6 ms·
I don't understand why? Salaries are high because you're competing for the same small group of talented people. They aren't high due to the location.
by chrisseaton 7y ago
I don't understand why? Salaries are high because you're competing for the same small group of talented people. They aren't high due to the location.
- jcdavis 7y agoAs more companies are WFH friendly, the potential employee pool expands massively
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Tiktaalik 7y agoI'm pretty sure the salaries are heavily dependent on location related cost of living requirements. Aren't salaries different in different locations? (ie. same company with offices in Vancouver Canada vs Seattle vs SF?) I've heard they are... If pay was purely about talent, everyone would be paid the same.
- Apocryphon 7y agoA friend at Google says Bay Area and NYC salaries are higher than at other offices.
- bcrosby95 7y agoAt least some of the Bay Area stuff is probably due to proximity of the main office. At least, that is what was explained by a friend of mine that decided to stay at the Venice office - that it's easier to advance in all ways if you work in the Bay Area.
- 908B64B197 7y agoThere's also a talent gap. From my experience, a lot of tech workers in Vancouver simply couldn't meet the bar for the stricter US immigration. With the current stricter enforcement on H1-B and the lax Canadian immigration system I expect to see a downward pressure for wages in Vancouver as more of the B players are relocated there.
- cplanas 7y ago> There's also a talent gap. From my experience, a lot of tech workers in Vancouver simply couldn't meet the bar for the stricter US immigration. Really? It doesn't seem to be this way to me. The academic requirements are, I believe, the same: a degree. I think in the US you also need a job offer (for H1B), but that hasn't been hard to get for a software engineer in the last 10 years. The real "bar" for US immigration is a hard limit on visas, which are resolved via lottery. Your "ability" on winning a lottery doesn't say much about your talent for engineering. Note: I moved from Europe to the Bay Area, I'm a bit familiar with the process.
- 908B64B197 7y agoThe job requirement makes all the difference. In Canada, the point based immigration system will reward anyone with a STEM degree with points, irrelevant of the actual market value of the degree. My friends in those market tell me it's not uncommon to have senior foreign graduates incapable of passing a fizzbuzz interview. They often have multi year gaps in their resume where they couldn't land a job upon arriving in Canada. Contrast this to the US where for an application to even get to the lottery it has to be vetted by a business that's willing to spend multiple thousands of dollars to maybe get a visa for the worker. There's also a lot of workers that simply can't pass the bar due to the Requests For Evidences required by the US government. As an European from, what I assume, a legitimate university you wouldn't experience those issues. Most of the folks who fail at this step will have back-up petitions filled at one of the satellite locations in Canada.
- chrisseaton 7y agoCan’t most senior developers get an exceptional ability visa?
- cplanas 7y agoNo. As far as I know, exceptional ability is really exceptional. Being a very senior engineer in, say, Google Zurich doesn't really qualify. For an O-1 you need to have received nationally/internationally recognized prizes; published media in major publications... https://www.wegreened.com/o1-visa https://www.wegreened.com/o1-visa
- mattlondon 7y agoUsually the salaries are based on "market rates" and explicitly do not consider cost of living. This is why London jobs are not paid more than SF - the "market rate" in London is lower despite living costs being the same or more than SF (especially when in London none of the FAANGs offer free transport to and from work and property prices are so much higher near transport hubs). Market rates are murky - I guess it is based on competition and who employs in the area. There is some sort of shared database that loads of companies use from what I understand, but they are flawed since they don't include a lot of high-paying employers in finance et al.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- laurencerowe 7y agoCost of living looks higher in Vancouver than Seattle while salaries look higher in Seattle that Vancouver... High pay requires a competitive job market (employer can't find anyone else to do it to the same standard for less) in a profit making industry (it's worth staying in a line of business even with higher wage costs.) Honestly I'm quite surprised how little salaries at big tech companies vary by location within the same country. The bigger difference seems to be in opportunities for career advancement with more post-senior roles available at head offices.
- downerending 7y agoA lot of us would disagree with that. Housing is so expensive that lots of talented people simply cannot afford to move to the BA. Looked at another way, "talented people" are often smart enough to realize that if they do get the same salary, they net a lot more if they live elsewhere.
- joshuamorton 7y agoI'll bite, where, other than the usual suspects (similarly high CoL areas like NYC and arguably Seattle), or Chicago for the slim group of people working at the finance companies there, are making the same take home compensation as someone in the bay at one of the better paying companies (Google, Facebook, unicorns, etc.)? You're looking at 160K gross for a new grad + the value of the various perks, and that doubles for someone with 5 years of experience. You're correct that for someone who wishes to own a home right out of school/within a year, the bay may not be the best choice (although working there for a year or two and then moving elsewhere probably is), but there are basically no other places where a SWE in their mid twenties can bank 100K a year after expenses.
- downerending 7y agoThat first sentence needs to be taken out back and shot. :-) I agree that "new grad" is the best case for being in the BA. Once you're ten or fifteen years into your career and have a wife and kids, the downsides of the BA are far more painful. And if you didn't spend those ten or fifteen years building up capital while living in the BA, moving there later can be all but impossible. That talent is simply not accessible to BA companies unless it's remote. All that said, my point that given the same salary, or even a modestly smaller one, you net more if you're not paying for housing in the BA.
- joshuamorton 7y ago> That first sentence needs to be taken out back and shot. :-) Oh you're right I'm so sorry :P > All that said, my point that given the same salary, or even a modestly smaller one, you net more if you're not paying for housing in the BA. Ah, I somehow missed the (emphasized) do in your original sentence. I'll just leave now.
- dsr_ 7y agoOh, no. The FAANGs are competing for the group of people who are willing to work in a small chunk of California and, to a lesser extent, small chunks of Virginia, Washington, Illinois, New York and Massachusetts. Remove those restrictions and the relevant group expands. This is as silly as competing for men, or competing for US citizens, or competing for 22-32 year-olds. Demographics like that have very little power compared to testing for relevant skills, or having a visible track record.