3 ms·
>building fancy pilots all day, but refuse roll them out because it will cannibalize their core business That's the big difference I've noticed between German
by ChuckNorris89 7y ago
>building fancy pilots all day, but refuse roll them out because it will cannibalize their core business
That's the big difference I've noticed between German and US companies.
In German companies if you are an exec that brought success to the company in the past then your word is the law and focus is on keeping the status quo and make sure that any new ventures don't make existing higher ups obsolete.
Whereas in US tech companies innovation is the primary focus regardless if someone's division ends up obsolete and needs to be let go. Famous examples being how Netflix pivoted from DVD rentals or Tony Fadell, creator of the iPod who was tasked on delivering an iPhone prototype back in the day and failed as his team's design was basically an iPod based phone which lost in favor of the current iOS iPhone we all know today. During the live iPhone launch demo, Steve Jobs deletes his contact from the favorites list basically saying "you're fired" and the rest is history.
You won't see something like this in a German company where age and experience in the company is more valued than being a visionary for future market trends. That's why you'll never see the big German car manufacturers pull off a Tesla even though they have more resources. Can't pivot and cannibalize the current products and have to shit-can some famous higher ups that were successful in the past.
- jotm 7y agoThey are more conservative. Blockbuster, Sears. VW, BMW.
- asjw 7y agoBut also Siemens, Bosch, Bayer, Lufthansa Systems Btw, even though I'm a huge Ferrari fan, the research being made at Daimler AG (Mercedes) is astonishing, not only in Formula 1, their self driving trucks are an incredible piece of technology
- lowdose 7y agoIt's the typical innovators problem you describe and that is pretty international. I do think you have a point about culture and in Europe in general software engineering is not seen as such a value adding activity as in the US. Salaries are less than $100k even in senior positions and I think because of this more talent has moved to the cutting edge technology companies in the US than Europe wants to admit.
- Torwald 7y agoThis is much bigger than your comment makes it out to be. There used to be a real IT industry in Ger. We had Siemens-Nixdorf as a very decent global player. We had Commodore producing their PCs in Braunschweig. Now all that's left is the relative newcomer SAP.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoThe tech industry you are referring to(SiemensNixdorf/Commodore) was mostly consumer hardware and has along with the likes of Nokia, Motorola and Sony Ericsson long moved to Asia or disappeared all together as margins are thin in that business and cost of labor is too high in Germany. Consumer focused software is where the big money is now an that is unfortunately a huge vacuum in the German tech sector.
- Torwald 7y ago> The tech industry you are referring to(SiemensNixdorf/Commodore) was mostly consumer hardware Both Siemens and Nixdorf build mainframes. Later Siemens had it's own version of DOS. Most Commodore PCs were used in office environments. I am not referring to 8bit machines nor Amigas.
- lowdose 7y agoYes I know, Siemens sold their whole dutch software divisions to TomTom and thus basically pulled the plug themself. And SAP could be seen as the Oracle of Europe. For customers and consultants it's an implementation nightmare. Lidl launching an AWS competitor is probably done on advice of their accountant. The big four are known to overpromised on the capabilities of their outsourced software division in India. When Google and Microsoft struggle to catch up to AWS with 10s of 1000s of the best engineers it is completely unrealistic Lidl is going to achieve anything. This is a discount brand for crying out loud clearly on misinformed money waisting spending spree bender. The Germans will have a hangover like nothing else they have experience before.
- redis_mlc 7y ago> Famous examples being how Netflix pivoted from DVD rentals Not to nitpick your overall post, but let me explain the context better. Netflix is named "Net flix" because the original plan was to offer a streaming product ASAP, but investors and end-users weren't ready at the time. So mailing DVDs was done initially, and because of a loophole in USPS pricing rules, was a genius move when looking at cost. (Netflix historically has employed a former Postmaster General to stay on top of that.) Source: worked there, read a bunch of stuff on this.
- eru 7y agoDo you have a link to a write-up on the loophole in the USPS pricing rules somewhere? Edit: I found a few articles. Seems mostly a lesson on how you shouldn't have a government monopoly on the postal service in your country..
- smnrchrds 7y agoI can't find the article. Would you mind linking to it?
- redis_mlc 7y agoAdding to my previous comment. The Netflix business model hacks were: 1) First class mail (cheaper than media mail packages for bare DVDs) with likely letter-carrier presorting, volume and whatever other postal discounts (hence hiring former Postmaster Generals) were available, plus an agreement with the Post Ofice to manually sort DVDs to avoid machine damage using their light-weight mailer: "Bulk Discounts. First-Class Mail commercial pricing is available for presorted letters, flats, and packages with a minimum quantity of 500 mailpieces. Automation discounts may also apply." https://www.usps.com/ship/first-class-mail.htm https://www.usps.com/ship/first-class-mail.htm See the 2000/2001 mailers for the prepaid first-class stamp: http://blog.dvd.netflix.com/new-dvd-releases/the-evolution-of-the-mailer http://blog.dvd.netflix.com/new-dvd-releases/the-evolution-o... Also, if you get a tour of a main post office or sorting facility, you will see bins labelled "Netflix", so DVDs get special handling and slightly faster return delivery. 2) Because Netflix was the first adopter of #1 for DVD's, they won a ruling that they could continue to use First Class pricing. (The Post Office tried to move them to media mail which allows better packaging (at much higher cost) for automated handling, but that was viewed as anti-competitive by the court.) https://www.courthousenews.com/post-office-cant-raise-rates-on-netflix-mailers/ https://www.courthousenews.com/post-office-cant-raise-rates-... (I used to be an expert in postal bulk rates around that time.) 3) First-sale doctrine allowing multiple rentals of the same DVD without further payments to the studios. (Streaming requires payment per stream.) https://freakonomics.com/2013/03/22/a-brave-new-world-for-copyright-and-the-first-sale-doctrine/ https://freakonomics.com/2013/03/22/a-brave-new-world-for-co... For HN readers, I believe this is the first detailed analysis of both their postage pricing strategy and first-sale doctrine in one article, likely because few people know about both bulk mail and IP.
- asjw 7y agoThe other big difference is that German companies prefer stability over pure profit, because it creates a better working environment and a happier society overall, where your job doesn't depend from sheer luck, especially the lower income ones. They pulled out more Tesla's than Tesla will ever do, and they still rank on top of the carmaking industry. Tesla, on the other hand, the first thing has done when they bought Grohmann Engineering was to stop the production for competitors, that led the founder to leave. That's never a good sign for an established business. That's the price you pay for having a "humanly deficient man" as a CEO.
- ChuckNorris89 7y ago>German companies prefer stability over pure profit Sorry, but Dieselgate would like to respectfully disagree with you.
- rglullis 7y agoKeeping entrenched carmakers happy and double standards from the state when dealing with institutions they have a stake on is stability, after all...
- asjw 7y agoDiesel gate has nothing to do with pure profit, it has to do with Germany keeping its market shares and the occupational figures (the stability I was talking about) Only 2% of the cars were sold in US Of course the fact that US was leading the production of luxury electric cars has to do with the revelation being made public in 2013 while politicians and regulators have known for years They were (illegally) accumulating money to invest in electric car manufacturing without having to "disrupt" the industry which has political consequences in Europe, where job places are highly unionised I'm not saying they were right I'm saying that they were keeping the stability at any cost, they just sacrificed some upper manager after the scandal, and in fact 6 years later the numbers say that in the electric car market "Volkswagen leads all carmakers with over 1.4 million sales. Renault-Nissan and China's Geely have also overtaken Tesla."
- neuronic 7y agoThere is a notable exception to this role: Germany's e-commerce giant Otto [1] has transitioned from order by catalogue to webstore pretty well and they are doing some nice things techwise. Maybe exception to the rule but definitely an example of not being stuck in the past and it's a LARGE corporation. [1] https://www.otto.de/ https://www.otto.de/
- fragmede 7y agoThat seems overly stereotyped. North American companies that fail to innovate do so at their own peril. They languish, and eventually become irrelevant. Kodak, Sears, RIM (Blackberry) come to mind. So do the non-Tesla US car companies. General Motors, Ford Motor Company, and Fiat Chrysler Automobiles.