6 ms·
There's another factor at play in these discussions: Cynicism tends to look smart to outside observers. Cynicism is often mistaken for competence to outside ob
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
There's another factor at play in these discussions: Cynicism tends to look smart to outside observers.
Cynicism is often mistaken for competence to outside observers. If a piece of software has a specific problem, the person chanting "This software is garbage" is going to look smarter than the people saying "Hold on, maybe this software is this way for a reason".
There are various (somewhat weak) studies on the topic. For example: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29993325 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29993325
> Four studies showed that laypeople tend to believe in cynical individuals' cognitive superiority. A further three studies based on the data of about 200,000 individuals from 30 countries debunked these lay beliefs as illusionary by revealing that cynical (vs. less cynical) individuals generally do worse on cognitive ability and academic competency tasks. Cross-cultural analyses showed that competent individuals held contingent attitudes and endorsed cynicism only if it was warranted in a given sociocultural environment. Less competent individuals embraced cynicism unconditionally, suggesting that-at low levels of competence-holding a cynical worldview might represent an adaptive default strategy to avoid the potential costs of falling prey to others' cunning.
In toxic and mismanaged environments, being a cynic from the sidelines can be a better political strategy than being the positive person in the trenches trying to find solutions and compromises.
- TheOperator 7y agoReading that study cynicism was essentially defined as "low trust in others" and competence was ability in a handful of cognitively intensive tasks.
- Hokusai 7y agoCynism also has the advantage that no solution needs to be provided, so you are never wrong. > In toxic and mismanaged environments, being a cynic from the sidelines can be a better political strategy than being the positive person in the trenches trying to find solutions and compromises. Yes. In the best awesome places I have worked, there are great constructive discussions on how to solve problems. If anyone is an environment that cynism is rewarded, run from there. There are better places to be.
- abnry 7y ago>If anyone is an environment that cynism is rewarded, run from there. There are better places to be. This is why I quit Twitter.
- cutemonster 7y agoQuit the app? (Or quit the company as an employee?) Curious about Mastodon, if that's possibly a different experience
- abnry 7y agoQuit the app as a user. It wasn't a platform thing, in terms of technical aspects although there is probably something to be said about how it shapes community, but it was the community itself.
- root_axis 7y agoIntersting. In my anecdotal experience cynics tend to speak in a very confident matter-of-fact tone that suggests others are fools for not embracing the cynical perspective. I imagine this gives cynicism an edge because people don't like to be perceived as too gullible or naive.
- grahamburger 7y agoI have found that this can be a dangerous gamble on the part of the cynic. Often the cynic's argument can't even withstand a single clarifying question. The first person to ask "can you explain in detail why this won't work?" can often elevate themselves above the level of the cynic, sometimes humiliating the cynic in the process. I have experienced this from both perspectives and as a bystander. Today I try as much as I can to be the problem-solver instead of the cynic. I try to do it in a way that gives the cynic a way to save face, though - it's almost never a good strategy to humiliate a team member.
- zimpenfish 7y ago> The first person to ask "can you explain in detail why this won't work?" Unfortunately, in some forums, that often leads to that person suffering a barrage of negativity whilst the cynic ignores the question in favour of blustering elsewhere.
- tilolebo 7y agoExactly, someone else will just pop in the thread and post a provocative/insulting GIF/pic, and that's it, you'll have lost the argument. I'm looking at you, Twitter...
- mewpmewp2 7y agoI think the same thing is going on with the commentary on economy currently. Whenever I browse around Reddit for example the comments that get upvoted are the cynical ones, "markets are irrational", "feds are pumping up the stocks" etc, but they do not put any real thought into what is happening with the markets and why.
- gerland 7y agoThat's a bit off-topic, but what do you think is happening? I'm considering buying some s&p500 based stock, but I'm a bit afraid. What do you, anonymous stranger on the interweb think?
- mewpmewp2 7y agoI have many thoughts on this topic, I'm not an expert and many of these are theories up with so the may also be flat out wrong, but I just disagree with the sentiment that markets are irrational or it's just feds pumping up the stock. I think saying those things is dismissive and anti-intellectual. When I'm trying to think about the subject and whether I should invest myself, I'm trying to figure out what are the actual consequences of coronavirus long term and what in general are investor's motivations. Here are few assumptions I make: 1. Stock price is determined by an umbrella of possible consequences and chances for each consequence. These are just examples, but for example there might be 30% chance that we can manage coronavirus while reopening the economy, +50% chances that we will have a vaccine in 1 year period that we can mass-produce etc. For each of those consequences we can think of an appropriate SP500 price (I'm taking SP500 here as an example, but it could be any other index as well). If economy goes back to normal, the SP500 price could go to 3400 again. Investors will try to predict what are the odds and in total stock price should reflect what investors on average think the odds of something to happen are. 2. The way investors react to these possible consequences comes from that specific investor's expectations and long term strategy. It's important to know what is average investors expectations and risk tolerance. If SP500 is 2200 (which it was when people were expecting it to go to 1700) and you expect 90% of chances of SP500 going back to 3400 within 3 years you can determine that you have 90% chances of making 54% returns within 3 years which is crazy good. So at this point it makes sense for most investors to buy in, because even if it goes lower, you will still be making very good returns. Now that SP is at 2800-2900 I think it's still better to buy in than not, but you can't obviously expect as fantastic returns. I bought in and even with a little bit margin, but I have enough margin left to buy in more if stock should fall. I'm investing and looking at least 5-10 years ahead. So it makes sense for investors to buy in now that they are not crippled by fears of what coronavirus might do - it's already quite clear it's not the end of the world even if it might shake up economy further throughout this year. 3. There are possibly some positive long term effects of coronavirus. Increased productivity, tech and automation from having been forced to experiment with WFH etc. I think all of these might increase productivity. I'm speaking of those not to just sound optimistic, but these are something a lot of people don't mention. These are just rough thoughts I have right now, but in conclusion I have decided to buy in since I have determined that in 3-7 years there are very high chances of making very decent returns. I doubt corona can affect us for that long timeframe. Of course it's more risky than usual to buy in right now so if you have low risk tolerance it's up to you. If you possibly need that cash within 1-3 years, then maybe not buy in, but whether you should buy in right now should be determined with when you want to use that money and how much you are willing to risk. Usually more risk means more reward since only people who can handle that risk will be buying (so stocks will be more underpriced when there's more risk and uncertainty). And since I don't want to use that money before 5 years anyway, for me it definitely makes sense to take that risk. Also even if stocks fall just after you bought in you must be able to handle that and not think you did the wrong thing and sell. You likely wouldn't be able to sell in time anyway. Many people are fearful right now which means a lot of people are holding cash or shorting. Once fear subsides, stock will start to climb faster again so you should want to be in before general fear subsides..
- eeZah7Ux 7y agoYou are confusing cynicism with expressing criticism. They are 100% orthogonal.