3 ms·
> I have a feeling it'll also sway MacOS DAW users to take a closer look at just what Linux has to offer pro audio users I'm sorry but I just don't see this ha
by rvz 7y ago
> I have a feeling it'll also sway MacOS DAW users to take a closer look at just what Linux has to offer pro audio users
I'm sorry but I just don't see this happening anytime soon. Linux distros like this don't have the mindshare that Windows and macOS already have and these users still use the proprietary software like GarageBand, Logic Pro, FL Studio, Reason and Omnisphere. And no, wine doesn't count for them.
'Professional Audio Users' won't bother with a Linux distro that doesn't have 'official support' for their existing proprietary setup if they were to attempt to migrate. If they're lucky to get exactly everything running on their unsupported system via Wine on their chosen distro, plugging in their favourite hardware should better recognise it or not crash Wine. The moment one of those issues occurs, they'll go back to macOS or Windows and will be staying there for a long time.
Also, one needs to define 'Linux support' in terms of DAW software.
- fit2rule 7y agoI have 15 years of experience running Ubuntu Studio professionally, and 20+ years doing pro audio with other platforms. I'm currently producing/engineering in a high end studio loaded with all the latest high end gear, and I stand by my statement: Ubuntu Studio is clearly a viable, professional platform now. I've done a ton of work with this, and its a rock solid and highly stable DAW platform. More so than MacOS' recent Catalina clusterfuck .. and light years ahead of Windows' headaches. Sure, its not the hype-intensive candy land of Windows/MacOS, but then again .. that's the point, entirely. From the get-go, Ubuntu Studio packs an amazing punch - just installed, out of the box, there's more happening in this OS as a DAW than on either MacOS or Windows, and even after a fresh install of either of those options, you'd still need to spend hundreds of bucks on programs and plugins just to match what Ubuntu Studio offers. Plus, go through all the hassles of installation, iLok, free plugin installation nightmares, etc. You'd be surprised just how great things are, out of the box, if you'd just get over your prejudice about it not being 'mainstream' enough to support your ideals for what constitutes 'professional' DAW usage. I run REAPER and have tons of VST plugins from my Windows DAW onboard the Ubuntu Studio rig - they just plain work. Sure, it doesn't get the attention it deserves from pro audio developers - but that is changing. Lots of devs are seeing Ubuntu Studio rise in the scene. And this is only going to improve with this inclusion of KDE ..
- mnm1 7y agoTotally agree. It doesn't matter how well Ubuntu studio runs, it doesn't have the right apps. And likely never will. Wine is a non starter. And the stability of such a system is generally unproven as many vsts have no official Linux support. I'd love to try it if fl studio or reason or similar had a Linux port. Or Linux had an audio app that could compare; it doesn't. Until then, there's nothing compelling.
- fit2rule 7y agoYou're pretty much off the mark, on every single point: 1) Most Windows VST .DLL's run just fine, unless copy protected - and even then, iLok can be made to work. You won't have a Catalina-level catastrophe on your hands, either. 2) Apps: This is the entire point of Ubuntu Studio - once done with an installation, you have an amazing suite of apps to try out, without requiring further installation/sourcing. Multiple DAW apps are available: Ardour, Rosegarden, Bitwig Studio, QTractor, LMMS, Audacity, Renoise, Tracktion Waveform, ZRythm, Radium - and even REAPER (one of the best DAW's in existence) is Linux-native now. 3) FL Studio runs great under Wine and there is no reason not to run it that way. It is quite stable and has not crashed on me, ever, after years of use. LMMS is also a viable alternative to FL Studio too, also very stable. 4) Ardour is excellent, and so is Harrison Mixbus and XDubber. There are many amazing new-generation apps which are available in Linux native versions, too - see for example VCVRack, which performs better on Linux than it does on my Windows DAW ..
- mnm1 7y agoYou're completely missing the point. It's fine for amateur, non-live, non-critical work. But just because it works for you, it doesn't mean the software is stable. Hell, KDE itself (at least the kubuntu version) is not very stable so I doubt this version of ubuntu studio will be either. And suggesting to run VSTs on an unsupported OS or FL Studio under wine is likewise fine for amateur, non-live performance mode. For everything else, it's tempting fate especially when your desktop environment crashes when displaying the desktop number after switching desktops (one of many, many issues that cause kde to crash, lock up etc.).