4 ms·
The Price of Covid Freedom May Be Eternal Spying
- troughway 7y agoThe language used in this article is written with a soft authoritarian tone. It’s a nice gesture of Bloomberg to put shills for his wet dreams in the opinion section, but the advocacy of surveillance state by the big media is becoming obvious. I can’t speak for HN or the mods, but I do wonder if there are subjects that are not worth discussing because of how undemocratic and liberty infringing they are. Case in point, anything that uses the language and examples like this “opinion” piece to hem around a “means justify the ends” rhetoric. They (media, governments, billionaires) will use any and all means to gain more control, power, and minimize potential leakers, whistleblowers, usurpers and anyone who disagrees with their rule.
- alphabettsy 7y agoYour comment sounds deeply conspiratorial, especially towards the end. I’d argue that there are more pieces in the media bringing light to the rampant privacy abuses in tech than advocating for greater surveillance. The writer says: “The bottom line: Where they exist, robust institutions could still offer resistance. In most other places, the individual’s autonomy has already become a virus casualty. Poorer countries where consumers have only recently started going online will see states insist on devices that come with pre-loaded tracking apps. More information will reside on central servers than epidemiologists have asked for or need. But who will stop the juggernaut?” So I’m not sure I agree that he’s advocating that the ends justify the means.
- gentleman11 7y agoThe media follows trends and advises what is popular. People are scared now, so almost all the media attention I am seeing is pro spying right now when it comes to Covid. 6 months ago, it was different. It’s not a conspiracy, it’s market incentives
- alphabettsy 7y agoThat might be true or it might be confirmation bias. I’ve seen mostly stories warning about the potential for abuse of some of the proposed solutions. Then again it might be my own bias seeing that.
- gentleman11 7y agoIt’s probably our respective filter bubbles, which is a whole other problem
- goldforever 7y agoYeah, its your own bias seeing that!
- keenmaster 7y agoWould you be in favor of such "authoritarian" measures if COVID-19 had a 15% fatality rate, affected the young just as much as the old, and three of your extended family members + 20 friends/acquaintances died? If the answer is yes, then our differences lie in the value you place on human life rather than our relative support for "authoritarianism." COVID tracing apps are about as authoritarian as forcing open your neighbor's door and violating his personal sovereignty by saving him from a house fire.
- gentleman11 7y agoExcept you don’t know whether the neighbours house isn’t on fire, so you had better go in just in case. And while you are there, take an inventory of everything you find, record the data forever for unknown future purposes, and then never leave. It is not a valid comparison.
- keenmaster 7y agoA more precise analogy on my part would have illustrated negative externalities. I am partially reliant on you for my safety. Even if I do everything I can to protect myself and others from the virus, you still put me at risk if you don't do the same. No one will compel you to opt into COVID tracing. You can purchase a non-iOS/Android phone. That would be a reasonable price to pay for forsaking a valuable public safety measure. Moreover, grocery stores and other businesses should be free to require proof that someone has a COVID-tracing device before entering the premises.
- sfj 7y ago> I am partially reliant on you for my safety. Even if I do everything I can to protect myself and others from the virus, you still put me at risk if you don't do the same. People put other people at risk by driving. Heck, a big tree in a public place is a risk due to the potential for falling limbs. Are you against those things, too? This whole argument seems to be about the people who feel vulnerable to the disease having to go to grocery stores to get food. If the government would supply clean food to those people, it would seem that we'd no longer have to metaphorically lock everyone in chains in order to save the few.
- smitty1e 7y ago> I can’t speak for HN or the mods, but I do wonder if there are subjects that are not worth discussing because of how undemocratic and liberty infringing they are. That's counter-intuitive. If liberty matters, it would seem that raising concerns is key. If HN readers are a self-selecting tech elite, who is more likely to suggest the ideas that are worth pursuing?
- greenonions 7y agoIn response to the article, it most certainly will be. The loss of privacy allows states to compete through coordination that otherwise isn't possible. Consider that the United States' disposition to privacy has contributed to the less effective response to the pandemic. Does the US gain an equivalent amount of competitiveness for the vulnerabilities that privacy allows? Are decisions even being considered with regard to this trade-off? I'm probably biased because I have enjoyed the benefits of privacy my whole life, but is it possible that the US is in general placing too high value on privacy?
- scottlocklin 7y agoPeople who write pro-totalitarian surveillance hellscape articles like this should definitely be placed on some kind of list.
- greenonions 7y agoNot only is the article not 'pro-totalitarian surveillance hellscape', but ironically, placing people on lists for articles they write is. edit: grammar
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- alphabettsy 7y agoI’m hoping your comment is meant to be sarcasm, otherwise it’s the ultimate irony talking about putting people on lists.
- redis_mlc 7y agoYou can't fight nature. One word: herd immunity.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoLike we have for all the other coronaviruses that we know as (a big part of) common cold?
- TaylorSwift 7y ago"...life, liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness." It's why saving lives are the most important, even at the expense of liberty and your happiness. Without life, the other two wouldn't exist.
- encom 7y agoNonsense. "Life", in this context, refers to your right not to have your life taken by the state. You don't have a right to be safe from all harm.