3 ms·
Are you sure testing capacity went up? I don't recall reading about that.
by watwut 7y ago
Are you sure testing capacity went up? I don't recall reading about that.
- tomjakubowski 7y agoIt's definitely up since early March. It's likely that testing capacity has been the limiting factor on case count for most of this time.
- asplake 7y agoIt’s very clear in the charts shown in the UK daily press conference. Positive tests in hospitals declining steadily, other tests (of which there has been a massive increase) making up the difference. What that says about what has actually been happening in the community is hard to say.
- chasd00 7y agothis is ridiculous, of course testing has gone up. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wsj.com/amp/articles/coronavirus-latest-news-05-09-2020-11589015996 https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wsj.com/amp/articles/corona... pay attention to hospitalizations. that metric is disconnected from the new cases and expanded testing relationship.
- Scipio_Afri 7y agoPercentage positive is disconnected from testing increases. It shows if you're catching more cases because you're testing more or if the true rate of infection is actually the same or decreasing. It still has sample bias - which depends on the availability and criteria for testing someone. As soon as hospitals start allowing elective surgeries again hospitalizations become less of an indicator and you have to go by "suspected" or "confirmed tested" covid hospitalizations.
- dkfjdkfjda 7y agoI don't think it's entirely disconnected. It'd be disconnected if you had samples that are comparable (ideally random, representative of the population), but that's not the case in most countries. When you start with very limited testing capacity, you prioritize "important" groups of people that are often at higher risk of infection (healthcare workers, older people, ...) so you can expect higher percentage of people to test positive. But as you increase the capacity / number of tests, the sample structure will change - people with lower risk of infection will get tested, so it's natural to expect the percentage positive to decrease.
- orangecat 7y agoDaily tests have increased over the last several weeks: https://covidtracking.com/data/us-daily https://covidtracking.com/data/us-daily
- Scipio_Afri 7y agoYes but the percentage of positive tests accounts for the increase in testing rates. Positive tests divided by total tests. If percent positive of all tests is the same as before then the infection rate is not decreasing, or increasing - its constant. That is the case in many areas although some are seeing decreases or increases. E.g. some are increasing (e.g. Maine, South Dakota), some are decreasing (e.g. NYC, NJ), some are constant (e.g. DC/MD/VA have been constantly at 20% positive for the last couple of weeks now). Most states are looking for a decreasing rate of positive tests for two weeks especially of its the percent positive case is under 10%. Generally under 10% is considered under control or manageable by experts.
- joshuamorton 7y agoThis isn't correct. Tests aren't given randomly. They're rationed and given only to the most at risk people. As testing capacity increases, tests can be given to groups who are less likely to be infected. So at first tests were basically only given to people who had multiple symptoms, to be sure. Now you can get a test in my area if you're asymptomatic but working at a job that requires you to come into contact with other people. If the percent positive of all tests is constant even as you test more people, that means that even as you test less obviously symptomatic people, the number of infected is constant, which could mean the infection rate is going up. Or not, but it's not certain that it's complex. > Generally under 10% is considered under control or manageable by experts. Can you cite this?
- Scipio_Afri 7y ago"There's no exact number to aim for, but here's a guiding principle: You want a low percentage of your tests to come back positive, around 10% or even lower, says William Hanage, an epidemiologist at Harvard." https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/04/22/840526338/is-the-u-s-testing-enough-for-covid-19-as-debate-rages-on-heres-how-to-know https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/04/22/8405263... There are several other sources out there that state that for example the WHO also recommended it as a guideline. Yes not everyone is being tested but the 10% does account to some degree of the "severity" of those being tested. If you're only able to test the most likely cases you'll get a much higher % positive.
- greglindahl 7y agoThat's an interesting question, and the answer is now discussed daily in most news conferences about the pandemic. Asking interesting questions is good. Asking commonly answered questions is...