3 ms·
It seems that each generation of programmers at some point comes to this epiphany that a lot of things that they're doing are repetitive enough that they ought
by int_19h 7y ago
It seems that each generation of programmers at some point comes to this epiphany that a lot of things that they're doing are repetitive enough that they ought to be doable by non-programmers, if you just come up with a way to glue those common things together easily. That was the story behind "4th generation" programming languages, for example; and to some extent, behind RAD.
Every attempt so far produced many technologies that died very fast, and a few (e.g. SQL) that survived long enough to become a natural and useful part of the landscape - but even that part still requires programmers to tend to it. When non-programmers try to use that tooling, the result rarely works well; and in those few cases when it does, it's rarely maintainable anyway.
- jimbob45 7y agoRAD died because it could only cover 98% of business needs and idiot managers thought they needed a language to deal with 100% and so threw away really great tools. I could fully foresee VB making a comeback in the future.
- int_19h 7y agoRAD never really died, we just stopped calling it that. But open Visual Studio today, and create a new Windows XAML app, then open the form designer. You can still drag a button from the toolbox, move it around, then double-click it to wire up an event handler - exactly like it was in VB6. In fact, it's quite possible to ignore all the modern stuff like data bindings entirely, and just manually read and update all widgets, as a typical VB/Delphi app did.
- benibela 7y agoA typical Delphi app might have done that, but a selling point of Delphi was that it had data binding. Connect the TDB* vies to a TDataSource, and it would show the values of a database, without requiring manual updates.
- int_19h 7y agoVB6 and WinForms also had data binding. But in practice I've rarely seen it used, except for data grids.
- mattmanser 7y agoWPF has databinding available today, it's not gone away. https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/desktop-wpf/data/data-binding-overview https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/desktop-wpf/data/dat...
- int_19h 7y agoFor WPF, data binding is idiomatic. It wasn't back in those days. My point is basically that the tooling that we use for desktop UI development is still very much rooted in the RAD era - but as best practices around it changed, we dropped the "RAD" label. It was a gradual evolution, though.