4 ms·
Flaws in this line of reasoning: 1. Providing a well-rounded education is somehow impossibly expensive, whether with modern communication technologies like the
by keiferski 7y ago
Flaws in this line of reasoning:
1. Providing a well-rounded education is somehow impossibly expensive, whether with modern communication technologies like the Internet or paper books. Surely the solution is to make this education cheaper, not to simply get rid of it?
2. Ignoring the fact that a democracy doesn't work if citizens aren't educated. Quoting The Great Books of the Western World:
This answer...assumes that we can leave all intellectual activity, and all political responsibility, to somebody else and live our lives as vegetable beneficiaries of the moral and intellectual virtue of other men.
The trouble with this assumption is that, whereas it was once possible, and even compulsory, for the bulk of mankind, such indulgence now, on the part of anybody, endangers the whole community. It is now necessary for everybody to try to live, as Ortega says, "at the height of his times." The democratic enterprise is imperiled if any one of us says, "I do not have to try to think for myself, or make the most of myself, or become a citizen of "the world republic of learning."
- chrisweekly 7y agoWell said!
- aestetix 7y agoSounds like you're a Johnny :)
- keiferski 7y agoNope, just a fan of their program, although I'd like to do the Eastern Classics MA someday.
- barry-cotter 7y agoEducation for its own sake needn’t be expensive but trying to force it on the unwilling doesn’t work and makes things worse for those who actually want it by mixing in people who don’t actually care into their classes. If twelve years of primary and secondary school can’t awaken intellectual interests for more years in college won’t either. We know it doesn’t work for literature because most people don’t read for pleasure and those who do mostly don’t read literature. That is the easiest one besides possibly music, where again the academically favoured version is wildly less popular than what is generally consumed. Forcing education on people does amazingly little to change their tastes. If democracy doesn’t work if citizens aren't educated how did it work before universal primary or secondary education? The US, UK and France among others had a wide franchise long before a high school education was normative. And education doesn’t even make informed citizens. Only 40% of the US population can name all three branches of government. Most people are ignorant of civics in all countries. You can’t make people retain information they neither use not care about but you can make their childhoods worse by wasting their time. Forcing a simulacrum of education on the unwilling or unenthusiastic has low, low returns in knowledge.