4 ms·
This is encouraging. Two negative viral tests and a positive antibody test, and people should be able to get an ID that says they're exempt from movement and ma
by Animats 7y ago
This is encouraging. Two negative viral tests and a positive antibody test, and people should be able to get an ID that says they're exempt from movement and mask restrictions. (To discourage faking this, getting that ID should also turn eligibility for the Emergency Care Benefit, since they can work safely.)
There's still argument over how long immunity lasts, but it has to be at least two or three months, or there would already be widespread (large numbers) reports of people getting the disease more than once. So, for now, IDs could be good for three months. They can be extended later as more info comes in.
First step in the US should be to test first responders in NYC. NYC already has maybe 21% antibody-positive people, and those on the front lines are probably higher. Knowing who's immune will be a great relief to them.
- feyman_r 7y ago>>> ..they're exempt from movement and mask restrictions ... There's a negative repercussion of people around such folks getting a false-impression that masks are not a serious need (if this is in question, that's a different discussion). It also creates a possibility of visible 'haves' and 'have-nots', which can cause trouble. I think having uniform messaging for movement/masks irrespective of antibody presence will remove variability in response from people.
- Animats 7y agoSo the ID card goes on a lanyard. It also creates a possibility of visible 'haves' and 'have-nots', which can cause trouble. Yes. So? Gradually, more people are added, painfully, to the "have' list.
- erik_seaberg 7y ago> they can work safely Maybe. If only 1% of your employees could work safely, it's probably not worth opening the doors and paying them to try to get something done in the absence of the other 99%.
- Animats 7y agoIt's probably around 5% now in the Bay Area, 25% in NYC.
- zaroth 7y ago> A special document to exempt people from “movement and mask restrictions”... I just find this idea viscerally revolting. All I can think of is armbands with the Star of David. I don’t believe there can ever be any justification for mass restriction of movement in society, because such is a roadmap for tyranny. However I need only make the case there clearly isn’t justifiable ends in our current pandemic. What we have found is a minuscule and highly stratified extreme-risk population (mostly, nursing homes) and a vast majority for which COVID is the least of their concerns. Much more pressing a concern for the masses is getting back to their jobs, their so-called “elective” procedures, and resuming healthy socialization and recreation patterns. What we need, and what the Constitution requires are strictly targeted measures to keep COVID out of nursing homes, and for everything else to re-open. Mass restriction of movement and mandatory testing is neither legal, nor is it conscionable.