet how aware they were that the population was, in fact, unrepresentative. The original suggestion, way up thread, was not to overgeneralize studies. This is a huge problem in our society.