8 ms·
To be fair, Musk's tweet especially says if anyone is to be arrested for this, it should be him. > to make a political statement. I see it as more a business
by kelnos 7y ago
To be fair, Musk's tweet especially says if anyone is to be arrested for this, it should be him.
> to make a political statement.
I see it as more a business decision, and only secondarily a political statement.
- justapassenger 7y ago“Dear Officer, you cannot arrest me. Did you even check Twitter?”
- LanceH 7y agoHe did say he no longer needed a house.
- atoav 7y agoOr terrorism, depending on the perspective.
- lightgreen 7y agoIt’s not terrorism by definition of terrorism regardless of perspective. Same as a person is not a nazi just because someone disagrees with them. Same as speech is not violence. Etc etc etc.
- JabavuAdams 7y agoYou started off strong, but overreached. If I say to my spouse or child "You fucking stupid cunt, I've told you a thousand times to put the dishes away! You good for nothing piece of shit, you can't even get that right!" That's violence. EDIT> Speech is an act. That act can be violence.
- AlgorithmicTime 7y agoNo, no that's not violence. Violence would be if you hit your child or spouse.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- MaxBarraclough 7y agoNo, that wouldn't be violence. A more interesting example would be giving an order to fire rubber bullets into a peaceable crowd. In the same sense that someone has committed murder if they hire a hitman, we could say that the speech act of giving the order, is a violent act. Your example of a stream of abusive language, is not the equivalent of that. If someone is punished for such an act, they are not being punished for committing a violent offence. I do wish people would stop trying to shift the definition of 'violence'. I don't want to have to make a habit of saying 'physical violence' just to close the door on it.
- atoav 7y agoThe difference between your view and the view you are commenting on is (as so often) whether we look at the act or the outcome. And honestly, given the dictionary definition of violence both are valid perspectives. Cambridge Dictionary says: violence – extremely forceful actions that are intended to hurt people or are likely to cause damage. Nowhere does it say these actions have to be carried out with the body (and if we are pedantic here, yelling into a room can be very physical as well as you are literally moving air with your breath). Violence is a matter of communication. If your girlfriend accidentally turns around and hits you in the face with full force, it hurts, but that doesn't mean it was violent behaviour. If she however hits you on purpose with bad intent, it can be weak as hell and still constitute violent behaviour. This means violence is not purely physical, but also an act of demonstrating/communicating power over the other. And as an act of communication there is more to it than it's pure physical components.
- MaxBarraclough 7y ago> If your girlfriend accidentally turns around and hits you in the face with full force, it hurts, but that doesn't mean it was violent behaviour. If she however hits you on purpose with bad intent, it can be weak as hell and still constitute violent behaviour. Disagree. That is a violent act, but one without violent intent. Boxing is a violent sport, but isn't criminal. > This means violence is not purely physical, but also an act of demonstrating/communicating power over the other. And as an act of communication there is more to it than it's pure physical components. I don't think the word 'communication' is helpful here. I think what you're getting at is intent.
- gerland 7y agoNo it is not. Problems with drawing the line between what is acceptable and what is "violent" speech are caused precisely by the fact that this axiom is completely false. You cannot have free speech, and by extension speech at all, without causing what you percieve as "violence". First of all, do not put equality sign between physical and being verbally abusive. The first one is something external that you have no control over, no matter how much you fight, the second you can just shrug off and continue with your life. Problem with your example lies in the lack of context. On the more humorous side - maybe your wife is a cunt and your children are little bastards. If you percieve any kind of abusive expression, no matter of the context, as violence, then you're just done. There is no useful way that you can contribute to culture and society, because you cannot participate in discourse anymore. On the more serious side - what about "psychological violence"? What about when your wife treats you like a slave and verbally abuses you on a daily basis? If your wife mistreats you, then just leave. Her words cannot stop you. What stops you is more likely the threat of being beaten, that she will make it impossible for you to see your kids and she will take your house. The violence is physical, economical and sociological, not verbal. Going further - your comment disgusted me and I've felt that it violates some of the most important values I have in my life. Is this violence? Not at all, I will just shrug it off and continue to enjoy my day. I will get some downvotes and maybe be less frequent in visiting left-leaning websites. We lose the ability to talk to each other, but it's far from being violence. It's just stupidity on both sides.
- JabavuAdams 7y agoAlmost all situations of real interest and disagreement will be grey-area and call for a pragmatic vs. a dogmatic approach. > First of all, do not put equality sign between physical and being verbally abusive. I am not, in general -- let's try to confine ourselves to my specific example. > The first one is something external that you have no control over, no matter how much you fight, the second you can just shrug off and continue with your life. This is a dogmatic assertion that is not supported by the evidence. If I were feeling less charitable, I could counter that of course you could do something about physical violence -- you just had to train harder, have better weapons, or build a coalition. People are emotionally abused. Stating that in some cases, some people can transcend that abuse is ... not really relevant. It's interesting, and should be studied so that perhaps we can confer immunity to more people. > Problem with your example lies in the lack of context. On the more humorous side - maybe your wife is a cunt and your children are little bastards. As soon as you admit context you admit that abusive speech could be an act of violence, as well as true speech. As you say, yourself, context matters. This is why dogmatic approaches to this issue are doomed to fail. > If you percieve any kind of abusive expression, no matter of the context, as violence, ... Let's just stick to my example. To disprove "speech cannot be violence", I only have to find one example of speech that is violence. I don't have believe or prove that all (abusive) speech is violence. > then you're just done. There is no useful way that you can contribute to culture and society, because you cannot participate in discourse anymore. This is nonsense. It's smacks of litany rather than logic. A person can be a productive member of society in many ways, yet hold beliefs that disturb you. > Going further - your comment disgusted me and I've felt that it violates some of the most important values I have in my life. I can't know, but your words suggest that you are looking to be disgusted. We all like to be self-righteous at times, but I doubt we are as far apart as you believe. I have deep knowledge of computer science, artificial intelligence, biology, and emotional abuse. All of these areas teach that nature has no respect for our ontologies. We may try to draw a hard line between violence and speech, but we mislead ourselves. Almost all of the cases worth debating occur at the fuzzy edges of these concepts. Failure to realize this may result in the sense of having a crystalline framework, but ultimately it misleads.
- atoav 7y agoI didn't say that it was terrorism. I said there are perspectives from which it could be seen as such. FYI: https://www.forbes.com/sites/carlieporterfield/2020/03/31/coronavirus-spitters-could-be-charged-as-terrorists---heres-why/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/carlieporterfield/2020/03/31/co...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- masonic 7y agoI don't see how he could be arrested given that none of this lockdown was implemented in criminal statute law. Fined, maybe, but even fines can be reversed by courts.
- clouddrover 7y agoHere is Alameda County's public health order: http://www.acphd.org/media/572718/health-officer-order-20-10-shelter-in-place-20200429.pdf http://www.acphd.org/media/572718/health-officer-order-20-10... To quote it: "Pursuant to Government Code sections 26602 and 41601 and Health and Safety Code section 101029, the Health Officer requests that the Sheriff and all chiefs of police in the County ensure compliance with and enforce this Order. The violation of any provision of this Order constitutes an imminent threat and menace to public health, constitutes a public nuisance, and is punishable by fine, imprisonment, or both."
- kyuudou 7y agoThis is municipal code, not criminal law. Very important distinction. Like with a traffic ticket, they can fine for not complying. They cannot arrest you, however. Where they "get" you is if you blow off the court about resolving the fine which is contempt of court, which is a criminal offense. It blows my mind how supposedly smart people know so little about the law. It's a lot like programming. The keywords are important and the logic used as well.
- clouddrover 7y ago> This is municipal code, not criminal law. These businesses are facing criminal charges in Los Angeles for violating the Los Angeles county public health order: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-04-03/coronavirus-closures-los-angeles-criminal-charges-against-four-stores https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-04-03/coronavi...
- kyuudou 7y agoI guess we'll find out what the judges the locals voted for and the juries summoned are made of. Even then, their decisions can be overturned by a higher court or appealed so that basically means nothing. They can say "criminal municipal code violation" and a good judge should say, no, that's not how this works. I guess it is LA, though...
- dragonwriter 7y ago> To be fair, Musk's tweet especially says if anyone is to be arrested for this, it should be him To be fair, you can't both commit a crime and pay other people to commit crimes and get them out of the legal consequences by tweeting that you are the only one who should be arrested.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 101404 7y agoNot sure about the rules in the US out that country. But it's it really a crime to go to work? Especially some national law and state law seem to allow it. Just the county's burocrats seem to prohibit it.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> But it's it really a crime to go to work? Yes. > Especially some national law and state law seem to allow it State law makes it a crime to violate orders of county public health officers for the control of communicable disease.
- cbar_tx 7y agothe crime here is county officials engaging in literal economic repression. It's not a matter of when the government orders whatever is says this week. The fact of the matter is that if a business feels it's time to reopen, it should do so, cautiously of course. Neither the employees or customers are forced to go. They have a right to refuse. They don't have a right to dictate what others decide to do with their business
- gremlinsinc 7y agoIf you're a drug lord, manufacturing meth, just because you provide jobs to the runners, doesn't mean they can't be held accountable, am I right?