3 ms·
That's welfare. It's effects are not the same as UBI. Finland has welfare too. The special feature of schemes like UBI and NIT (Negative Income Tax) is that
by nabla9 7y ago
That's welfare. It's effects are not the same as UBI. Finland has welfare too.
The special feature of schemes like UBI and NIT (Negative Income Tax) is that they remove the high effective marginal tax rate from poor people who work.
The problem with conditional welfare payments is that they increase effective marginal tax rate for poor household. The rates are really high 70-100% depending on country and situation.
For example, in Finland effective marginal tax rate for poor person is somewhere between 80-101%. (That 101% is for single parent for low income job). According to Greg Mankiv and others the effective marginal tax rate for the poor can be 70-90 percent in the US.
https://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/10/business/economy/10view.html?_r=1&ref=business https://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/10/business/economy/10view.h...
https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2010/10/greg-mankiws-marginal-tax-rate.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2010/10/gr...
- notahacker 7y agoIt is entirely possible to design welfare schemes with tapers which reduce marginal tax rate. The unique feature of UBI is that it is additionally designed to subsidise economic inactivity.
- nabla9 7y agoIt seems that you are confusing marginal tax rate and effective marginal tax rate. UBI and NIT (Negative Income Tax) are designed to increase incentives. That's why free market economists like Friedman fiercely supported it. Milton Friedman - The Negative Income Tax: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtpgkX588nM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtpgkX588nM
- notahacker 7y agoYou can insert the word 'effective' into my sentence above, and it remains true. It is entirely possible to design tapered benefit withdrawals without resorting to unconditional basic incomes. (It's also theoretically possible to design tax brackets for a UBI/NIT system which imply effective marginal rates at 80%+, though I'm not sure why anyone would actually want to do that)
- nabla9 7y ago> design tapered benefit withdrawals Tapered benefit withdrawals are the exact reason for high effective marginal tax rate. You can't use them. You can design welfare system effective marginal tax rate decreases smoothly, but you can't make it linear. (unless you make the taxation incredibly complex and effectively same as UBI/NTI)
- notahacker 7y agoThe question then becomes whether a perfectly linear marginal tax rate is actually optimal in real world conditions [and if so, whether it's sufficiently optimal to warrant subsidising 8 million economically inactive people in order to encourage some of the 250k Jobseekers Allowance claimants out of their welfare trap] In the real world [i] the effective marginal tax rate in for a UBI imposed in contemporary society is still going to be very steep (UK subsistence UBI ~£10k per year, median UK taxpayer under current system has a taxable income of ~£22k per year and many people on sub-median incomes are net taxpayers) and [ii] the conditionality of a benefit is a pretty strong reason to take a job, high effective marginal tax rate or not