3 ms·
I answered a question on StackExchange yesterday, and once I had Googled and read through some threads and dug up some answers with links to post, I noticed the
by jodrellblank 16y ago
I answered a question on StackExchange yesterday, and once I had Googled and read through some threads and dug up some answers with links to post, I noticed the question had been edited by a moderator.
Looking at the history, I saw that this neat and tidy question was originally a sloppy mess. Suddenly I felt cheated - here I was answering someone who had asked a sensible well written question ... except they hadn't.
I had a similar realisation that I wasn't answering to help someone, but to help future search engine results, which is less endearing.
- kjksf 16y agoThink of it this way: instead of helping one person who can't even phrase a question properly, you're helping thousands of people who will find your answer in the future by searching for the version of the question that was properly phrased (and the one you actually answered).
- fedd 16y agoAND helping yourself, making your name known on the web so that you'll be easier to be hired or funded! :)
- jamesbritt 16y agoI appreciate Reg's insight on the appropriateness of his answer. I (usually) hate it when I ask a technical question and get 20 Questions from someone who would rather question my intents or knowledge than just answer the question. But Reg makes clear why people might do this; most often they are probably trying to be helpful at a level above mere practicality. They care about the person asking the question, not just the question itself. They are involved because there's a community. Healthy communities offer reciprocal benefits, which draws people in. If you remove that, what is left to motivate participation? Some people get off on public displays of cleverness, but if people are given to feel they and their free contributions are simply fodder for someone else's business they are not likely to stick around. Sites like Quora have to decide if losing the participation of someone of Reg's caliber is worth it to maintain some strict protocol.
- rick_2047 16y agoI don't understand what you are trying to say, the moderators only improve the grammar or remove spelling mistakes. They never (in essence) change the question, they help the person get the question across properly.