15 ms·
The Fed Will Buy Bond ETFs Now
- q92z8oeif 7y agotax payers -> fed govt -> "the fed" -> blackrock inc -> corporate ETFs -> american corporations which tax structure is in ireland.
- dmillar 7y agoThe first link here is more aptly Japan and China. And, to make this really circular, Ireland also is one of the largest holders of US debt.
- FriendlyNormie 7y agoAh yes, the dreaded Irish run the world from the shadows, not Jews.
- bcrosby95 7y agoNote that most government debt is owned by taxpayers in one form or another though. China and Japan are very large foreign owners though.
- dmillar 7y agoJapan is actually the largest, fwiw. These Fed programs are being financed by debt spending, not tax increases. So even if some of this debt is held by US tax payers, it's not at their expense. They're getting paid interest.
- dtwest 7y agoDebt spending tends to turn into tax increases if you actually plan on paying the money back
- outside1234 7y agoThe end game here is inflation. Which, in the long run, will also make the stock market, and their options increase, as revenue and profit inflate. But not in the short term.
- drdec 7y agoExcept that the Fed is buying bonds that pay a higher rate that they borrow at (U.S. Treasury rate). So unless there is a lot of defaulting, they should be fine. It's like they are mortgaging the White House at 0.25% and buying bonds that pay 4%.
- thephyber 7y agoNot necessarily. If the economy grows faster than recent history, a constant tax rate brings in more revenue. Also worth looking at the last time the USA completely paid off its government debt. > On January 8, 1835, president Andrew Jackson paid off the entire national debt, the only time in U.S. history that has been accomplished. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_United_States_public_debt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_United_States_p...
- dtwest 7y agoYes, well actually if the economy grows at all, a constant tax rate brings in more revenue, while we tend to spend more too. But I agree it is theoretically possible. In Andrew Jackson's case they also raised taxes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tariff_of_Abominations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tariff_of_Abominations
- luckylion 7y agoSo it's US corporations moving their international earnings to Ireland and using the cash they keep there to buy US Treasurys, because they don't have that many things to invest in and they can't pay out dividends because they don't want to repatriate and pay taxes?
- thephyber 7y agoOf $23+ trillion of US government debt, the largest foreign government debtors are {Japan with $1.27 trillion, China with $1.09 trillion, UK with $0.40 trillion}.[1] Ireland owns about 0.1% of US securities debt ($0.28 trillion)[1]. That's a _very_ low circular factor. [1] https://www.thebalance.com/who-owns-the-u-s-national-debt-3306124 https://www.thebalance.com/who-owns-the-u-s-national-debt-33...
- athriren 7y agoThe largest holder of US debt is the US federal government. The debt is owed by us to ourselves. It is just numbers in accounts. The conception of federal debt as some giant anvil hanging over our heads is not correct. Foreign holdings only account for about a third of all obligations, which the US could—but will never, for obvious reasons—unilaterally take off its books and ask anyone who has an issue with it to take it up with the DoD.
- anm89 7y agoThis is utter nonsense. Just because American national debt is held by American citizens and corporations doesn't mean its not real or that it could just be canceled out on paper and it wouldn't matter. Those debts are projected future incomes for those other people\companies and if they magically disappear some parties would end up very badly screwed. This narrative, while often repeated, is nonsense.
- yborg 7y agoThey don't really have to be American, just organized in the US and having "significant US operations." So American Honda, for example, can now be funded by the US government. Since it's an indirect funding facility, these company bond issues can be used for stock buybacks, i.e. executive comp so the taxpayer doesn't just subsidize executive compensation via the capital gains rate, it now can fund it directly. The smart money never wastes a good crisis!
- kolbe 7y agoThis is what bothers me about USA 2020. We thoroughly divided due to relatively small differences in political options, but the real division that no one seems to care about is the political elites stealing money from the poor and middle class. We draw political allegiances so arbitrarily, and totally ignore that it's BOTH parties renewing the PATRIOT Act (which is happening now), and both parties giving our tax dollars to their friends.
- jjoonathan 7y agoPeople are starting to care. In 2016 Bernie almost got elected on this platform, Trump did get elected on this platform, and in 2020 the DNC had to throw an election just to keep Bernie at bay.
- q92z8oeif 7y agoand still, not a tiny dent in the two party system. Which proves that your history is anecdotal with very little (none?) significance statistically.
- Aunche 7y agoThere is a growing divide because people can't help but cherry pick anything that fits their narrative. The government is spending hundreds of billions on unemployment, direct stimulus, and keeping people on payroll, but the only thing liberals have to say is that the money isn't enough and coming too slowly. I'm liberal myself and I can see why people feel frustrated, but I can also see why so many conservatives feel like progressives are being entitled.
- jjoonathan 7y agoConservatives: we're printing $5300 per capita, $1200 of which goes to working people and $4100 goes to the market/rich and the working people still want more?! Such entitlement!
- mrosett 7y ago
- nickysielicki 7y agoI am so angry, and we are so fucked.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI've been told by a professional it's unhealthy to tell someone else how to feel, so let me instead offer a suggestion: take a deep breath and think differently about the situation, and seek out opportunities to still profit from manipulations sanctioned by the economic system. For example, those of us who knew this was coming bought certain ETFs to front run the Fed and BlackRock, knowing they were going to begin purchasing them. Continue to seek out such opportunities in the future. The game is "rigged", so play along. "When you can't change the direction of the wind, adjust your sails."
- lisper 7y ago> those of us who knew this was coming How does one join that club?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoConsume relevant data from reliable sources. The Fed was very clear they intended to provide "unlimited support" to "maintain liquidity" when they made their March statements. > When asked if the Fed would run out of ammunition to support the economy, Powell said no. > “When it comes to this lending, we're not going to run out of ammunition. That doesn't happen," he said. TLDR "Okay, so you're going to buy everything you can without any discrimination about price to hack around fiscal policy failure, good to know." https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/monetary20200323b.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/mone... (Federal Reserve announces extensive new measures to support the economy) https://www.usnews.com/news/us/articles/2020-03-26/fed-chair-powell-says-will-provide-nearly-unlimited-lending https://www.usnews.com/news/us/articles/2020-03-26/fed-chair... (Fed Chair Powell Says Will Provide Nearly Unlimited Lending)
- stx 7y ago
- dznodes 7y agoThis could be the reason stocks have been going up ..despite double-digit unemployment. Decoupling from reality?
- toomuchtodo 7y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/comments/ghcfn5/dddd_the_20102020_liquidityfueled_asset_bubble/ https://www.reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/comments/ghcfn5/dddd... (ignore the subreddit, it's actually an excellent analysis about how liquidity operations are inflating asset values)
- nytf3 7y agothis is a poor ripoff of Lyn Alden's work: https://www.lynalden.com/global-dollar-short-squeeze/ https://www.lynalden.com/global-dollar-short-squeeze/ (02/20/20) https://www.lynalden.com/great-depression/ https://www.lynalden.com/great-depression/ (03/12/20) https://www.lynalden.com/quantitative-easing-mmt-inflation/ https://www.lynalden.com/quantitative-easing-mmt-inflation/ (05/01/20)
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThanks for sharing, wasn't familiar with this body of work.
- nytf3 6y agoNo problem! Not much of a pedigree, but I think the articles stand by themselves.
- stx 7y agoI wonder what the US going into a deflationary spiral would mean for real estate like rental houses? When economists say deflationary spiral do they mean prices of assets (like houses) would fall?
- 7y ago
- programmertote 7y agoAs someone who have a very basic understanding of economy and the Fed's role in managing it, does this mean the federal government is owning more and more share of private companies (at least their debt portion)? Does that mean, the US, which is supposed to be a very capitalistic nation, is now trending toward the economy operated by quasi-government-owned companies? Is it imaginable that eventually, the US government owns the majority stake in these quasi-government-backed companies, moving the US economy further away from market-based capitalism?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cik 7y agoNot really. It means that federal government is backstopping certain types of debt. This ensures that market liquidity happens such that mid-tier companies without ease of access to capital can access capital at lower interest rates. With the fed backstopping debt, they're effectively the debtholder for these smaller companies - so yet it's a bailout. However, unlike when the fed took actual stakes in GM and Chrysler they don't hold shares. They merely receive the interest payments and coupons on the associated debt. It's pretty hard to argue that there's EVER been market based capitalism. Much like communism, it's a bogey that has never actually existing - instead we have systems similar to them.
- redis_mlc 7y agoThe above is a very good answer. > the US, which is supposed to be a very capitalistic nation 1) large corporations write laws and engage in monopolies to prevent competition. They have no desire for any sort of capitalism as the average person would think of. This is crony capitalism. 2) corona is destroying the capital that smaller companies had to engage in authentic competition. This is the problem we really need to address in May, 2020 before we flush 200 years of progress down the toilet. (When you see articles about billionaire investors crying in public this month, this is why. They look at the economic numbers and know what our country is throwing away over the flu.)
- 7y ago
- yingw787 7y agoOne can dream, but you can imagine if the Fed really wanted to implement UBI, it could probably do something like: - Give everyone in the U.S. a guaranteed loan for $2,001, 0% interest, payable at the end of the month - Before you "default", enter in a "negotiation" where the Fed can buy back the security from you for $1, writing off "the losses" - Do it all again the next month Tada! Monetary policy as fiscal policy! If you don't want to write it off immediately, guarantee 0% interest and have the timeline for the loan be 200 years, then write off the debt as nonpayable after death. But seriously, I'm not sure if there's a clear line between monetary policy and fiscal policy anymore.
- User23 7y agoThere never really was. It was always a charade. The only real “benefit” of the current system is that seigniorage profits are accrued by primary dealers rather than Treasury.
- espadrine 7y agoIn the EU at least, monetary policy is a property of the currency (which crosses borders), while fiscal policy is a property of the government (associated with a single administrative country). If the world evolves further into currency consolidation (which seems to be the direction aspired to by many technologists hoping for Internet money), this distinction will grow in relevance.
- yingw787 7y agoI kinda don't think after all this people want to move towards currency consolidation. Isn't the E.U. the only union and non-country to have a singular currency? And isn't that singular monetary policy something that causes a great deal of friction between member states (e.g. Greece and Germany back in '08)? I think if you took another vote among E.U. members to ratify the Maastricht treaty today, you might get a different result. What us technologists might aspire to is pretty different from the ground truth.
- dilandau 7y agoIgnoring the awful attempt at conversational writing, this is bad news for Americans in the long term. Short term we add liquidity, allow hedge funds to delever, and prop up a market everyone wants to crash. Longer term the taxpayers (individuals and American businesses) are going to be eating the cost. This bailout makes 2008 a blip on the radar. It's going to take decades to play out.
- lainga 7y agoWell, I'm sorry if you don't like Matt Levine's style, but he's been at his attempts for many years now and it's what distinguishes him from the rest of the regular columns. I think to the point where if anyone else at Bloomberg tried it, they'd be accused of a game stab at Money Stuff. So maybe he's doing you a service...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dilandau 7y agoImagine responding to my actual comment.
- blackrock 7y agoAhh.. the hypocrisy of the American government. They continually accuse other countries of manipulating their currency, of creating fake stock markets, of all kinds of financial shenanigans. And then, when crisis hits America, 3 times in the past 20 years! What does America do? The exact same thing that they accuse other countries of doing. You should realize that by doing this, that America will never return to a normalized system, where homes are affordably priced for the average American. What ever happened to the invisible hand of the free market? It was all just a lie. Welcome to the Ponzi scheme, called the American financial system.
- maxk42 7y agoThe Federal Reserve is not a part of the government. It's a private entity.
- chrisco255 7y agoIt was. At some point the Treasury and the Fed "merged" for all practical intents and purposes. There is no longer a clear separation of banking and state. It's fuzzier by the day. But ultimately, this is what power does. It consolidates. It corrupts. Decentralization is the only counterweight to the corrosive effects of power. The power to print money at will...it will prove to be our economy's undoing.
- apta 7y agoWhich is so ironic to leave the economy of a country up to the whims of a private entity, where the people running it indulge in parasitic and immoral practices (interest/usury) to always profit off of the backs of people.
- Endlessly 7y agoAnyone have a graph of the capital injections (or capital equivalent valuation at the time of actions) that the US and other countries have taken since 2020 started?
- ajsharp 7y agoThe Fed balance sheet is probably the most direct way to look at the aggregate liquidity injections: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttrends.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren...
- fuckyah 7y agofor US: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL
- zelly 7y agoThis is not news. It was priced in when the S&P500 rose from 2300 to 2900. Now the market is starting to (already has?) priced in the Fed straight up buying equities.
- astrea 7y agoI'm not exactly a financial expert, but I feel like any stock market news is accompanied by a fleet of "This was already priced in" comments.
- zelly 7y agoLegitimate shocks are not. For example, when Apple announces bad earnings or as a more extreme example, 9/11.
- odonnellryan 7y ago"priced in" does not mean the market is perfectly valuing these assets. They can still be overvalued or undervalued. What it means is these assets have had a price movement in line with investor sentiment: meaning buying on this news isn't going to be a "play" anymore. It doesn't mean you should avoid these assets, just that you should be aware that there were already movements in these assets because of expected Fed action. Meaning this was "priced in."
- bawana 7y agoNo matter how much qe the fed does , there will be no inflation. The money goes to banks and financial institutions. They do not spend it on real goods and services. Rather they implement financial tools to get higher roi. Thus too many dollars chase too few financial tools resulting in equity inflation (a rising stock market) The real market of goods and services is unmoved and as a result wages and prices are stable (stagnant). The fed only helps banks because they use a system designed in the 1930s. Back then before credit cards, internet banking, before the repeal of Glass Steagall, banks drove the economy by lending to people. (See ‘It’s a Wonderful 𝐋𝐢𝐟𝐞’) To move the economy, the fed has to put money into the hands of people who will spend it. Each taxpayer should get a fed account with a monthly stipend of fed-coin. Fed-coin will have a half-life to encourage people to spend it. Once spent its value will be fixed as it gets converted to regular dollars
- whatok 7y agoThere might not be CPI inflation but there's definite asset inflation which trickles down to real estate which trickles down to rent which trickles down to money in everyday consumers' pockets.
- jsdevtom 7y agoPrinting money is, by definition inflation. Printing money in to the hands of people who spend it is stealing from savers. Effectively discouraging responsible financial decisions in favour of lending.
- cs702 7y agoUS credit markets are not really working as "markets" anymore, properly speaking, because a single special buyer, the Fed, is setting both risk-free rates and credit spreads for all corporate borrowers. Just by announcing it is willing to buy corporate bond ETFs, the Fed has become the very visible hand of the bond market. The "price" of a corporate bond no longer means what you think it means. It is now determined by the Fed's willingness to buy bond ETFs for reasons that may or may not have anything to do with the creditworthiness of individual companies. This is both utterly shocking and completely predictable.
- whatok 7y agoFew things: - No one knows how much or what exactly they're buying but they're limited by the size of the overall facility and are primarily going to stick to investment grade with a carve out for fallen angel and HY ETFs. Blackrock needs to provide the Fed with a list of ETFs they may buy and disclosure on that is uncertain. - They are not required to publish their holdings but will provide an aggregate number alongside the rest of the H.4.1 numbers published on Thursday. - The main and other part of this secondary market facility is secondary market corporate bonds. There is a certification process that issuers need to complete in order for the Fed to buy their bonds. Given the backlash on PPP, issuers are reluctant to register and especially reluctant given that secondary markets are more or less functioning. - Most of the impact of this and other facilities announced has been seen in the announcement; not through actual purchases. This is true for the Fed and has been true for the BoJ and ECB. - With the announce impact/implicit backstop, a (current) cap on ETF purchases, and a reluctance for issuers to certify, if markets function properly, you may not see very many purchases by the Fed under this facility at all.
- granzymes 7y agoThe comments here confuse me. The Fed is buying bond ETFs so that it can provide support to the corporate debt market in a way that doesn't 1) require a ton of careful, time-consuming credit risk analysis and 2) doesn't favor individual issuers. The goal is to improve credit conditions and provide financing that otherwise wouldn't be available to companies during this crisis. This isn't manipulation of the stock market, it's making sure credit markets don't dry up at the worst possible time and exacerbate the damage. The funding here is $75 Billion from the Treasury Department (authorized by Congress) and like other Fed facilities the money isn't disappearing into the void; the Fed will eventually unwind these positions or allow them to runoff its balance sheet. As much as I love Matt Levine, maybe having an article with a higher information density would reduce the number of low-effort comments. Something like this article[0] maybe, dang? [0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/bond-etfs-climb-as-the-fed-kicks-off-historic-purchase-program-11589296012 https://www.wsj.com/articles/bond-etfs-climb-as-the-fed-kick...
- whatok 7y agoThe Fed buying bond ETFs is a small portion of the overall SMCCF. They are buying bond ETFs right now because the issuer certification process for buying individual bonds has been dragged out and right now it seems that not many issuers want to register because of backlash from PPP. I agree with your two initial points in the context of the Fed ONLY buying ETFs but that's only a small portion of the overall facility. With secondary bond purchases, the Fed is absolutely going to be favoring individual issuers not willingly but through the design of the program and the form of individual issuers' capital structures. If the Fed wanted to rush a program out to only buy ETFs, they did not need to take almost two months to do so. The underlying corporate bonds were the main target of this program, they ran into some operational problems launching that portion of the facility, and decided to go ahead with the ETF portion. Agreed on the Matt Levine. He's fine for certain things but it seems like he's the ultimate source for tech people who want to talk about finance and he's not always right/is only one side of the story.
- adrr 7y agoThey could just look at the etf holdings and buy paper based on that. If you’re buying billions of debt, you don’t buy an etf and pay management fees. Backlash is going to be huge when the public finds out how much these fund managers take home in bonuses with all this new capital flowing into their funds.
- sylvain_kerkour 7y agoHi, I know this is not a common point of view but here is what I propose to stop being angry against those magician apprentices (they make money disappear from pockets of others to appear in theirs). Just ignore them. Just ignore this circus. Build resilient local communities, reconnect with your family, build yourself a sustainable future. As another one said: "The game is rigged", so just play another game. It's not worth being angry against this noise. They know what they are doing.
- tathougies 7y agoAnd after you reconnect with your local community, form your own currency.
- sschueller 7y agoIt's illegal as soon as you stop paying the tax man.
- anm89 7y agoI wish I heard more people saying this. This really sums up my philosophy. I pay very close attention to these markets because I feel that understanding them personally benefits me but while I strongly disagree with most of the policy I don't get moralistic about it. I either figure out how to profit off of it or get on with my own life. There are more interesting and valuable things to do in life than to be angry at how unfair a bunch of things that are totally out of your control are.
- omerbensaadon 7y agoNobody sees any issues with the Fed being saddled with private sector debt? The same Fed that decides how much money is printed? The same money that is the world reserve currency (functionally, the new gold)? What the fuck is happening?
- thephyber 7y ago> is happening What is different this time? The Fed has participated in just about every financial bailout since it was founded in the 1910s. Even before the USA moved from gold-backed-bucks to fiat currency, there were rumors that there wasn't enough gold to back all of those promises. > Nobody sees any issues I'm sure lots of people are concerned, but that isn't the question. The question is what can be done and I think at this point everyone s paralyzed with indecision.
- omerbensaadon 7y agoThe difference is the riskiness of the things they are willing to buy...
- jsdevtom 7y agoThis will just inflate the everything bubble further than it has ever gone before. Terrible news.
- neonate 7y agohttps://archive.md/Uwedm https://archive.md/Uwedm
- andrewla 7y agoNow that the "audit the Fed" members of Congress have been effectively neutered by "crying wolf" too often, the Fed is content to just wander around eating villagers, knowing that nobody has any interest in enforcing the Fed's charter or imposing any restraints on their behavior.
- dsalzman 7y agoFor those who like to listen and not read. Here's an automated podcast of this newsletter. https://anchor.fm/talking-money-stuff https://anchor.fm/talking-money-stuff
- dznodes 7y agoToo Big To Survive = too big to fail
- dznodes 7y agoSo will smart investors now just follow the FED and invest in whomever they are propping up? If so they will pick the winners and the losers in every market.
- odonnellryan 7y agoNo, because it's possible some assets are now overvalued because of this news. This news is possibly positive for the market in general, but if you go buy corporate bond ETFs right now it doesn't mean you'll make money, and it definitely does not mean you'll make money compared to buying a total market ETF or something similar.
- jb775 7y agoMy instinct tells me we are headed towards massive inflation, and if your investments aren't parked in the right place (or if you don't really have investments), you're in for a rude awakening. I don't see how it's in anyone's best interest (besides the bankers collecting fees) for the Federal Reserve to get in bed with ETF management companies.
- naveen99 7y agoIt’s the Heisenberg uncertainty principle of modern monetary theory: Increasing tax lowers inflation. inflation via government spending is a negative tax.
- pczy 7y agoAs far as I'm aware, the arbitrage mechanism works both ways. Continuing your analogy, authorized participants are able to trade the underlying turkeys for new tokens, or redeem the tokens for turkeys. When the price of a token is bidded up, its price becomes attractive relative to the turkeys. Authorized participants buy the underlying turkeys, create new tokens and then sell those tokens to take a risk free profit. This continues as long as there is a price mismatch, and ensures that ETF prices are in sync with the underlying assets.
- Wendy6464 7y agoDo you know insurance companies think your credit score reflects the risks involved in insuring you. For me this is very important because insurance is expensive and with a bad credit score could increase my insurance premiums .So i always keep my hacker friend (privatehacker247@gmail.com) close. He removes late payments, evictions, school loan or any negative item you wish to remove from your credit report and boost your score to about 790 – 795, for an affordable amount. PHONE : (207) 689 0256