5 ms·
I’m kind of surprised that you’re surprised by it. Outrage over privacy violations has very little to do with the actual harm that the privacy violation causes
by ashtonkem 7y ago
I’m kind of surprised that you’re surprised by it.
Outrage over privacy violations has very little to do with the actual harm that the privacy violation causes, and much more to do with whether or not it seems to violate a prior expectation of anonymity or privacy. This concept is even enshrined in US jurisprudence; the “expectation of privacy” is a big factor in how privacy works in America.
Back to Google. The problem isn’t that they captured packets or SSIDs; the problem is that they captured it sitting outside your house. With that change it feels like Google has gone from taking photos of the city that you might be in, to sitting in the bushes taking pictures of your house.
- judge2020 7y ago> the “expectation of privacy” is a big factor in how privacy works in America. You might expect privacy in your home, but if someone looks through your window when passing by and you exchange glances, you likely aren't going to call law enforcement because they violated that expectation of privacy. Of course, if something revealing or private was observed when that happened, or if they were specifically looking someplace people don't just look (eg. upstairs window) it might warrant filing a police report, but my point is that, based on the articles linked in this thread, Google was sniffing all packets without malice or intent.
- ashtonkem 7y agoThis is neither about intent nor the letter of the law, it’s about perception and outrage. It doesn’t matter if it’s legal and without malice, it feels creepy in a way that their regular internet behavior does not. It’s also impossible to verify what Google will do with that data now or forever. They say they’re doing it in good faith, but then again everyone says that. How can you verify that, and do you trust them with it forever?
- ForHackernews 7y ago> in a way that their regular internet behavior does not. Counterpoint: I think if most regular people understood the extent of Google's other surveillance behavior, they would also find it creepy.
- shadowgovt 7y ago> it feels creepy in a way that their regular internet behavior does not And that is, of course, where people come to reasonable disagreement; it simply doesn't feel creepy to a lot of folk. I assume the difference in feel is whether one interprets "capturing unsecured wifi packets via wardriving" as akin to peeping-Tomming into every neighbor's house or akin to sailing along a coastline full of lighthouses broadcasting their beacons and writing down the strobe patterns.
- jbay808 7y agoIf they look in the window and start writing observations down in a notebook, I probably would call the police.
- Grazester 7y agoAnd what could the police do for that really besides tell you close your blinds if the person was not on your property?
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoAt some point that might count as stalking?
- catalogia 7y agoThe could tell the note-taker to fuck off. Police often tell people to fuck off when they're not doing anything that's illegal.
- shadowgovt 7y agoThat's a bad analogy for an unsecured wifi. Wifi is radiated energy in radio spectra. They're not looking through your window; you're shining a flashlight through your walls and they wrote down the pattern you're strobing into the street (and that pattern isn't even secret; you're using the common pattern everyone uses to send messages intended to be universally understood).
- jbay808 7y agoRadiated energy in the radio spectrum is very different than radiated reflected energy in the optical spectrum?
- shadowgovt 7y agoIt goes through walls and curtains, for starters. In radio, we're all living in glass houses. ;) Privacy guidelines and analogies around what is and is not acceptable to view emitting from someone's domicile start to break down when everyone's in a glass house.
- mindslight 7y ago> if someone looks through your window when passing by and you exchange glances, you likely aren't going to call law enforcement because they violated that expectation of privacy Sure. However if that someone snaps a picture, that changes. Especially if you knew they're being paid to collect pictures for a popular website. The outrage is over the scale and complete lack of accountability. If Google detailed the specific information that was collected and stored, positively notified every subject, and gave us all a way to easily permanently opt out, it would be a different story. But instead, these surveillance companies insist on treating OUR personal information as "their" property based simply on their having collected it. Hopefully this is starting to slowly change with the GDPR etc, although it's going to be a long path due to how thoroughly surveillance companies have embedded themselves into society.
- magicalhippo 7y ago> whether or not it seems to violate a prior expectation of anonymity or privacy Anything sent over the air cannot be assumed to be anonymous or private. The bits are being transmitted through a shared medium. If I'm using semaphores to communicate with my girlfriend across the road, I can't be upset if her neighbor looks at me as I wave flags around in my living room.
- gowld 7y agoThe law trumps your opinion. https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2014/02/25/282523377/thermal-imaging-gets-more-common-but-the-courts-havent-caught-up https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2014/02/25/28... > In 2001, the Supreme Court held in Kyllo v. United States that police officers violated the Fourth Amendment when they used a thermal imaging device to detect marijuana plants growing inside a home. "Where ... the government uses a device that is not in general public use, to explore details of the home that would previously have been unknowable without physical intrusion, the surveillance is a Fourth Amendment 'search' and is presumptively unreasonable without a warrant," wrote Justice Antonin Scalia. > To make his point, Scalia added that the device can tell you things that the average person would not be able to tell standing outside the house. "[F]or example, [the device can reveal] at what hour each night the lady of the house takes her daily sauna and bath," he wrote.
- magicalhippo 7y agoBut WiFi signals are usually readily available outside most homes, and in fact many people _want_ to be able to stay connected to their WiFi from just outside their home.
- XMPPwocky 7y ago> Anything sent over the air cannot be assumed to be anonymous or private. The bits are being transmitted through a shared medium. The point of the law here is exactly to prevent things which are technically possible, but socially frowned upon. A law against something that isn't possible doesn't do anything. (Should this be illegal? Maybe not! But your point seems very silly.) If you're using your voice to communicate with your girlfriend in your own apartment, can you be upset if somebody's got their ear pressed up against your door, listening in? I mean, you knew that was technically possible to do. Why would you expect privacy?