3 ms·
Mathematics does have a notation problem, and that means you effectively have to learn a foreign language to be able to understand it. And like foreign language
by jcranmer 7y ago
Mathematics does have a notation problem, and that means you effectively have to learn a foreign language to be able to understand it. And like foreign languages, learning it outside of a structured, classroom environment can be difficult to sustain. Even worse is the fact that while terminology like "monad" can easily be searched for to find its definition [1], how is one supposed to search for ℜ?
Dismissing this foreign language aspect as easy to learn doesn't get to the heart of the matter. Is it really too much to be ask to be taught in vernacular English rather than foreign Church Latin, er, Mathematical Notation?
[1] Assuming that you don't get an answer like "a monad is a monoid in the category of endofunctors," which unfortunately does tend to be the case for higher mathematical concepts.
- bjl 7y agoVernacular English isn't capable of describing some concepts succinctly enough to be useful to mathematicians. If English was superior people would be using it. This 'argument' always just seems to be a thinly veiled excuse to avoid putting in the bare minimum effort required to understand a complicated topic.
- FridgeSeal 7y ago> Mathematics does have a notation problem An opinion that’s largely held by programmers and not people who actually do maths. You learn the symbols and notation as you go and it very quickly becomes understandable. I certainly Duns I have less issues understanding mathematical notation than I do reading some programming languages. > how is one supposed to search for ℜ? That’s chalkboard R, represents the real numbers. Searching “fancy R mathematics” (in Duck duck go) nets a page that explains what the chalkboard R, N, P, Q and C symbols all mean. > Is it really too much to be ask to be taught in vernacular English Mathematical texts used to be written in plain English without the notation, it’s honestly so, so much worse. It’s multitude more verbose and so much harder to grasp.
- jcranmer 7y ago> An opinion that’s largely held by programmers and not people who actually do maths. The "people who actually do maths" will almost by definition exclude anyone who has issues understanding the notation. You need to look at the latter group of people to work out if the notation is unnecessarily obtuse. > it’s honestly so, so much worse. It’s multitude more verbose and so much harder to grasp. As a counterexample, consider the proof that undirected Hamiltonian cycles is NP-complete, by reduction from directed Hamiltonian cycles. Karp's original paper says literally just this: N = V × {0, 1, 2} A = {{<u,0>, <u,1>}, {<u,1>, <u,2>} | u ∈ V} ∪ {{<u,2>,<v,0>} | <u,v> ∈ E} By contrast, a vernacular English description would look like this: Replace every node in the directed graph with a set of three nodes in a line. Gather all the incoming edges to the first node, and all the outgoing edges to the last node. Every path that visits every node exactly once must reach the middle node by starting at the first node and going through to the last node, and thence to the first node of a corresponding subsequent node, so every Hamiltonian path in the undirected graph is a Hamiltonian path in its directed counterpart. More verbose, yes, but (IMO) easier to grasp.