4 ms·
Agreed. Whats so hard to understand about laws applied uniformly? We can complain that there's no avenue for fast reopening of low risk non-essentials, but to
by jayd16 7y ago
Agreed. Whats so hard to understand about laws applied uniformly? We can complain that there's no avenue for fast reopening of low risk non-essentials, but to complain that policy failure means the policy is "not evidence based" is myopic.
- scarmig 7y agoI kind of get it: you can imagine a world where the government offers a fine level of granularity specifying how and when different facilities in different industries can open, and that would be more "rational" than blanket prohibitions. But that ignores the actual process of policymaking: imagine a program that consists of thousands of lines of nested if-else statements, that gets a hundred PRs per day from devs implementing requirements from a dozen different PMs who aren't even necessarily communicating with each other or that knowledgeable about the actual product requirements, who also might be getting bribes to put in buggy code that happen to favor certain actors. Optimistically, even given all that you might be able to build a policy that generates more efficiencies than a whitelist of a couple sectors. Even if you can, though, you won't be able to effectively communicate the why of any particular decision to the public. So they get pissed off when you allow people to go to the beach on a sunny day to pop open a bottle of beer while you disallow in-person religious services.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoThis is basically my main complaint about the approach in the US. That ship has long sailed, but it should have been straight quarantine. We got soft 'shelter in place' that was basically disregarded based on what I saw ( in IL suburbs at least; can't speak for other places ) and not applied uniformly. And I don't even want to get started on our governor deciding that golfing is somehow essential to the quality of life here. In short, I understand the anger. I even understand the guy, who did not want to wear a mask out of spite at my wife's place ( more specifically, he did not want to wear it, because eff IL state government; he put it on when he was told it was office policy.. ). But it is getting messy and we better figure it out quick, before that powder cake gets lit. The opportunity to contain it has passed and now we really need to think hard what to do next, because options are not great.
- scarmig 7y agoThe best solution would have been for the US to shut down from mid-February to the end of March to get time to put together a comprehensive testing and contact tracing program, but that was never in the cards: people wouldn't have accepted it coming so soon, and wouldn't have accepted sitting in quarantine for two months when weekly national deaths weren't even breaking double digits. As for what now... unfortunately I don't think there's a good way out for the USA. Other highly developed countries have established a tenuous path toward controlling the virus (in different ways), but Americans seems intent on running headfirst into the abattoir.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoI will admit that in January I was sure CNN was selling a pandemic scare ( and at the time I basically dismissed it as an exotic flu ). But in February the writing was on the wall, which is why we were slowly stocking up on essentials. There are few times to accept government restrictions, but I would say pandemic qualifies. Hell, I was almost ready to accept Trump's flimsy characterization of the pandemic as war with invisible enemy since I was half hoping he would impose stringent restrictions. But he chickened out. And now we have this wishy washy, no mans land, not quite quarantine re-opening. To say that it is a cluster fuck is an understatement.
- scarmig 7y agoIn January I had the fortunate timing of moving to China a day before the Wuhan lockdown went into effect (talk about culture shock). Though my thinking on the pandemic has evolved since then, I came to three immediate conclusions: 1) COVID-19 is a BFD 2) The PRC, in culture and governance, is exceptionally well-equipped to handle disasters of this type 3) The USA, in culture and governance, is exceptionally badly-equipped to make this pandemic unfold as anything except a giant clusterfuck Those seem to have held up pretty well.
- deathgrips 7y agoThe disaster wouldn't have happened in the first place if China had not assassinated doctors trying to circulate early information about Covid-19. China in effect created the problem and then solved it very, very painfully.
- twblalock 7y ago> Whats so hard to understand about laws applied uniformly? The law was applied arbitrarily from the beginning of the lockdown. There was never uniformity, and the decisions about which businesses are essential was arbitrary rather evidence-based. In what rational world is a marijuana dispensary considered more essential than a car factory?
- notriddle 7y agoPresumably, someone who's undergoing chemotherapy and needs something to help with the resulting nausea.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deathgrips 7y agoHow will they get to the dispensary?
- jenrzzz 7y agoMany delivery services are operating, or they could have a caregiver pick it up for them.
- deathgrips 7y agoWhat sort of vehicles will those deliverers and caregivers use?
- amf12 7y ago> What sort of vehicles will those deliverers and caregivers use? The one they already have. How were they buying groceries and making deliveries before the pandemic? I understand where you are going with this, but that's not a good faith argument for keeping car factories open.
- 7y ago