5 ms·
Leaving Spellcheck Enabled Is a Privacy Risk (2016)
- detaro 7y ago(2016)
- code_duck 7y agoHave any of the relevant issues changed since 2016?
- detaro 7y agoFor one, Chrome Apps for non-ChromeOS aren't a thing anymore. Also, it's customary to add that notice on HN regardless of how timeless the content is.
- code_duck 7y agoYes, of course the year is always there if it's not this year. What I mean is to that this same insecurity principle could apply to other situations.
- SteveNuts 7y agoWhat about things like spotlight? If I work in healthcare and I search for "Jane Doe medical records.txt" does part or all of that search end up hitting a webservice somewhere?
- palijer 7y agoYou can use an SSL proxy/snooper to find out. I use Charles to see what is actually happening at that level, you would be surprised (or not) at how much stuff is sent to third parties. https://www.charlesproxy.com/ https://www.charlesproxy.com/
- scalableUnicon 7y agoThat used to be straight forward, but now most of the apps come with certificate pinning and for seeing through network request, toying with tools Frida are now needed.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoCan certificate pinning be defeated?
- tedivm 7y agoIt's not something I'd expect your average user to be able to do, but it is possible and is regularly done for various reverse engineering purposes. The approach I've seen involve changing what certificate is pinned to one that is locally controlled. That being said I don't think it's nearly as common for certificate pinning to be present as people think- in fact it was deprecated in 2017 because it caused so many problems. Instead things like HSTS and transparency logs are used to prevent damage from malicious issuance of certificates, and organizations can typically override things with their own CA. If your software is pinned to a specific certificate (even if that certificate is a root CA) your software won't work in many corporate environments. One of the exact reasons mentioned- medical data- is a big driver in this. My company has APIs used by medical companies, and they have to whitelist our service in their firewalls because many of them MITM all traffic to ensure that PHI isn't sent out over an unapproved service by mistake.
- jrochkind1 7y agoIt is kind of "hilarious" that enterprises are defeating the ability of a client to prevent a MiTM eavesdropper on the net, for the sake of ensuring privacy of transmitted data.
- jtl999 7y ago> in fact it was deprecated in 2017 because it caused so many problems. Instead things like HSTS and transparency logs are used to prevent damage from malicious issuance of certificates, and organizations can typically override things with their own CA. Still kinda salty that pinning was deprecated from HTTPS. It wasn't perfect (accidental/malicious pinning was far too easy seeing how it was merely controlled by an HTTP header), but the current alternatives (Certificate Transparency, CAA DNS records) aren't an adequate replacement. Sure Certificate Transparency helps to detect a misused certificate, but it doesn't actively prevent it from being used, and CAA requires that the CA isn't "lying" about the header through a "bug" or otherwise.
- sneak 7y agoBy default on iOS every single search in the app search pane hits the web, character by character. That and iCloud Backup are the first two things I disable on a vanilla iOS.
- HenryBemis 7y agoFun fact. iCloud backup "conveniently" records all phone history (calls, text messages). And maybe the authorities cannot get into your phone (debatable) but Apple always gives them your backups (warrant+gag order). And that includes ALL call logs and ALL your SMS and iMessages.
- snazz 7y agoI'm not condoning Apple's decision to not perform end-to-end encryption on iCloud backups, but they would be pretty useless if they didn't include call logs and text messages. If I lose my phone and restore from a backup on a new one, I want my old text messages as much as any other piece of data.
- grawprog 7y agoGoogle, not that I typically support things they do, found a way to do both: https://support.google.com/googleone/answer/9149304?co=GENIE.Platform%3DAndroid&hl=en https://support.google.com/googleone/answer/9149304?co=GENIE... As far as I know, appleid's have some kind of password/authentication system that could be used to encrypt backups.
- dubcanada 7y agoIt doesn't say it stores text messages? It says it stores text messages on Android which means they are not backed up. It also says you use Android messenger which hooks up to Google's services. The text messages have to be stored somewhere.
- yencabulator 7y ago
- rovr138 7y agoBy default, yes.
- qwerty456127 7y agoAFAIK leaving the text translation feature enabled (even if you disable for a particular language) is even more of a risk.
- londons_explore 7y agoText translation in Chrome doesn't send anything to Google servers unless you actually translate a page. It detects what language the page is written in with an entirely client side model (which is why it's accuracy is poor).
- lynndotpy 7y agoI don't believe Signal Desktop runs as a Chrome app anymore, can anyone confirm?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gentleman11 7y agoIs this a chrome/electron only issue, or is it OS level as well? What about Firefox?
- livre 7y agoChrome issue, you can disable it in the settings page.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mirimir 7y agoThe title ought to include "in Signal", or more generally, "in apps that use online dictionaries". I always disable that. And it's easy to check; just test with no uplink. Also, misspelling is a profiling risk.
- joecool1029 7y agoTitle of submission should be: 'Leaving spellcheck Enabled On Chrome Is a Privacy Risk'. In the spirit of trying to do constructive discussion, the original post references the long dead Signal Chrome app. The new desktop garbage they push is a Node.js app called Signal Desktop. They use native spellchecking provided by Node and Hunspell (even on Windows, which could use native windows API available for 8 and newer and which probably is privacy violating) To the best of my knowledge, Hunspell is privacy conscious software. EDIT: Additional context, https://github.com/electron-userland/electron-spellchecker https://github.com/electron-userland/electron-spellchecker also confirms it only uses Hunspell on windows.
- lihaciudaniel 7y agoThank you this will help anyone with paranoia of being watched.
- MereInterest 7y agoThe conspiracy theorist in me thinks that Google deliberately makes Chrome's offline spell check be as poor as possible, to give people incentive to give all text to them under the guise of spellchecking. It seems like every day or so, there will be some common word that is marked as misspelled, usually a plural or possessive form of a word that is in their spellcheck dictionary. The developer in me thinks that this is because nobody at Google cares about the experience if the user chooses incrementally slightly more privacy, and so it simply gets no attention.